4 ms·
I don't fault Tynt for creating this service; it's actually a bit clever. I reserve all my blame for the websites that actually use this service.
by wvenable 16y ago
I don't fault Tynt for creating this service; it's actually a bit clever. I reserve all my blame for the websites that actually use this service.
- benmathes 16y agoWait, what? There's plenty of blame to go around, here. Blame the websites that decide to screw their users, but also blame a company who makes a product that screws users.
- probablycorey 16y agoHow is it screwing you? At most it is a minor inconvenience.
- benmathes 16y agoMy copy buffer is my copy buffer, and a fundamental aspect of computer interaction. It does not belong to The New Yorker or Techcrunch.
- Kadin 16y agoThat's a good point and I agree, but why then do browsers let this sort of crap happen? Why do they allow JavaScript to modify what gets copied to the copy buffer, rather than just copying whatever you happen to select from the rendered page? I can't think of any good reason why that functionality should be allowed. The copy buffer should be as off-limits to the JavaScript VM as the contents of my hard drive. So while the developers of this "feature" and the websites that implement it are partially to blame, I think there's a flaw in browsers that's allowing them to do it in the first place. There aren't nearly enough fine-grained controls over JavaScript in modern browsers, given the really obnoxious shit that's beginning to be done with it (JS-based popups and popovers). Browser developers have left an opening for abuse and, particularly with the last decade-plus of WWW development in the rear-view mirror, we shouldn't be surprised when it gets abused in really user-hostile ways.
- daleharvey 16y agobrowsers dont have access to the clipboard, but they should do for the same reason word, spreadsheets, photoshop, ..., every other major desktop application do have access. This is a core piece of functionality that is a major part of building usable applications. yes they can be abused, you can make red text on a green background, or phish someones bank about and steal thousands using this technology, banning it isnt the solution.
- chc 16y agoWhy do operating systems let this crap happen? If a Web application mustn't put things on the clipboard, surely that applies to programs not written in Javascript as well. The idea that Web browsers shouldn't allow Javascript to do hardly anything is a large reason why the Web's "open platform" is getting kicked around like an empty can by closed platforms.
- raganwald 16y agoConsider this bit of 'cleverness:" Encode music CDs with a Windows rootkit that prevents copying of unencrypted music from said CDs, phones home, and otherwise helps 'protect music owner's IP from piracy.' Do we not fault the creator and instead fault the companies that buy it? Here's a horse I have been beating for several decades: "Fault" or "Blame" does not obey the laws of conservation. Just because we blame Alice for failing to check her blind spot before making a lane change doesn't mean we absolve Bob of fault for ignoring her turn signal. It's reprehensible to make and sell this stuff. It's also self-defeating to buy and deploy it.
- cujo 16y agoTo the car analogy. That's exactly what it means. As a driver I have no obligation to honor your request to change lanes. It is your obligation to decide if moving sideways into my car is the right move. In the above case, and in tynt's they aren't doing anything wrong. It is more analogous to gun control, without the dire consequences of misuse.
- raganwald 16y ago> As a driver I have no obligation to honor your request to change lanes. It is your obligation to decide if moving sideways into my car is the right move. Please don't stick to "the letter of the law" in Ontario. I respect your right to have an opinion about this, but would despair if such a choice resulted in injuries or death. In Ontario we have no-fault insurance for exactly this reason. If you choose not to respect someone else's signal and an accident results, you are both getting dinged for the cost of repairs. Your failure to "drive defensively" is your fault, regardless of the official rules for right-of-way. Fault is only of interest if the police end up laying certain types of criminal charges. You might escape fault if the other driver runs a red and hits you. You will not escape fault if you see another driver signal a lane change and you have time to slow down and allow them to change lanes. If someone changes lanes into you and you had no reasonable chance to react, you're possibly off the hook. But there's really no reason to see someone signal a lane change and bull right through without being very certain that they know you're there and plan to wait for you to proceed.