12 ms·
I am sick to death of hearing "First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win" used as justification for anyone's pet technolo
by jgrahamc 16y ago
I am sick to death of hearing "First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win" used as justification for anyone's pet technology subject always winning.
Just because Eric Raymond cast himself as the Gandhi of the OSS movement and used that quote doesn't mean we should copy him.
- ZeroGravitas 16y agoWell it only really applies if you are ignored, then laughed at, before it becomes an actual fight. Despite his appearance in their ad campaign I don't see many Apple fans considering themselves ignored or laughed at, nor using that as justification for their assured future victory if they are. On the other hand it seems to fit the Christensen disruptive model very well: "The reason big new things sneak by incumbents is that the next big thing always starts out being dismissed as a “toy.”
- ahoyhere 16y agoHow old are you? How's your memory? Before the iPod dominated the market, before Apple's re-ascent to glory was completely undeniable, Mac users were _always_ the butt of jokes.
- cdibona 16y agoActually the first application of that phrase to Linux came well before Eric appeared on the scene. I'd say that I first saw it on a t-shirt for Linux Expo in North Carolina in 97 or 98, and it was being used colloquially well before that. If I were to credit anyone, I'd maybe credit Jon Hall, who used it in his speeches when he was promoting Linux at DEC.
- kalid 16y agoI really dislike that quote too, it's a tautology along the lines of "You keep losing until you win". If you haven't won yet it's because it's just around the corner -- just put up with the ignoring, laughing, fighting a bit longer. Never mind the fact that innumerable technologies were ignored, laughed at, and fought and never won.
- d0mine 16y agoThe quote could be interpreted as a praise of perseverance. And it is not a tautology due to you can prove that perseverance increases/decreases your chances for success. For example, in a casino perseverance is not a good quality unless you cheat (the more you play the more you loose). On the other hand a startup founder might benefit from having this property ("You have to be willing to keep trying new things and refuse to die." http://startup2startup.com/2008/11/25/paulgraham-ycombinator-recap/ http://startup2startup.com/2008/11/25/paulgraham-ycombinator... ).