3 ms·
I wonder what the effect would be of a mixed strategy where only the relatively safer and lower-concentration forms of a drug are legal?
by skybrian 10y ago
I wonder what the effect would be of a mixed strategy where only the relatively safer and lower-concentration forms of a drug are legal?
- prodmerc 10y agoThat would actually work just as well as full legalization. Except some people would still take too much of that substance and die, and then the banheads will be at it again.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> I wonder what the effect would be of a mixed strategy where only the relatively safer and lower-concentration forms of a drug are legal? The interesting solution is very high taxes, with the tax based on the amount of the substance. Then higher concentrations have higher taxes. The optimal tax amount is just below the amount that would cause the tax-evading black market to be larger than the legal market. And then prosecuting for tax evasion doesn't cost the other taxpayers anything because every prosecution pays for itself through the back taxes and penalties, without having to put anybody in prison.
- M_Grey 10y agoWe already put people into feedback loops of administrative fines, and jail. You really think this would play out differently? Without incarceration, how exactly do you propose to collect your money? Once you figure that out, be sure to tell all of the parents looking to collect from deadbeats your secret, they need it!
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoThe government doesn't need your cooperation to collect a tax debt. If you owe them and you have any money or assets they just seize them, and if you don't have any money they have your employer garnish your wages until you've paid it off. The IRS does not screw around. And the point is to deter people from evading taxes. If they're permanently bankrupt you can't collect anything from them, but they also end up on probation which means the government can search their place and finances without a warrant. If they're stupid enough to violate their probation by committing tax evasion again, even though it's now much easier for the government to catch them, now they can go to jail.
- M_Grey 10y agoThe government doesn't need your cooperation to collect a tax debt. It does if they want to actually make a profit on collecting taxes. Those "bleed the beast" pricks, extreme LDS sects, etc... all seem to have little trouble withholding taxes. Could the government step up enforcement? Sure... but it costs money.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> Those "bleed the beast" pricks, extreme LDS sects, etc... all seem to have little trouble withholding taxes. Those people live in isolation without corporate employment, use of financial institutions or the ability to hold title to a vehicle. Hardly "little trouble".
- M_Grey 10y agoThey do that for reasons that have nothing to do with not paying their taxes... still, if you need an even ore obvious example... http://fortune.com/2016/04/29/tax-evasion-cost/ http://fortune.com/2016/04/29/tax-evasion-cost/
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> They do that for reasons that have nothing to do with not paying their taxes... If that's the cost of getting away with it, most people are not going to be willing to pay it. > still, if you need an even ore obvious example... http://fortune.com/2016/04/29/tax-evasion-cost/ http://fortune.com/2016/04/29/tax-evasion-cost/ That's not the enforcement cost, that's the potential revenue gain from increased enforcement.
- M_Grey 10y agoThat's not the enforcement cost, that's the potential revenue gain from increased enforcement. ...And more enforcement to increase revenue... costs... money. Which was my entire point. The government requires cooperation in your taxes, and already loses hundreds of billions to those who don't.
- simonh 10y agoAlcohol and tobacco are heavily taxed many countries, with pretty low levels of incarceration for smuggling them. It doesn't seem to be much of a problem in practice. Also programs of decriminalisation of regulated drugs provision in several countries have been very successful. At this point, there's an awful lot of actual real world evidence that it really does play out differently.
- zkms 10y ago> where only the relatively safer and lower-concentration forms of a drug are legal? Partial legalisation of that type is likely to be counterproductive to achieving such a shift to safer forms of drugs. Trying to enforce (laudable and correct) principles such as "lower-concentrations are better and safer" with the coarse and brutal tool of the criminal law tends to be counterproductive -- there are far better tools of policy-making. As far as the criminal law and the police goes, they should keep their nose out of drugs except for pathological cases where there's actual criminal intent -- such as intentional / grossly negligent fuckups by drug manufacturers or people non-consensually dosing others or, say, drugged driving. Besides those sorts of exceptions, it should be impossible to get arrested/searched for any drug offences. Completely removing the selection pressures (those created by fear of law-enforcement actions such as search and arrest) towards easier-to-conceal drugs will, by itself, allow for exactly the shift back that you describe. Combining that with regulatory requirements for labelling, dose accuracy, and lack of impurities will allow people to safely use drugs in controlled accurate doses.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoThat really depends on how low you go. If you are hankering for some whiskey, diluting it to the strength of beer or wine simply won't do. That said, there is good reason to avoid things twice that strong because folks die that way. And I think similar care should be taken with stuff that is illegal. I'd not be too happy with half-strength pot, for example, but others might be. On the other hand, I'm not sure I want a strong cocaine (if that were my fancy, that is) nor do I necessarily want a hit of lsd that is doubled in strength (one can take two, after all). The thing is this: If you go too low, folks will just buy the black market stuff anyway as that will seem like legalisation in name only. If you go too high, folks get in trouble.