3 ms·
There are some regulations for software. I work for a U.S.-based electric power utility that owns and operates a nuclear power generating station. There are mos
by taylodl 10y ago
There are some regulations for software. I work for a U.S.-based electric power utility that owns and operates a nuclear power generating station. There are most definitely regulations addressing the software used in the operation of that facility.
But that's an extreme case. More generally, I see programming as a skilled trade and not an engineering practice. In my worldview programming is akin to carpentry, plumbing, electrical work, etc. Yes, one needs an aptitude for the job and some technical training - maybe even an apprenticeship - but by and large we should see programming as a skilled trade. Viewed in that context Peter Thiel's comments about education make sense - we don't insist plumbers and carpenters get 4 year degrees to practice their trade, so why do we insist that for programmers?
For software projects whose failure would cause tremendous harm to the public, either physically or financially, then I could see having a certified software engineer oversee the construction of that system. I don't see this as any different than how we build buildings. Certified engineers/architects design the building, review the design and inspect each stage of the build process and final result while tradesmen build the building. This model prevents us from overcorrecting and insisting all programmers become certified engineers - that's not necessary.