3 ms·
Not that I don't mind giving Brooks a good lashing, for I too "Now and then I don’t mind David Brooks’ columns at the NYT" (heck, he wrote one in the last month
by hga 16y ago
Not that I don't mind giving Brooks a good lashing, for I too "Now and then I don’t mind David Brooks’ columns at the NYT" (heck, he wrote one in the last month that was better than OK :-), but isn't this sort of the reverse pattern of posting, in that the essay on how people who don't have a clue about complexity ritually invoke it as a "thumb-sucking, multisyllabic way of saying something is hard" as Kedrosky puts it?
I'd go further, pointing out e.g.:
The success of D-Day/Operation Overlord and a lot of other complex stuff that no one person could understand. We have proven techniques for dealing with these sorts of things. Would that our ruling class of social engineers that includes him be a fraction as good at dealing with their complex problems.
Tree Mile Island is a poor example as he uses it: "In the first place, people have trouble imagining how small failings can combine to lead to catastrophic disasters. At the Three Mile Island nuclear facility, a series of small systems happened to fail at the same time."
Well, I'm sure this is true, but the people who count in this, the designers of the reactor, imagined it and e.g. included a conic spreader at the bottom of the reactor vessel to allow for a serious core melt-down. Which is the worst case that indeed happened and that the system they designed contained, as they planned. No China Syndrome in the real world (in the US, at least).
I continued to analyze this essay, but it's, say, 80% bogus and not worth the trouble of debunking in detail. Let's just say that when he closes by saying we live in an "imponderably complex technical society", he's mostly revealing that Sons of Mary like him can't ponder it. Sons of Martha like us can make a lot of sense of it and we will continue to do so.