3 ms·
In some ways Japan may be addressing their demographic challenges in a way that works for Japan. For years the west (businesses, academia, think thanks) has tr
by mc32 10y ago
In some ways Japan may be addressing their demographic challenges in a way that works for Japan. For years the west (businesses, academia, think thanks) has tried to convince Japan they needed to open immigration to address low birth rates --however, given their aging population and the advances in robotics and automation, their holding back the popular tide might make their transition into automation easier as they are naturally drifting to an economy which needs fewer people...
Much of the west would also have plateauing or decreasing populations if it were not for the importation of foreign populations.
Even advanced economies will be unable to provide middle class lifestyles to everyone if most people are not being productive in some way. We may just have to get used to most people doing more with less. That might mean living healthy but more frugal and less consumerist lives.
- crdoconnor 10y agoAll Japan needs to do is to raise wages and increase job security. It's the same problem the US has, they've just had it for longer. Japanese birth rates didn't fall because of some fundamental, immutable law of the universe.
- istorical 10y ago> Even advanced economies will be unable to provide middle class lifestyles to everyone if most people are not being productive in some way. This doesn't really make sense to me. If we look purely at the economy in terms of its inputs and outputs - in terms of goods and services - we won't suddenly have less goods and services. We'll have the same or more goods and services with lower costs (because robots will be cheaper than people - otherwise we'd just employ people). So you have the same end result (the goods and services) with less operating costs - seems to me like if you don't change anything you'd either 1) see business owners growing their share of wealth while the hordes of unemployed starve - or 2) you'd increase taxes and increase welfare spending and things would net out such that the average person's quality of life could be preserved. Of course, if you're argument assumes that we're hurtling straight towards option 1, then yeah that makes sense. But it doesn't mathematically make sense to me that automation _has_ to mean people become destitute.