3 ms·
> No, it doesn't. It was never empirically proven that there is a connection between minimum wage and unemployment. (You are simplifying the whole economy to th
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
> No, it doesn't. It was never empirically proven that there is a connection between minimum wage and unemployment. (You are simplifying the whole economy to the labor market, but there is also demand side.)
Nobody can prove something like that because it depends on dynamic characteristics of the economy. If everyone who makes minimum wage worked for the government and the government did nothing but pay them more money by taking on more public debt then the current-year employment rate obviously wouldn't go down, but our current economy doesn't look like that.
Only ~1% of workers in the US make minimum wage, and they represent an even smaller percentage of total consumption than that. Increasing their wages is not going to create a large increase in local consumption, especially when some of the money goes to things that don't create new local unskilled jobs, like increasing salaries for existing CEOs, or leaving the local economy and going to workers in China or India, or creating demand for skilled jobs that the newly unemployed minimum wage workers aren't qualified for.
And the entire wage increase comes out of the employer's pocket, which for middle class employers means that much less consumption by the employer -- the "increased demand" from higher minimum wage is the broken window fallacy. Meanwhile there are existing jobs that can justify the lower wage but not the higher wage, so those people become unemployed, which reduces local demand, not only due to the lost amount to the employee but also the profit that employee had previously generated for the employer and the surplus for the employer's customers and suppliers and so on.
- hnbroseph 10y ago> Only ~1% of workers in the US make minimum wage does this statistic limit to literal minimum wage? so if someone is hired at +5 cents, do they not count?
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> does this statistic limit to literal minimum wage? so if someone is hired at +5 cents, do they not count? Including minimum wage +5 cents is still ~1%.
- hnbroseph 10y ago+1.00? +2.00? does it include everything sub-living wage?
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoFinding the specific data at that granularity is apparently a pain because everybody provides data for income instead of wages which doesn't distinguish $15 for 20 hours from $7.50 for 40 hours. FWIW the median wage is ~$16. > does it include everything sub-living wage? There are many people who work primarily for tips, but raising the minimum wage wouldn't change that.
- hnbroseph 10y agoit would certainly be curious if nobody made <$15/hr yet there was so much noise about it.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoMinimum wage is traditional special interest politics. The benefits are concentrated (the specific people who make minimum wage and don't lose their jobs get a raise) but the costs are distributed (things cost more for everyone, higher unemployment). Suppose you raise minimum wage by 10% and as a result 9 people get a 10% raise and one person loses their job. Well, you just got yourself 9 votes at the cost of one, even though the net result across those ten people is negative. And the net result across all people is even worse because now people have to pay higher prices for things, but those costs are too widely distributed to change anyone's vote. So raising the minimum wage (or having one at all) will tend to have more political support than it can justify on the merits.