4 ms·
What percentage of all startups are founded by immigrants? If it's on the order of 51%, you can't rule out the possibility that this number just reflects the ba
by nerdponx 10y ago
What percentage of all startups are founded by immigrants? If it's on the order of 51%, you can't rule out the possibility that this number just reflects the base occurrence rate of immigrants in the "population" of all startup founders.
- cromwellian 10y agoCould be true but looks just as bad. If 51% of all startups are founded by a tiny minority of immigrants relative to the general population, then why the hell do we want to keep these people out?
- xapata 10y agoI don't think that'd counter the author's point.
- nerdponx 10y agoNo, but it changes it.
- davidf18 10y agoGood studies must discuss denominators as well as numerators. The 51% is misleading. What would be important to know is how many immigrants were founders with a denominator of how many founders were there. Moreover, there is some (wrong) assumption that an American could not have been a founder in place of the immigrant founders of a similar company. H1-B visas were created for the intent of not displacing Americans but rather filing jobs for which Americans do not have the skill. Americans have skills for almost all of the jobs that are filled with H1-B visas. There should be a independent committee that verifies that there are absolutely no Americans available for each individual job.
- basseq 10y agoThe 51% is misleading. What would be important to know is how many immigrants were founders with a denominator of how many founders were there. The statistic here is: "51% of unicorns had at least one founder who was born in another country". Palantir, for example, is included as an "immigrant-founded company", which it is, but Peter Thiel (Germany) is one of five co-founders. So with a subset of one company, only 20% of founders were immigrants.