4 ms·
Yup. The train is a huge boondoggle, mostly because they are building it backwards. Building the middle part where no one lives is easier and will make a lot
by jedberg 10y ago
Yup. The train is a huge boondoggle, mostly because they are building it backwards. Building the middle part where no one lives is easier and will make a lot of jobs in a lot of poor areas, but then it is just a secret welfare program, not a useful piece of infrastructure. Let's just provide welfare if that's the goal, and then build some useful infrastructure like electrified tracks in the Bay Area and bullet train to Stockton that people might actually ride and then use those fares to pay for the rest of the train.
- ZanyProgrammer 10y agoI think the Central Valley was a giant fait accompli to get the rest of the project funded in case of a political crisis. The prevailing mood in 08-09 was also that CAHSR would be used similarly to the economic stimulus passed by congress. You would think listening to CAHSR blog and their ilk back then that Fresno and Bakersfield were the navel of the world.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Building the middle part where no one lives is easier and will make a lot of jobs in a lot of poor areas The planned initial operating segment has one endpoint in the third largest city in the state, and passes through the fifth largest city in the state, so the idea that it's in a place where no one lives is, well, what recently has become known as an "alternative fact".
- jedberg 10y agoActually you're the one pedaling in alternative facts. The initial operating segment was going to be Stockton to Fresno until people complained about how stupid that was, and then they added San Jose.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> The initial operating segment was going to be Stockton to Fresno until people complained about how stupid that was, and then they added San Jose. Since we're discussing how the existing project is being built and is planned to be operated, and not historical plans that have been rejected as suboptimal, that would be irrelevant in any case. It's also, AFAICT, not true; in both the final 2014 Business Plan with the Merced to Burbank IOS, and the draft 2016 Business Plan (they are done in even numbered years) which shifted to the San Jose to Bakersfield IOS, Stockton was not only not part of the IOS, but not even part of the Phase 1 SF-to-LA plan, only the Phase 2 expansion to Sacramento and San Diego, which is more of a vague concept than a concrete plan.)
- caf 10y agoGiven that government bond rates are virtually zero, it would seem to make more economic sense to issue bonds to pay for construction rather than using operating income from an earlier segment.
- Johnny555 10y agobuilding the middle part where no one lives is easier and will make a lot of jobs in a lot of poor areas It will make a lot of temporary jobs -- and transient workers will come from hundreds of miles away to work on the project and will leave when it's done so many of the jobs won't directly benefit local residents. Small towns will see a brief increase in business during the construction, then it'll die away, along with the small businesses that sprung up to support it.