3 ms·
How do you feel about structured, graded MOOCs like Harvard's CS50x? I'm also curious about how you feel things like /r/learnprogramming, stackoverflow, and st
by komali2 10y ago
How do you feel about structured, graded MOOCs like Harvard's CS50x?
I'm also curious about how you feel things like /r/learnprogramming, stackoverflow, and stackoverflow IRC can act as surrogates for teachers.
- YZF 10y agoI can't comment on this specific MOOC but I've done MOOCs where there were a lot of quizzes, active forums, extra-curricular activities, and involvement from the course staff (E.g. Dan Ariely's on Coursera). Those are certainly better than just reading a book or watching a video. I think there was still a very high dropout rate. Having any sort of online community certainly helps as well. I've learnt to play the guitar online. I did a couple of music related MOOCs. I use YouTube resources like JustinGuitar and Lick'n'Riff. But I still felt like I needed a real teacher and went and got one. Even though this teacher is probably not at the same level of some of the YouTube "gods" :) I still got a lot out of that.
- ghaff 10y agoIn general, I've found the forums on MOOCs pretty useless other than for dealing with specific technical issues with the course itself. They just don't scale well and there's a huge disparity in the level of the participants a lot of the time. In programming courses, you've got some people asking about some nuance of an algorithm while others aren't sure how to install a text editor. Any course built around having meaningful discussions in the forums has been a tire fire in my experience. Automated code checkers are definitely useful but, other than that, I'm not sure I've found MOOCs much different from watching YouTube videos. Nothing wrong with that--especially with top-flight lecturers--but they're hardly revolutionary. Videos of lectures have pretty much been a solved problem since VCRs went mainstream.
- greenhouse_gas 10y agoHonestly, at this point I found reddit a much nicer place to go then stackoverflow for technical questions. SO users demand that your question be "correct". Note, I didn't mean that it should be clear what your problem is, it's just that if you ask a "noob question", for an explanation, or if five people think it can't be done, you'll get down voted and closed in a second. It's sad because other (smaller) SE sites are quite nice.
- HeavenBanned 10y agoI used to think like you do re: SO. I used to hate it actually, I felt like it detracted from the learning environment prioritizing form over substance. But now I approach it differently: I just create a new dummy account for every new question I have and ask a question following the strict guidelines. I tend to get a response within seconds. And its usually correct. You may say I'm gaming the system, but SO is broken that way. I had a "permanent" account, but it said I had to wait SIX MONTHS before I could ask another question, because my questions were "bad." Interestingly, I have one dead dummy account that had 50 points on it. I had an amazing question about time in C++. I can't transfer those points onto my permanent account, so it was a worthless exercise. But I don't really care. A new dummy account will solve all my problems. Why should I invest in getting better and asking better questions if SO won't reward me for doing so? It just rewards God-tier enterprise code-junkies looking to pad their resumes. I'm just a chum in the ocean looking for my meal. I have no qualms in being a dick to the system. Stack Overflow is terrible because the gamification is terribly implemented. On the one hand you get instantaneous correct responses. On the other hand, if it doesn't have a cherry on top when you ask it, it gets downvoted to oblivion and closed because it's a duplicate (I mean...is it a duplicate if someone can't understand the duplicate?). I don't even know what I think about it anymore. I think Stack Overflow sucks, but I can't live without it.
- aquabib 10y agoThis is incorrect. SO is polluted with "noob" questions and answers, which is why SO is so useless. Google and now even MSDN search results are also polluted with SO hits which are mostly just noise. If anything SO needs more strict moderation.
- digler999 10y ago> SO hits which are mostly just noise. I completely disagree. I'm an experienced dev from C++ learning Android/Java dev. Literally 90% of what I need is on SO (the rest usually from mkyong), thanks to google some of the answers even bubble up to the search page so I dont even have to click on them. I would be much worse off without SO.