2 ms·
Speaking of Apple, you know the only reason webkit and chromium are open source? It's because it was built off the (L)GPL. If it was BSD/MIT then webkit would h
by flukus 10y ago
Speaking of Apple, you know the only reason webkit and chromium are open source? It's because it was built off the (L)GPL. If it was BSD/MIT then webkit would have been completely closed. That means no Chrome and no electron (well maybe that's a good thing).
> But over time, a lot of the sting has been taken out of that, as corporations have seen the long-term advantages to open source in helping them avoid another firm's lock-in and network effects.
And what about when you can sell it, like with a closed sourced android that is locked in to google?
- Nomentatus 10y agoYou are dead wrong. Blink was the re-creation of webkit; one more GPL license that wasted everyone's time and money by forcing a full rewrite, one more tragedy. The Android libraries (as opposed to Java engine, app store, etc) that Google recreated are open source, and not locked in to Google, many others use them. It's not reasonable to hope to banish proprietary code entirely, especially since open source hasn't really found a good, general business model yet. Open source code that businesses will use and contribute to is winning the day; GPL has been a bad wrong-turn. Again, copyleft might work - but the software and hardware patent grabs that come with GPL2 and GPL3 simply haven't. Such an incredible waste. It's hard to find historical parallels.
- flukus 10y ago> You are dead wrong. Blink was the re-creation of webkit; one more GPL license that wasted everyone's time and money by forcing a full rewrite, one more tragedy. Blink is a fork of webkit, it's still under the LGPL. But I see where you've gone wrong now, you're attributing every OSS rewrite that also includes a license change to being rewritten because of licensing, which is simply not true. Without webkit being LGPL though, they never would have got to the point where they could fork it. > It's not reasonable to hope to banish proprietary code entirely, especially since open source hasn't really found a good, general business model yet. Open source code that businesses will use and contribute to is winning the day; GPL has been a bad wrong-turn. The GPL doesn't banish proprietary software and never will. It banishes GPL software from becoming closed software.
- Nomentatus 10y agoFalse, but this has been argued elsewhere in the forums, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blink_(web_engine) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blink_(web_engine) to see it does have a BSD license.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> It's because it was built off the (L)GPL. If it was BSD/MIT then webkit would have been completely closed. That means no Chrome and no electron (well maybe that's a good thing). The interests that led Google to make Chrome would still have existed, though it probably would have been a downstream adaptation of Firefox with V8 rather than one of WebKit.