6 ms·
I notice this theme again and again in every "change yourself" book, show, class, lecture. Be it weight loss, improving mental health, curing addiction, becomin
by komali2 10y ago
I notice this theme again and again in every "change yourself" book, show, class, lecture. Be it weight loss, improving mental health, curing addiction, becoming a better writer/photographer/programmer, the theme all comes down to a battle against yourself. Fighting the desire to snack, fighting the desire to lay on the couch instead of going to the gym, fighting the desire to veg and watch netflix instead of watching another lecture in the MOOC you're taking.
You'd think it'd be easier to control ourselves. I have trouble understanding how we can want something, but some other part of us can seem to not want that thing, or just be extremely short sighted to the point of being an obstacle to our "long-sighted self."
- nybblet 10y ago"The Master said, 'The prosecution of learning may be compared to what may happen in raising a mound. If there want but one basket of earth to complete the work and I stop, the stopping is my own work. It may be compared to throwing down the earth on the level ground. Though but one basketful is thrown at a time, the advancing with it is my own going forward.'" (The Analects, translated by Legge)
- techbio 10y agoI agree, and similarly long to simply think myself to where (I think) I'd like to be. Learning though, by it's very nature, means fixing what's wrong or implanting knowledge in place where one is "not even wrong". If it were easier it would be of less value. The supply is more limited than the demand.
- simonh 10y agoThe more I think about it and learn about the functioning of the brain, the less I believe in the unitary 'self'. I once read the suggestion that what we think of as the 'self' is really just the brain's public relations department.
- SamBoogieNYC 10y agoYou might enjoy a book called Quantum Psychology (Robert Anton Wilson). He lays out some interesting concepts about the way we think and one thought experiment in particular, observing all the 'thinkers' within and how they can multiply at will i.e consider the following innocuous statement: "I observe that I am happy" Who is happy and who is the observer?
- mistermann 10y agoEckhart Tolle may say the observer is your conscience and who is happy is your mind. That's a guess though. :)
- lazyant 10y agoI call it the "executive summary", basically we "are" a PowerPoint presentation of our brains.
- twic 10y agoI picked that idea up from Greg Egan's short story 'Mister Volition': http://greg-egan.wikia.com/wiki/Mister_Volition http://greg-egan.wikia.com/wiki/Mister_Volition
- Filligree 10y agoApologies for the unrelated comment, but I saw one of yours from three months ago: > Is it 'Into Darkness' that has the idea of a space where you can only move forwards, not sideways? This sounds like that mixed with the rigorous alternative physics of the Clockwork Rocket series. ...and that sounds like my kind of book, but googling only gives Star Trek links. Can you tell me the author?
- Filligree 10y agoFound it...
- ChemicalWarfare 10y agotakes will + effort to fight entropy. "your self" in this case is just a manifestation of a physical entropy-prone world that you are dealing with. some of that is pre-programmed or instilled by the circumstance, anything above and beyond that requires additional effort that might seem like it's applied at "fighting yourself".
- BeetleB 10y ago>Be it weight loss, improving mental health, curing addiction, becoming a better writer/photographer/programmer, the theme all comes down to a battle against yourself. Most of them say that, but a few say the wiser thing: Prevention is king. If you don't get addicted to something, it causes fewer problems. This applies to both physical and mental addictions. Don't let your body get used to fatty foods, and there will be nothing to fight. Same goes for alcohol. Or tobacco. Or TV binging: I've been relatively cable-free for well over a decade. >fighting the desire to veg and watch netflix instead of watching another lecture in the MOOC you're taking. Amusingly, I have to fight the desire to take yet another MOOC. I'm addicted to information/knowledge. I absorb it easily. Retaining the information, and actually utilizing it takes a lot of work. For me, taking another MOOC is just a way of slacking off to avoid putting in the effort to apply those skills I keep "learning".
- hackuser 10y ago> the theme all comes down to a battle against yourself Perhaps "control" and "battle" are the wrong model. Some broad, general suggestions based on what experts have said: Respect yourself: If you are doing something over and over again despite not wanting to, there probably is a good reason for it, a legitimate healthy need, even if the expression of that need is unhealthy. Respect that need and its priority as legitimate and serious. Find a healthy, productive way to address it. It should be no surprise that the response is unhealthy: Imagine if someone else had a real need and your response was to ignore it and abuse them constantly for acting on it; how would that person behave? Know yourself: Know your strengths and limits; don't put yourself in position to fail and then abuse yourself for failing. Again, imagine you were someone else's manager, you knew their limitations, and yet you kept putting them in position to fail and then abused them over the results. That would be a horrible failure of management, not of the employee. Have compassion for yourself. Like every human ever to live, you also will live your whole life with serious flaws. Nurture yourself: Work together (so to speak) for change. That's how real change happens; that's how good parents, good teachers and mentors, and good managers accomplish things. Fighting with people just entrenches the problem. .... That feels a little too ... bullsh*tty to post - loose, imprecise ideas with little serious foundation included; my apologies. But I'm not sure how to tighten it up, don't have links at my fingertips, and posting it seems better than not.
- thegeomaster 10y agoI like this. Very well put. However, I can't seem to be able to make a connection with the examples your parent comment mentioned. For example, if you want to lose weight but keep eating fast food despite that---what is the healthy need manifesting through that, and how do you address it in some other, good way? Same with being addicted to e.g. alcohol or smoking.
- naasking 10y ago> For example, if you want to lose weight but keep eating fast food despite that---what is the healthy need manifesting through that, and how do you address it in some other, good way? If it's not a nutritional deficiency, then perhaps it's a snacking habit, so maybe switch to nuts, sunflower seeds or fruit. The habit starts losing its power when you're no longer flooding yourself with high doses of sugar and/or salt, which is where the habit's positive reinforcement comes from.
- prodmerc 10y agoIt's the animal side vs you, the consciousness. The animal side is happy with eating, shitting, sleeping, fucking, pointing and laughing at funny stuff, punching other people and things. You, on the other hand, are trapped inside this animal and want quite different things. It's a constant struggle.
- wamatt 10y ago> I have trouble understanding how we can want something, but some other part of us can seem to not want that thing Humans typically associate themselves (ie 'you'), as a distinct thing in reality, rather than a group of competing agents.
- plainOldText 10y agoSpeaking about battling ourselves: I recently started questioning whether we're truly free – as in, do we have complete control over the decisions we're making. There are certain things about ourselves we simply can't control, such as our parents, where we were born/raised, our genetic makeup, the structure of our brains, etc, and these things highly influence our decision making. So it looks like there is constant battle between who we want to be and who we truly are.
- dsbmac 10y agoThere's a whole eastern philosophy around this sort of sentiment. The idea being that things aren't inherently 'anything' but we do attach emotions or ideas to those things. You can take a 'meta' step back and notice this.
- ClassyJacket 10y agoI agree. I find it amazing how unfocused the human mind can be, but at the same time am not really surprised given how we evolved. I also have somewhat of a pragmatic view of solving this problem. Anecdotal, but since I started taking the antidepressant Valdoxan (aka Agolmelatine, sadly illegal in the US) I've found that I feel it's easier to win that battle. When I say I'm going to do or not do something, I'm more likely to stick to that. I've finally, for example, gone to my parent's house and not binge eaten on my mum's generous cooking. I went to the bar and actually had two drinks instead of six. I haven't taken them, but I also understand that there may be some other medications such as AHDH or concentration drugs that have a similar effect, possibly with different time scales and mechanisms. I'm still a total coffee addict - haven't kicked that one yet - and I'm by no means perfect. But my self control was pretty much non existent before, and in the last two months I've made alot of progress. I hope that we continue to find better ways of managing the brain's chemistry (and the side effects of doing so), but just as much that the methods we have now become more widely available, and less illegal and stigmatized.
- pasquinelli 10y agoI think of it like this: I want to lay on the couch, not go to the gym, but I want to want to go to the gym, or I want to have gone to the gym. I want to have gone to the gym because I hate to be at the gym. Realizing that, I have a choice: is going to the gym a chore, like flossing my teeth to avoid tooth pain or taking out the garbage so I'm not living in garbage? that is, is going to the gym something I do even though I don't want to, and which I needn't pretend to like? or should I just admit that i hate the gym and find something else to do?
- GarvielLoken 10y agoBut you don't need the gym, for losing weight or getting healthier. The only thing you need the gym for is getting big muscles, now you can reframe the question. Is my goal to be more healthy or getting ripped? If the goal is health then you can stop going to the gym. Start running, start swimming, try bicycle, outdoor gyms, join a hike group, join a martial art club. Start doing excersices at home with your body weight. If you are so weak or big that you can't do many bodyweight drills, then you don't need a gym anyway. Better served with a small 10$ dumbar package at home. The only thing that can be good with a gym is a Personal Trainer that can give you a good plan. It will be hard to replace that service to the same level. If your goal truly is to be more muscular, then and only then does it really become a question of motivation. Do i want this enough do go to the gym, even on the days that i don't feel for it?
- agumonkey 10y agoFor some places, not having a car is already a free health increase. Walking regularly is free "healthcare".
- agumonkey 10y agoThat's the nice thing about chaotic wild life. Your life depends on every day gymnastic and it's often quite a pleasure to feel alive and full. We distorded the game too much it seems. Unless the VR trend provides a healthy dose of entertaining physical activity.
- mleonhard 10y agoVipassana meditation has helped me to increase discipline and self-control. Since taking a 10-day course, I finally got control of my snacking urges and my emotional health has drastically improved. http://dhamma.org/ http://dhamma.org/