3 ms·
The article you linked concludes that "the wealthiest 1 percent are an outlier: 36 percent of their income comes from capital gains". As the graph suggests, tha
by prostoalex 10y ago
The article you linked concludes that "the wealthiest 1 percent are an outlier: 36 percent of their income comes from capital gains". As the graph suggests, that number quickly decreases to 10% and 5% when the group encompasses the wealthiest 5% and 10%.
So for those three groups the income not subject to capital gains tax constitutes 64%, 90% and 95%.
This is before the capital gains are even broken down into long-term vs short-term (which are taxed at plain old income tax rates).
I am still not seeing what led you to believe that the effective tax rate will be significantly lower.
> That is federal income tax, you've missed state
Mmm, okay. Well, I am not a CPA and not sure about other states, but California makes it easy by treating any capital gains (long-term or short-term) as income, so (at least for CA) the effective tax rate of someone relying on long-term capital gains will be pushed up, not down.
I agree though that if some other states have favorable treatment of long-term capital gains, the numbers would look different.
> medicare and social security
Both are subjects to wage limits, and at $166,000 (which will be a higher value once the state tax is incorporated) we're well past those limits.
> the lottery has a negative expected value, investment does not. In the long run
But a capital gains requires a sale, which means the position has been exited, and there's no long-run. True, it might be a partial sale of an asset, and in some case the proceeds of a sale are invested into another position, but at this point you're pretty much betting the new assets will increase in value and be a candidate for a sale. Hence my lottery comment.