12 ms·
Why Is Silicon Valley So Awful to Women?
- username223 10y agoI think most of it can be explained by this: > The percentage of female computer- and information-science majors peaked in 1984, at about 37 percent. It has declined, more or less steadily, ever since. Today it stands at 18 percent. In an environment that's over 80% male, not to mention largely young and/or single, women will have a rough time. I don't think SV is necessarily any worse than any other similar environment (e.g. infantry, oilfield work), but that's not high praise.
- justincormack 10y agoYou don't think to ask why the ratio of women has halved?
- username223 10y agoI do, but I don't have a good answer. Maybe 65/35 is already beyond the cultural tipping point. Maybe women, who are more mature at college age and now make up a sizable majority of the undergrad population, realize that there are better options than tech. It's a bit off-topic, but this old Phil Greenspun article comes to mind: http://philip.greenspun.com/careers/women-in-science http://philip.greenspun.com/careers/women-in-science
- ForHackernews 10y ago> realize that there are better options than tech. What would those be? Tech is relatively easy, relatively highly paid, it involves no hazardous work conditions, and it can be done from almost anywhere in the world with good internet connectivity.
- username223 10y agoTravel nursing, for some people. Instead of putting in hours sitting and staring at a screen (which is somewhat hazardous in the long term), you work a 3-month stint for premium pay, then do whatever you want until you need more money. Or if you like interacting with people more than machines, sales and marketing are universal skills that are always in demand.
- flukus 10y agoIsn't that a question for women? Why haven't their number increased as much as men during the same period? My best guess is that it's due to social pressures from other women about being geeky and nothing to do with men.
- jrnichols 10y ago"In an environment that's over 80% male, not to mention largely young and/or single, women will have a rough time." I wonder if we ask the same questions about men in female dominated careers such as nursing, and ones where men have almost been driven out of, like K-12 education.
- DanBC 10y ago>I wonder if we ask the same questions about men in female dominated careers such as nursing, and ones where men have almost been driven out of, like K-12 education. This has been mentioned many times on HN. Yes, there are programmes to get more men into teaching young people, and into nursing. (Also more women into mining and construction).
- jrnichols 10y agoOh. Sorry. I've never seen it mentioned here. also: I had no idea there was even a down vote button on HN.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tabeth 10y agoThe answer is obvious: it's bias. I'll never forget the day I removed my picture from my LinkedIn profile and the amount of random spam I received increase substantially. People don't like the answer, but there's only one: anonymity. Any other solution simply changes who will be discriminated against.
- jbhatab 10y agoI honestly don't understand how someone can be sexist. I have never thought lesser of the people I've worked with because of gender. I don't know if this is too personal but would you mind talking with me to explain what it's like. ive worked work many females in the past with no issues besides personalities. I just want to really understand and empathize. feel free to reach out at jbhatab@gmail.com if youd be so kind
- ed_balls 10y agoI'm above the average looking guy. When I added my picture to LinkedIn the amount of spam increased substantially. People are really biased creatures. Usually the intent is not malicious, but rather caused by tribalism, evolution, empathy, mirror neurons etc. One example is ageism, which is actually a systematic bias. For examplem to be a president you have be 35 or older. Let's imagine we created a perfect candidate in a lab which is 29. She's creme de la creme. And we have abolished this law. No dice. She would not win.
- oconnor663 10y agoWhether or not anonymity would change the "fairness" of the outcome, it's not at all clear that it would change the outcome itself: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_bias_on_Wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_bias_on_Wikipedia
- tabeth 10y agoThe goal is not to change the outcome, the goal is to remove bias. If the outcome is the same under perfect anonymity, then so be it.
- flukus 10y ago
- jdietrich 10y agoI don't have a dog in this fight, but this is a clear case of begging the question. Is Silicon Valley really awful to women? Do we have any comparative data that suggests that SV is any more sexist than most industries? I hear a lot of unpleasant anecdotes, but very little data. I think that the answer to this question is very important. If we operate on the presumption that SV is uniquely awful, then we may be looking for solutions to sexism in all the wrong places.
- sdflkd 10y agoWhere does it say it's uniquely awful instead of simply awful? If you read the article there is data too, btw.
- darawk 10y agoThe question implies it. The question "why is silicon valley so awful to women" implies that it is uniquely so, otherwise the question would be "why are men so awful to women", or "why is corporate america so awful to women".
- eli 10y agoSV is objectively worse than corporate America as a whole... But that doesn't really matter. Tech has a problem and other industries also having problems -- maybe even worse problems! -- doesn't excuse it. This is fixable, but it starts with acknowledging it exists.
- darawk 10y agoThat's an interesting theory. The question though is whether or not it is true. It certainly could be true. But it could also be that SV is more self-critical, and so we hear about it more. It could also be that we (denizens of HN, that is) are in SV (in the broad sense of 'tech') and therefore more aware of its shortcomings. And it could also be that it is in fact more hostile to women. In the absence of data, we simply don't know.
- throwawaysbdi 10y agoI don't get why this isn't obvious. Software is seen as the wild west of engineering. Exciting, competitive, reckless, sometimes brutal. It's like Wall Street, selling cars, working oilfields. The popular perception has been fuelled by megafounders who struck gold, becoming the richest people in the world by their mid 20's. SV is in a 40 gold rush for the next big thing and it doesn't seem to be slowing down. For all sorts of reasons that have been beaten to death, most women won't stick around in such a field. For gender balance to return in our lifetimes software engineering would need to lose much of the existing culture
- nazka 10y agoBut what does it have to do with gender? Yes SV is highly competitive but are we in a place where it's common for men to put down women just because of that?? It seems extrem to me.
- bsder 10y agoIt isn't. If you want horror stories, ask lots of intelligent women from western Pennsylvania why they are now sitting in Silicon Valley. There is a big difference between a couple of socially inept brogrammers making shitty comments and every single relative asking you why you're planning to go to college instead of getting pregnant like your sister.
- eli 10y agoSexism elsewhere doesn't make sexism in SV ok.
- viraptor 10y agoYou're not saying SV isn't awful with this comment. You're just saying western Pennsylvania is awful as well. It's not like it's some kind of a race to the bottom.
- bsder 10y agoI am adjusting your level of "awful". "Awful" is going into court 3 times because the court couldn't get your house title right because you are married but didn't take your husband's last name. "Awful" is being told you don't need a scholarship because you're just going to get pregnant anyway. "Awful" is being a female in Japan who felt that suicide was her only option because if she got fired she was never going to get another job. Does Silicon Valley need work on fairness? Yeah, on a lot of fronts. However, almost all of them are malfunctions of "power". Trump wasn't grabbing pussies because he's in Silicon Valley. It's not specific to sexism, and it's not specific to Silicon Valley. It's about the fact that the powerful feel they can abuse their position.
- viraptor 10y agoNot sure I understand. Why do you want to adjust my level of awful? It's not like we've got to prioritise - they're different areas. It's not like we have to solve one to solve the other - the are problems that can be addressed at the same time. They're both awful situations in their local context. I don't think we need to have a race or classification between those, unless they lead to difference in how we approach them. If it's just to say this is more awful than that... what's the point?
- TheLilHipster 10y ago> Why is [Insert location of choice] So Awful to Male Babysitters? Culture and everything else that comes along with gender minority work environments. You adapt, like everyone else. The push for institutionally enforced advantages is just insane: > “Tying bonuses to diversity outcomes signals that diversity is something the company cares about and thinks is important,” Equal opportunity does not mean equal outcome. Giving a minority share an unfair advantage in the market just because "they're a minority" is not progress. I'm so disappointed at how manipulative these sorts of ideals are in reality. Their proponent's hearts are in the right place, but the outcomes are just so backwards. Regardless of your gender, if you're in an environment and you're discriminated against in an illegal way, go through the appropriate legal channels and crush it. Stop wasting our time trying to police culture. /rant
- rayiner 10y agoIf there is not equality of outcome, then either: (1) no equality of opportunity exists; or (2) there is some confounding factor. Ironically, you identify the thing that creates unequal opportunity: the "culture" that "comes along with gender minority work environments." Men have the opportunity to go into programming and be in a culture that is not stacked against them. Women don't. That's not equality of opportunity. Acknowledging that the existence of a gender disparity in and of itself creates a hostile culture for the minority gets you halfway to understanding why attempts at eliminating the disparity directly are justified. And such measures are inherently temporary: once you eliminate then disparity that creates the hostile culture, you eliminate the need to take any affirmative measures to keep the new ratio. You also precisely identify why you can't fix past institutional discrimination simply by no longer doing it. The past discrimination creates a culture that's hostile to the minority gender. That culture is self-perpetuating without active intervention (the "policing" you complain of).
- TheLilHipster 10y ago> Men have the opportunity to go into programming and be in a culture that is not stacked against them. Women don't. That's not equality of opportunity. Depends where you define the line between opportunity and outcome. You could take a step back and argue that equal opportunity exists in the education space for both women and men to thrive in said field. The fact that this doesn't result in a 50/50 split in gender in the market is an indicator to me that the cause isn't institutional, it's cultural. You can't police culture and you shouldn't be trying to police the outcomes of a "free market". I appreciate your perspective, but I think you've honed in on symptoms, not the cause. If the cause is institutional, fix it 100%. All hands on board, sign me up. If its cultural - adapt. Cultures will also adapt in-time to the individuals that make up said culture.
- supercanuck 10y agoBecause Silicon Valley can't even agree there is a problem. Just look at this thread of all the people whining for more data on this supposed "problem". Some of the folks won't be happy until there are secret Amazon Echo's tabulating all the shitty comments and passive aggression in every office or emails being scanned and categorized for domineering and condescension. and even then you'll get a bunch of "correlation doesn't equal causation, dummy!"
- et-al 10y agoThis. When a minority group is consistently saying there is a problem, one should probably question their existing beliefs and wonder if they don't see it due to some sort of bias. And it's fine to be wrong, to not have see it. However, take an honest chance to listen. Not debate. Listen. For a bunch of smarter-than-average folks here, we're still susceptible to groupthink.
- saosebastiao 10y agoIt's called death by a thousand control variables. If only the data controlled for {education, hours worked, experience, attractiveness, nail color, booger density} then you'll see no effect... Except by then, the whole analysis becomes a charade. When you try all the possible combinations of variables and then stop the moment you find one that rejects the null hypothesis, your analysis isn't objective... it is predetermined.
- alexssung 10y agoI've never heard of death by a thousand control variables. What's exactly wrong with data controlled by relevant variables such as education, hours worked, and experience? If you find a combination of variables that reject the hypothesis, maybe you should look further into it, no? Dismissing it because you think it's not objective for some absurd reason is rather unscientific. "Trying all possible combinations of variables" does not disqualify an analysis from being objective--not sure where you got that idea from.
- saosebastiao 10y ago
- Spooky23 10y agoIMO the reason is that most IT wasn't really engineering until fairly recently. Back in the 90s, which weren't long ago, you could make a ton of money without really knowing anything at all. Nowadays those people are senior leaders. So they do what people do in these situations: gather the tribe. (Aka old boys network) More than in any other line of business that I have seen, IT has lots of old school ethnic and cultural fiefdoms. Bro guys, various south asian groups, school alumni, etc. The places I have worked at that had more women in technology also had fewer of these networks. Look at the story about the dude stealing tech from Google, starting a fake company to get bought out by his pals at Uber. In what other industry is bullshit like that even possible!
- pascalxus 10y ago>“Workplace conditions, a lack of access to key creative roles, and a sense of feeling stalled” are the main reasons women leave tech. Based on what I've seen over the last 10 years working at a variety of software companies: both men and women get mistreated, roughly equally, at least at the places I've worked. People often assume the reason they are being mistreated is due to some factor of themselves (race, gender, etc), but this is the fundamental attribution fallacy (see social pyschology) that colors our perceptions. But, i haven't worked at every company. Perhaps, there are some where egregious conditions do exist, as mentioned in the article. As long as the talent oversupply exists, it will be hard for men & women affected by these adverse conditions to move to companies with better cultures.
- itsdrewmiller 10y agoBut women are leaving at a higher rate than men. And if you look at the diversity stats that come out it is usually the case that women are less represented in management than even tech, which suggests their complaints about access/stalling may be more correct in aggregate.
- wry_discontent 10y agoThere was an article a while back (I can't link it right now because I'm in mobile) that showed that even when they masked voices, women did worse in programming interviews. The problem? They didn't bounce back from failure as well as men did. They failed and quit, while the men continued to fail until they had success. How can you know this isn't a similar effect?
- wry_discontent 10y agohttps://blog.interviewing.io/we-built-voice-modulation-to-mask-gender-in-technical-interviews-heres-what-happened/ https://blog.interviewing.io/we-built-voice-modulation-to-ma... This is the article I mentioned.
- pottersbasilisk 10y ago
- mybrid 10y agoEngineers are aholes. How the negativity manifests itself is different between genders but the fact remains, Engineers are aholes. Nonstop, 24/7. As a software contractor I interview more than most I can tell interview horror stories that will peel paint. Has little to do with my gender though. Key man is common problem in the valley. Some person makes themselves a key man in the company and then reign down holy hell on everyone around them. This scenario plays out every day in Silicon Valley. The point is the problem is much larger than just how women are treated, but how people are treated. If you can't take the heat get out of the kitchen is the mind set. Its a dog-eat-dog world and I'm wearing Milkbone shorts, as they comedian quipped. Root cause is not gender specific. Root cause is mean people in general. Mean people are going to be mean people, independent of gender. It doesn't help that Bill Gates, Steve Balmer, Bill Joy, Scott McNealy, Larry Elison, Steve Jobs are pretty much mean people role model CEOs people understand being mean as necessary. It would be interesting to redo this study and swap being mean for gender as the bias. I have no data but I suspect that being mean is a far bigger factor than gender bias. At a minimum being mean plays a large role and if addressing part of the root cause is not part of the solution then all of the bias related solutions are sure to fall short.
- sudosteph 10y agoIf everyone was respectful then of course the problem would resolve itself. But imagining for a second that the story did somehow manage to get statistics and quantify the "mean"-ness of an individual, there would still be case for sexism being a factor that uniquely impacts women more negatively. For example, many people are somewhat "mean" but 1. Are these people only mean to women? 2. Are they "meaner" to women than men? 3. Are they mean in different ways to women? (ie, sexual harassment is usually only towards women) Interesting thoughts though. I wonder though if emphasizing a more radically respectful culture in general would make a difference. It would definitely curb the resentment that men feel over stuff like diversity hiring goals, but without data, we do not know if it would meaningfully make women and minorities experiences any better.
- candiodari 10y agoSilicon Valley is awful to many groups. From Spanish speakers, to non-homeowner natives, to women. I feel like maybe we ought to give some attention to the situation of the masses of Spanish speakers in the bay area. They're certainly facing far worse than women in tech companies, and it's a much more fundamental problem.
- sudosteph 10y agoEveryone saying "SV isn't worse than X" is missing the point of the article. Yes, we know plenty of industries are more awful. The point is that SV talks a big game when it comes to taking care of workers (high pay, perks, unlimited vacation), but doesn't always walk the walk when it comes to improving the treatment of female or minority workers. Relevant quote: > That the tech industry would prove so hostile to women is more than a little counterintuitive. Silicon Valley is populated with progressive, hyper-educated people who talk a lot about making the world better. It’s also a young field, with none of the history of, say, law or medicine, where women were long denied spots in graduate schools intended for “breadwinning men.”
- steeef 10y agoquote from "Snowcrash": > “It was, of course, nothing more than sexism, the especially virulent type espoused by male techies who sincerely believe that they are too smart to be sexists.”
- HoppedUpMenace 10y agoEveryone has a bias, plain and simple. You don't overcome the bias with programs or incentives, it takes a fundamental change of attitude among the people perpetuating the bias. Its something that should be acknowledged and pointed out but not forced down people's throats.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- flukus 10y agoWhat about when it's the culture of minorities that is the problem? Who are you to say that there culture has to change?
- bobdole1234 10y agoOh, you're racist.
- ue_ 10y agoCan you give an example please?
- flukus 10y agoStrongly anti-intelectual cultures that put no emphasis on kids achieving at school. I think many urban black communities would be an example of this.
- tabeth 10y agoSo you're basically victim blaming?
- flukus 10y agoYes, with the distinction that they're (often) victims of themselves. There has been plenty of poor, alienated groups throughout recent history. Irish, asians, jews, post WW europeans, vietnamese, balkan refugees. They all reverted to the mean (some above) in a generation or two, so at what point do you consider that there may be something different with this particular group that they've been unable to do that? In the same way you can't blame silicon valley for the lack of women when their simply aren't enough coming through to get close to 50% employment. It's not SV discriminating against women, it's women choosing not to go into comp sci. Now here we are, telling women and minorities that they made the wrong decision, as though they're helpless individuals that can't decide for themselves.
- 10y ago
- convolvatron 10y agook, just to start let me acknowledge that sexism is pervasive in tech as well as elsewhere. but maybe Silicon Valley is awful to everyone. the reality distortion field that sustains the notion that these people are special, in fact gods among men, twists the normal social contract into something unrecognizable. put that in the context of a fairly sexist society, add a healthy dose of people who are in tech because they couldn't hack it in the normal world, and voila
- mrkabuki 10y agoBecause women bitch a lot and feel entitled because they're a minority. Most women in tech are also unfit for their work.
- Main_ 10y agoI was watching the "Silicon Valley" TV show and was surprised how women are presented. Whether they are coders or non-tech, the theme went like this: Women who Code: always ask fellow men for help with their coding skills or just appear to not know what they were doing. Present them as sex objects, where men are thinking of them just for sex Women who can't code: generally presented either as stupid, dumb or as assistants of men who knew better. It seem that Hollywood is also complicit in presenting women as sex object. But I wasn't sure if this really is the truth about the culture in general in SV.
- prostoalex 10y ago> Women who Code: always ask fellow men for help with their coding skills or just appear to not know what they were doing. Present them as sex objects, where men are thinking of them just for sex Carla played by http://www.hbo.com/silicon-valley/cast-and-crew/alice-wetterlund/index.html http://www.hbo.com/silicon-valley/cast-and-crew/alice-wetter... was a prominent woman coder with none of what you described exhibited. Granted, I can't think of any other female coding characters on that show. Did you mean the HBO "Silicon Valley" show or a Bravo TV series with the same name (later re-branded "Start-Ups")?
- Main_ 10y agoI meant the HBO one. I didn't see Carla yet, I'm in season 1 still. But so far it's not really women friendly.
- A1phab3t 10y agoAre any of the commenters on this thread female? I read or skimmed every comment up to this moment, and every single one sounds like it's written by a male. Perhaps I'm silly but I feel a female commenting here would have mentioned their experience-- and nobody so far does as far as I could tell.
- mgarfias 10y agoCuz geeks are often assholes.