4 ms·
"He first caught the scent that something was off as an economics student in India, wondering why, despite his mastery of the mathematics and technology of the
by mcguire 10y ago
"He first caught the scent that something was off as an economics student in India, wondering why, despite his mastery of the mathematics and technology of the discipline, the logic always escaped him. Then one day he had an epiphany: the whole thing was “cockeyed from start to finish.” To his amazement, his best teachers agreed. “Then why are we studying economics?” demanded the pupil. “To protect ourselves from the lies of economists,” replied the great economist Joan Robinson."
Well, the first part is kinda true and the second is reasonable.
"Kanth realized that people are not at all like Adam Smith’s homo economicus, a narrowly self-interested agent trucking and bartering through life."
"Narrowly self-interested agent" is a pretty good model. A problem is the prescient, hyper-intelligent part.
"For every benefit we received, there came a new way to pit us against each other."
Because prior to the Enlightenment, everything was rainbows, butterflies, and puppies?
"He notes that when we replace the vital ties of kinship and community with abstract contractual relations [...] we become alienated and depressed in spirit."
Or perhaps we realize that someone who isn't related to us might not be the enemy.
"Kanth points out that the Bushmen do not have a Mars rocket, but they do have a two-and-a-half-day workweek — something that most modern humans can only dream of."
Speaking as someone who would be dead in a hunter-gatherer society, I'm not sure about that. Further:
"Although Sahlins' theory [...] has become a staple of popular anthropology and among alternative medicine aficionados, it has been challenged by a number of scholars in the field of anthropology and archaeology who have found that most hunter-gatherer societies were not in fact "affluent" but suffered from extremely high infant mortality, frequent disease, and perennial warfare. This appears to be true not only of historical foraging cultures, but also prehistoric and primeval ones."[1][8][9][10]
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Original_affluent_society https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Original_affluent_society
[8] Keeley, Lawrence. War Before Civilization
[9] http://johnhawks.net/weblog/reviews/life_history/aging_evolution/hill_2007_hiwi_mortality.html http://johnhawks.net/weblog/reviews/life_history/aging_evolu...
[10] https://condensedscience.wordpress.com/2011/06/28/life-expectancy-in-hunter-gatherers-and-other-groups/ https://condensedscience.wordpress.com/2011/06/28/life-expec...