3 ms·
> ...the false notion that democracy means that ‘my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.’ But this is a necessary consequence of the universal franchis
by throwanem 10y ago
> ...the false notion that democracy means that ‘my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.’
But this is a necessary consequence of the universal franchise. My ignorance has one vote. Your knowledge has one vote. In a system of rule that furnishes us each a vote and values all votes equally, my ignorance and your knowledge are worth exactly the same. In such a system of rule, how can it be otherwise?
- iiii_iivii_iiii 10y agoLet's not forget the two slippery fish in our hands that is other people's "ignorance" and our "knowledge."
- throwanem 10y agoOh, certainly. That's why I didn't swap the person of the pronouns from the quote. As may seem likely from the thrust of my prior comment, I don't favor the universal franchise as a system of rule; it seems to me prone on the one hand to severe corruption as various actors seek to regather the sovereign power which this scheme so atomizes, and on the other hand to precisely the sort of popular enthusiasm which the American founders sought to render harmless, a purpose whose merit the events of the twentieth century do much to demonstrate. Most who espouse such an opinion of universal suffrage seem to imagine it being replaced by a scheme in which they themselves still have some, indeed a much larger, measure of the power to rule. I think this is a mistake; where it isn't a deliberate satisfaction of arrogance, it seems to me prone to encourage that arrogance develop. I'd rather see a scheme in which the practice of rule is the province of those trained and skilled in that very specialized profession. Of course, the problem of competent rule remains, and it's not a simple one - I don't think I could even produce a formal definition, although Singapore seems like a good example in a lot of ways, and perhaps Sweden, or the Nordic countries in general, in some others. In any case, recent history offers little that I can see to suggest that universal suffrage offers a uniquely, or even notably, reliable solution to this problem, either.
- blowski 10y ago> I'd rather see a scheme in which the practice of rule is the province of those trained and skilled in that very specialized profession. Great idea! We can get everybody to vote on who those people are!
- throwanem 10y agoIt's really not a simple problem to solve! But one doesn't need to solve it in order to realize the parallel with, say, a heavily politicized and deeply factional user group voting on who will be the next datacenter admin. And then voting on who should vote on whether the maintenance budget gets approved. And so on.
- blowski 10y agoHow would you feel if Donald Trump removed your right to vote, and then instituted a bunch of experts with whom you viscerally disagree? If you think some people are not educated enough to vote, then persuade them that they need to be educated.
- throwanem 10y agoI'd feel as though nothing of significance had changed. But that's rather beside the point, don't you think? We're arguing the merits of democracy, not those of Mussolini- or Hitler-style dictatorship. While I concede that the one has frequently been seen to lead to the other, I'm not sure that that's in the scope of the conversation at hand, save as a particularly ugly failure mode.
- blowski 10y agoThe only difference I can see between your suggestion and my hypothetical scenario is whether you like the experts in charge. If you advocate for technocracy, you have to accept that you might not like the technocrats who end up in power. When it comes to making policies on things like tax, healthcare, government spending, military intervention, etc, there are no right and wrong answers, just opinions. And often there are equally well-founded opinions that contradict each other. Democracy solves that conundrum by getting both sides to appeal to the 'demos', with universal suffrage defining the demos as (almost) the entire adult population. How would you solve it?