3 ms·
I am not a lawyer, take this advice with a large grain of salt. From what I understand: Your lawyer is technically correct, but possibly being overly conservat
by WorldMaker 10y ago
I am not a lawyer, take this advice with a large grain of salt.
From what I understand: Your lawyer is technically correct, but possibly being overly conservative/risk-averse about it, which is the job of a good lawyer. If you trust your working relationship with your lawyer, trust your lawyers advice on this and find a way to meet your lawyer somewhere in the middle.
First of all, ordinary trademarks are no longer registered (the TM symbol is kind of unregulated at this point and only really as effective as you can prove in a court case that you've used it longer and it isn't just a generic word; you arguably don't even need to use the TM symbol itself these days). I'd say that I see a lot more TM than (R) trademarks most days, but on writing that am actually not all that certain.
If you are registering a trademark, you are registering the (R) symbol variant remains stricter about what may be registered and how. (In exchange for being harder to register and stricter in its registration you get stronger protections in court.)
If you look at examples of continued (R) usage you will find a few of the particularly older, more conservative brands do go to great pains to avoid even being used as a adjectives (they don't want to be used as real words at all) and are often "X(R) brand product" like "Kleenex(R)Brand Tissues". (Kleenex is one that is particularly conservative on this front as a lot of people do use Kleenex as a generic noun and they have been in danger of losing their trademark over the years because of that. http://kleenex.com http://kleenex.com is littered with "Brand Product" speak.)
You could probably get away with not registering your trademark at all, as most startups seem to do. If you do want to register, you should probably follow your lawyer's advice, even if it does feel particularly out of date or overly conservative/risk-averse.
Hope that helps.
- ready_to_launch 10y agoThanks for your thoughts on this! We've already registered the mark -- the application was approved by the USPTO, but there's just one last step of proving that we're actively using the mark in commerce (since otherwise it's "use it or lose it"). You make a great point about risk-averse advice being good lawyerly advice. I guess where that starts to chafe a bit for me is when the risk-averse advice also runs counter to the industry standard. It seems odd to defy industry standards in a detrimental way in the name of safety. Shouldn't following industry standards be safe enough? As noted in a prior comment, I don't see Adobe exclusively saying "Adobe® Photoshop® software" in the copy on their marketing site... they just say "Photoshop." So why can't we do that? It would be extremely awkward to do it the other way. You may be right that we could be stuck doing it the outdated/awkward way if we want the (R), but I'm hoping that is not the case! Somehow other (R) owners have avoided this problem... fingers crossed that we can as well. It was just such odd and surprising advice to receive from him today, that I was wondering if any other startups had waded these waters.
- WorldMaker 10y agoIt's interesting that you bring that up as Adobe is another one fighting to keep their trademark versus an increasing generic usage of it. Their own press kit requires that they do require the press to exclusively write "Adobe(R) Photoshop(R) software": http://www.adobe.com/aboutadobe/pressroom/pressmaterials/pdfs/photoshop_guidelines_pr.pdf http://www.adobe.com/aboutadobe/pressroom/pressmaterials/pdf... I don't know why their own website is more lax on the subject and not held to same standards (as opposed to Kleenex's site, for example, which is). I suppose that is a question for Adobe's lawyers. (I further suppose that is an ongoing battle between Adobe's marketing department and its lawyers and probably the lawyers are shaking their heads in disgust sometimes at their own marketing website.) «Shouldn't following industry standards be safe enough?» Maybe? We seem to be a pendulum swing where marketing copy is more relaxed/conversational and drops TM and (R) marks and is more lax with their restrictions. This seems to me probably because there hasn't been a very high profile trademark dispute in recent internet memory, so the risk seems low and the trade-off of being more friendly/approachable/conversational in marketing copy seems worth the risk. That pendulum swings with your competition. You need to know your competition and assuage the risk that they might want to genericize your trademark for their own competitive advantage. How much you need to do to protect your marks is probably some complicated formula of what you expect from your competition, what it is you are actually protecting, and how much effort you think may be needed to defend it in a court of law. Particularly to that last part, you likely want to defer to the risk aversion of your lawyer, presuming that lawyer is going to be the one helping you defend the trademarks in the court. Adobe (and Microsoft and some of the other "conversational marketing" trademarks) have a fair number of lawyers on staff and a "war chest" of one sort or another in assets they can deploy to defend their trademarks. As a startup you likely don't have anywhere near those resources, so having a long conversation with your lawyer about what marks you may need to defend, against whom, and deeply assess the risk. There may be a compromise position where a conversational marketing site is accompanied by a more formal press/PR site, which may be more than enough proof that you are using the mark in commerce. There's also a case that your competition doesn't care about your trademarks at all and there isn't any risk and you don't need to play it safe (or even have registered trademarks at all). You are in the best position to determine your risk and your lawyer is your best professional asset to work with on figuring that out. If you think that your lawyer is being too risk-adverse you might seek other lawyers' opinions, especially a specialist in trademark disputes, but be prepared to pay for that. In that case you probably also need to be prepared to pay for that specialist's time in the case of a defense of your marks, too.