5 ms·
I think it's pretty clear that the author doesn't really understand what "be yourself" means. Or he's using some weird academic/business school definition. It
by Spooky23 10y ago
I think it's pretty clear that the author doesn't really understand what "be yourself" means. Or he's using some weird academic/business school definition.
It doesn't mean that you let your Id rule and disrespect everyone around you. It means to do things natural to you and in line with your instincts.
Have you ever seen a really effective kindergarten teacher? Or salesman? Or engineer? They are naturally inclined to do what they do and have the instincts through education and experience to just do what others need to think about.
The example of the general manager at HP was a great one. Being a genuine and sincere person, even with subordinates is fine in a small setting. But when you're addressing 5000 employees, its formal by necessity and you're not speaking as you -- you're an officer of the company.
I think it's great when people don't try to be someone else. One of the people who I mentored for awhile started out as a real jerk... he almost got fired for attitude. It turned out that he was in the wrong role, an operational, follow the process role that was stifling to him and driving people crazy. We recognized that, got him in a better gig and he shined. If he had sucked it up and marched like a good soldier, I never would have known.
- fersho311 10y ago"Be yourself" would work well on someone like you, a self reflecting individual. Unfortunately, most of the people I know would use "Be yourself" as an excuse to justify their shortcomings (mood swings, laziness, selfishness, etc.)
- HenryBemis 10y agoA friend was "recently" working on one of them "big firms" that had "be yourself" posters plastered all around the place. He soon realized that what they really meant was: be a sociopath, be ruthless, go for blood/glory, be whatever you are (but-not-really-better-go-for-blood-like-the-big-bosses-around-here). Worse part is that they were frequently hosting school children where they were brainwashing 10yo kids to become ruthless blood-thirsty-money-making-drones.. (investing in future generations to pass down the torch!)
- afarrell 10y ago> I think it's pretty clear that the author doesn't really understand what "be yourself" means Well of course. As a phrase, it's meaning isn't clear just from the words in the same way that "give me that pen", "make your bed soon after waking up", or "brush your teeth twice a day" are. All of those scentences are made of phrases and words that have meanings and the meaning of the scentence follows from composing the meanings of its parts. "Be yourself" as a piece of advice has a literal meaning equivalent to "breathe and metabolize"-- a person is by definition themselves. So the phrase must mean something other than it's literal meaning, but what? As an adolescent, the only explanation I ever got was "don't try to be something you're not". The problem here, is that it contradicts so much other advice in your life. As an example, 16-year-old me was a shitty driver. Should I have stopped trying to be so shitty at driving? Of course! The phrase argues against growth in general and I'd seen people use it as an excuse to avoid growth. So 16-year-old me concluded that the advice was meaningless and that the people saying it weren't saying much of anything besides "chill out, relax". But considering who poorly explained it is and how often it is given as grand life advice, it isn't at all surprising to hear someone else take a drastically different meaning from it.
- derefr 10y agoIt's mostly supposed to mean "grow toward (and in the mean-time, fake being) the person you'd be most excited to be if all social knock-on effects were disregarded." Likely, this is a version of yourself improved along all the axes that will most enhance the sense of natural, intuitive engagement you feel when doing the things you love. It can also be phrased more directly as: "don't grow toward (or fake being) a version of yourself that you imagine will benefit you socially, if that hypothetical person does not also feel more engaged with, and excited about, being alive." (Or, in short: if you really love [fun activity] and hate [boring activity], don't pretend to love [boring activity] or hate [fun activity] just to impress someone. Because you'll still love [fun activity] and hate [boring activity], but now you'll be forced to deal with [boring activity] all day while carefully avoiding [fun activity].) ... That being said, this advice is nearly meaningless to children or teenagers, because it really can't mean anything until you 1. know what engages you, and 2. have enough life experience to build an intuition for what sort of things you might grow to love. It's sort of the same as the advice "write what you know": it only means something when you actually know (i.e. have lived through) at least one thing worth writing down.
- epigramx 10y ago> the author doesn't really understand what "be yourself" means. i.e. the problem is that people operate with simplistic mottos. It's how you create dogmatism, ideology and religion.
- cristianpascu 10y agoChristianity might be the best example of a religion created with a simplistic motto writen on an restaurant napkin. Learned that from judaism which used two napkins.
- wolfgke 10y ago> It doesn't mean that you let your Id rule and disrespect everyone around you. It means to do things natural to you and in line with your instincts. > Have you ever seen a really effective kindergarten teacher? Or salesman? Or engineer? They are naturally inclined to do what they do and have the instincts through education and experience to just do what others need to think about. I rather be frank: You identify "use your insticts" with "be yourself". But claiming with your examples this is a good strategy in general means having a trendemous selection bias. Most people simply don't have such insticts - only few people are very empathic, i.e. for many people "use your insticts"/"be yourself" simply leads by definition to problems. For example many "nerds" really "use their insticts"/"be theirselves". The fact that "nerdiness" is considered a bad trait rather falsifies your claim.
- vivekd 10y ago>Have you ever seen a really effective kindergarten teacher? Or salesman? Or engineer? They are naturally inclined to do what they do and have the instincts through education and experience to just do what others need to think about. I disagree, certainly great salespeople, teachers and engineers make what they do seem natural and effortless, but whenever I talk to them I discover that they put a lot of thought, effort and practice into molding themselves until their craft seems natural. In fact, Tom Hopkins, one of the greatest salespeople who has written several sales books told about how he didn't seem like the person who was right for the job, and he was making no sales, but then he decided to research, work and practice until he got good at it. In fact I believe this whole thing about "be yourself" or "be true to yourself" is a bunch of modernest rubbish. There is no "true self" to be true to. We are in control of who we are and we can choose to mold ourselves into the image of what we want to be. We are not at the mercy of some amorphous inner "true self" that this decides for us.
- arcanus 10y ago> make what they do seem natural and effortless, but whenever I talk to them I discover that they put a lot of thought, effort and practice into molding themselves Absolutely. These are trades that require heavy training and hard word. But the essence of the parent comment was that the immense amount of effort required to become proficient in these trades would be insurmountable if not for a deep passion for the subject.
- forgottenpass 10y agoBut the essence of the parent comment was that the immense amount of effort required to become proficient in these trades would be insurmountable if not for a deep passion for the subject. I'm proficient at many things that I hate doing simply out of necessity or profitability. Unless we define "deep passion" to include necessity and finding ways to make ends meet, then it doesn't apply. If we do define it that way "deep passion" proves too much fails to be a useful descriptor. It seems like less of a leap to suggest that we often have the luxury of using choosing our passions to become proficient at.
- 10y ago