6 ms·
Lloyd Conover, Inventor of Groundbreaking Antibiotic Tetracycline, Dies at 93
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- danso 10y agoI know the legend of penicillin makes it sound as if revolutionary drugs were discovered by miracle accident, but I'm guessing the less famous drugs, such as tetracyclene, involved a more "routine", non-sexy methodical-hypothesis-testing process, as described in the OP: > Dr. Conover, however, became intrigued with two naturally occurring antibiotics that, except for two atoms, were chemically identical. To Dr. Conover, the atoms seemed out of place. Each antibiotic had a chlorine or oxygen atom where he expected to find a hydrogen atom. Would swapping in hydrogen improve the potency of the drugs? > Using a routine chemical procedure, he stripped chlorine from one antibiotic and inserted hydrogen, creating a more stable molecule. He worked with a single assistant. “I didn’t want an audience if we failed,” he told The Plain Dealer of Cleveland in 1992. > The result was tetracycline, a powerful antibiotic with fewer side effects than the drug from which it was derived — proof, Dr. Conover wrote, that “a superior drug could be made by chemical modification.” In computer science and computer engineering, students typically learn about, and then how to implement such fundamental breakthroughs as Hamming codes [0] and implementing ALU's in VHDL [1]. What's the equivalent in chemistry/biology/pharma? That is, how do you get into the field/expertise/mindset in which you're creating and testing out drug compositions in a methodical way that Dr. Conover did when he was able to discover and confirm tetracycline in a matter of months. I realize this already feels like a silly question. Discovering new drugs is more complicated today. And a single science, such as chemistry, isn't enough to create an antibiotic, because you also have to be able to test the result. And perhaps there's a significant amount of chemical engineering process involved to efficiently create the target antibiotic. [0] http://nifty.stanford.edu/2011/hansen-hamming-codes/ http://nifty.stanford.edu/2011/hansen-hamming-codes/ [1] http://www.utdallas.edu/~poras/courses/ee3320/xilinx/upenn/lab5-ALUDesign.htm http://www.utdallas.edu/~poras/courses/ee3320/xilinx/upenn/l...
- sndean 10y ago> What's the equivalent in chemistry/biology/pharma? That is, how do you get into the field/expertise/mindset in which you're creating and testing out drug compositions in a methodical way that Dr. Conover did when he was able to discover and confirm tetracycline in a matter of months. I'm not a chemist, but several times I've walked up to a organic/medicinal chemist and been told something like "putting a fluorine there (pointing at a chemical structure) should make it bind better. I can do that for you in a week or two." There's apparently whole bodies of work [0], especially in medicinal chemistry, where you methodically put a fluorine at different positions around a ring (or something similar) and you test each new compound. Sometimes one will have some property that's a few orders of magnitude better than the rest, and you get a "miracle" drug. [0] http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/jm800219f http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/jm800219f
- refurb 10y agoFluorinations are very popular as fluorine is not that much bigger than hydrogen, so you don't tend to cause big confirmational changes with the swap. It's also very stable, so it's doesn't screw up your pharmacokinetics. And finally, fluorine is super polar, so a simple swap can dramatically change the drug's activity. As someone else said, drug design is still a lot of hand waving and hit and miss. Sometimes you can make the smallest changes to a molecule and have a huge impact. The fentanyls are a good example. Swap a hydrogen for methyl and you can increase potency by 100x.
- JunkDNA 10y agoThe field of study that most directly relates to what you describe is Medicinal Chemistry (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medicinal_chemistry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medicinal_chemistry) It's a fascinating discipline. Typically for any given drug, large numbers of candidates are made. Those candidates are trivially different and go through a battery of tests for toxicity and efficacy. While there's a lot of science to it, the amount we know about biology is too primitive for it to be a pure engineering discipline. There's a certain amount of art to it because it's not enough to make the compound. You need to consider that if it works, some day a person is going to have to make it at scale, so it needs to be easy to make too. Finally, biology is surprising and messy so sometimes a gut instinct tells you to go a certain way. I once was in a talk where one of the medicinal chemists who developed Amoxicillin described his excitement when they discovered the drug they had made had no taste whatsoever. The standard of care oral antibiotic that preceded it for brief period was horribly bitter (I forget the name). Kids hated taking the liquid form as a result. The team realized that with no innate flavor, the liquid form of Amoxicillin could be flavored with something more subtle than the typical grape or cherry flavors that they were accustomed to using to mask the flavor of drugs. He chose bubblegum.
- proee 10y agoMy dermatologist prescribed handfuls of tetracycline to battle my teenage acne. I took around 8 pills of the stuff daily for years. My GI tracks been messed up for years and there was very little improvement in my acne.
- xutopia 10y agoWhy would your doctor do that?
- monkmartinez 10y agoEminence based medicine vs. Evidence based medicine.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoDoxycyclin is a first-line treatment for acne, it's a chronic bacterial infection, after all. But there's simply no good reason to continue first-line treatment that isn't working, hippocratic oafs are everywhere, one would guess.
- monkmartinez 10y agoI feel for you fellow traveler. I have a good friend that had to be on drip IV antibiotics for some time and struggles with GI problems. He says his best results came from kombucha and/or other fermented foods with probiotics and daily metamucil. There is also promising things happening with fecal transplants (FMT) I am told.
- protomyth 10y agoThey generally tried it (80's) before moving on to the other stuff. I tried it, but I got very sunlight sensitive (blisters) and they moved on.
- Aloha 10y agoProbiotics + regular consumption of milk, yogurt.. anything with active cultures will help. Every time I take antibiotics I run 60% chance of a fungal infection somewhere, so I have my own regimen to keep that annoyance away.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]