4 ms·
Mick Jagger on Music Profits
- jswinghammer 16y agoI recall that some people did make a lot of money on record sales. It just depended on your deal. The Beach Boys owned the copyrights to their songs and that probably contributed to their financial success. They seemed to be very wealthy and didn't have a huge succession of number one hits but a few number ones and a lot of successful singles and records. Most people in that business make no money though from what I've seen. I have to believe that some of the more successful artists and bands that I listen to do alright (e.g. Belle & Sebastian, Arcade Fire, Brian Eno, Neko Case, etc.). Maybe I assume that because I can't imagine them working a job.
- retube 16y agoMaybe he's exaggerating when he says "no-one got paid". The point is though, then and now, that only a very small number of artists really make money from record sales. The smaller artists have always had to support themselves with gigging and touring. Artists have been kicking up a fuss because maybe they see piracy as a barrier to their big cash in. the reality is, i would suggest, that they wouldn't be cashing in anyway.
- joubert 16y agoEven the megastars tour & concert. Isn't it because musicians are performers / entertainers? Making albums only is probably not enough (emotional) reward.
- inerte 16y agoYes, people like appreciation and a crowd of thousands screaming/moving/kissing side by side with your creation is a very rewarding experience. Plus, the sex :) PS: I only played at small, local bars... so for me it's more like my mom, 5 friends, and some free beers.
- tibbon 16y agoThere's a pretty big difference between really cashing in and not having to work a day job. I know several musicians who are full time professionals, but none of them are 'rich'. Even ones with a Grammy hanging on their wall aren't well off like Microsoft's first N employees. The bigger your band also the harder it will be for everyone to make a living (Arcade Fire vs Brian Eno).
- michael_dorfman 16y ago"It just depended on your deal" is a bit misleading, I think. I don't know (anecdotally) of anybody who got a good deal from a record company prior to 1970 or so, as Mick points out. The fraud and coercion reported by most artists is mind-boggling; artists were fleeced as a rule.
- mattmaroon 16y agoFor most of human history, waterborne diseases were our number #1 killer. Still are in many parts of the world. Then we got indoor plumbing. The point is, I don't want to go back. The fact that something has existed for only a short period of time on a cosmic scale does not mean that it cannot or should not exist forever. I like music, and as such would like to see artists remain profitable, even after the demise of the CD.
- davidjairala 16y agoI don't think he's advocating for artists not to remain profitable; I think he's referring to the fact that most artists have had to tour to make some serious money off their music.
- mattmaroon 16y agoAgain though, just because it's (almost) always been that way doesn't mean it should be going forward. FWIW I don't even disagree that it should be that way, I'm simply saying that one should never use the argument "because that's the way it's always been done" to justify anything.
- alanthonyc 16y agoI'll counter your poor analogy with my own poor analogy: for most of human history, we existed without the use of oil or its byproducts. Then we got plastics. I don't want to back to a world without plastics. Or we could review the argument on its own merits. For a short period of time, circumstances prevailed in which a small number of artists (skills ranging from acceptable through excellent) were able to make an outsize profit from their work. This looks like its coming to an end. The era of multi-dozen million dollar making artists like Michael Jackson, U2 and Madonna is giving way to an era where artists make a good, but not GDP comparable income, like Amanda Palmer and OK Go.
- mattmaroon 16y agoIt wasn't an argument that Mick Jagger made though, so there's nothing to review based on merits. It was a simple statement of fact. Any argument is by implication (ie. that because it was not always this way, it should not be that way). There was no discussion of how much artists should make at all, and any implication of such is suffering from the logical fallacy that because things have always been a certain way, that is the way they should be in the future.
- robryan 16y agoI think a musician that travels the world working what would be equivalent to full time hours anyone else would work they should make a good wage and then a little bit extra. I think things are a little flawed if musicians expect to be able to put out an album once in a while and become rich on that. I don't think music should be always free but maybe the price expected is a little bit over the top.
- mynameishere 16y agoThe old story goes Muddy Waters, who, according to one apocryphal tale, was busy painting the walls of the recording studio when a very young Mick Jagger popped by for a visit. (http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/2007/jun/21/popandrock.vinylword http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/2007/jun/21/popandrock.vinyl...) ...I read this a while ago and it screamed BS, but the truth is, anybody who was working with skinflints like Ahmet Ertegun was going to be underpaid. If you go back in time, you'll find people like Scott Joplin who got relatively good royalties. It depends on the deal-making. Led Zeppelin was 1/2 professional (not kids) and got a professional manager (Peter Grant) who made sure everyone got paid. The stones lived far beyond the typical pop band's longevity, and so matured enough to swing deals properly.
- jokermatt999 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bittersweet_symphony http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bittersweet_symphony And yet, he/The Rolling Stones felt no qualms about taking every penny of revenue from that song, despite it only using a small sample of an orchestral cover of one of their songs. Somehow, I can't respect much of anything he says about music revenue after knowing that.
- m0nastic 16y agoI fail to see a connection. He stated that musicians making money from recording albums is an aberration in the history or recorded music. It could be argued that the situation with the Verve backs up that point. I'd also not equate his personal opinions with the actions taken by Allen Klein.