4 ms·
Many of us spend time on various entertainment sites with active content discussions, HN is one of them. And the state of these communities is highly dependent
by wruza 10y ago
Many of us spend time on various entertainment sites with active content discussions, HN is one of them. And the state of these communities is highly dependent on owner's and moderators' power and vision on their evolution. Moderation is a thing that projects an experience on newcomers, who always do the same wrong things, because they are at the beginning of their way to be mature participants.
Otoh, there are few mostly uncontrolled communities that go through newbie hell via some sort of elitism/indifference to them. When you spend few years in these places, you start to see all the patterns — from newbies to almost speechless "old" guys with hardened mental armor. You easily estimate the amount of time your opponent was here (or in similar place) and you see where your discussion goes in terms of "meta". You feel the rotation in that group, because names change, but thoughts remain. You do not need the moderator's help to be able to stay. That's great in a sense, but in fact the community voice consists mostly of immature boys who throw fucks at each other and argue about things that have no real matter.
This resembles the state of the entire programming industry for me. Each year we see new "developers" of various grades ready to fight and produce more complex shit that has no real meaning. Countless new abstractions, conceptions, frameworks, etc that were already invented before their birth, but had no chance to jump in their minds because there is no news with cool design on whatever.io. Really seasoned and experienced guys have no voice in there, because the management consists of the same unprofessional people who delegate everything down. You're using 20-year old technology? Ha-ha, the MODERN way is foobar.js with server-side bazlets, you old loser! You know nothing! Maybe, but your tech is 2 years old, so you can't be experienced in it by definition.
I really wish they all just stop and look around. Technology is already there for decades, you just have to not reinvent it and accept rough edges, because they are there for a reason. Forced moderation of hyped "modern" junk at institution level is also welcome, so mainstream doesn't fall into this madness. Our area is so big that a regular professional starts to understand everything just around the time his career is over. There is nothing smart in it, this is pure insanity. /rant
Edit: word order, typo
- jodrellblank 10y agoTechnology is already there for decades, you just have to not reinvent it and accept rough edges, because they are there for a reason. There isn't just one technology, or one company, or one team, who can sit down and agree to stop. "People like the Amiga, so we're not going to make a competing computer, we're just going to fire everyone and go home" - every other computer company. "People like the iPod, but I can play .au files from my Sun workstation command line, so why doesn't everyone just accept the rough edges?" "rsync works, who needs DropBox anyway?" New technology is invented at least partly because rough edges are horrible, and at least partly because if we (collectively) don't invent stuff, what can we sell? How can we compete with other businesses? Why does anyone write? Shakespeare existed so writing should be over.
- wruza 10y agoAll new shiny things involve learning and making mistakes curve. That should be compared to different brand new languages and sentence construction methods, not different authors. Why doesn't anyone invent new languages? Is english really that good and easy? No, it is horrible in so many ways. But it is known to ~anyone so anyone can learn it and tell whatever they need to whoever they need. No need to complement that with chinese or russian, unless you are both native speakers and have no foreign sides in your business plan. We have at least math and chemistry notations as special cases, though.