4 ms·
"Your data is completely safe from ... any threat." How is that possible?
by TheSpiceIsLife 10y ago
"Your data is completely safe from ... any threat."
How is that possible?
- dredmorbius 10y agoIt's not. It's probably relatively safe at rest from compromise on the server(s). Endpoint attacks (users' own systems), or some form of targeted client update (e.g., client code that's dropped to individual users), either by SpiderOak or through other means (MITM / cert hijacking) strike me as plausible routes.
- jml7c5 10y agoFrom context I assume they mean threat levied against the company or data entrusted to it. They should probably change it to "any server-side threat", or just nix that portion entirely. (Nixing it is probably most reasonable, given that they could theoretically push an update that steals secret keys, AFAIK.)
- mavhc 10y agoBecause they don't have your data, they have your encrypted data and no key. Last week I emailed the Information Commissioner's Office in the United Kingdom https://ico.org.uk/ https://ico.org.uk/ about whether, in their view, storing encrypted backups in another country, when the key never leaves the UK, counts as moving personal data outside the country, sadly they said yes, I don't really have faith they understood the maths though.
- msh 10y agoMaybe they understand the theory but have no means of verifying the implementation, while its easier to verify the location of data.
- mavhc 10y agoThey don't really verify things anyway, they wait for people to inform them of issues. Encryption can be broken, but, one assumes: a) that your backups aren't likely to be stolen, b) that no one cares enough and c) by the time they are, the people whose information you stored are dead If you logged in you provided the key: NOTE: Logging in via the SpiderOak website does temporarily allow SpiderOak employees access to your password. Due to this exposure, we discourage users from entering your password online if they wish to fully retain our Zero-Knowledge privacy.
- icebraining 10y agoEncryption can be broken, especially in the long run.
- warrenmiller 10y agoIf they have no key how come I can login and download files from the web UI without providing my key?