4 ms·
> Which seems like an obviously good idea, but research has shown that in practice it doesn't save money or lives. Why don't they?
by astrange 10y ago
> Which seems like an obviously good idea, but research has shown that in practice it doesn't save money or lives.
Why don't they?
- ghaff 10y agoA number of reasons. -- Most healthcare monies are spent on the sickest individuals and they're least likely to participate in a wellness program. And the most motivated participants in lifestyle change sort of program would probably have been the most motivated to make changes outside of a program. -- Many chronic illnesses and other expensive medical conditions/procedures are not prevented by wellness programs, getting an annual physical, etc. -- A lot of programs are pretty superficial. (Discounted gym memberships and the like.)
- curun1r 10y agoThe wellness programs were never about changing behavior or making people healthier. They're about satisfying actuaries to reduce the cost of insuring more healthy individuals. Determining how much someone's health care premium should be depends on assigning them to a risk pool. The more data you have on that person, the more nuanced you can make that assignment. These wellness programs gather that data and appropriately discount the health insurance premiums of lower-risk employees. That they may change a few people's unhealthy behavior would just be a bonus. I've never seen a problem with that. I do believe that everyone should have the right to health care, but I don't think that everyone should have the right to health care at the same price. If people are actively making choices that make them, statistically speaking, more costly to insure, why shouldn't they have to pay more as a result?
- astrange 10y ago> -- A lot of programs are pretty superficial. (Discounted gym memberships and the like.) A discounted gym membership sounds like it'd save me money though. Is that what people are having problems with? I thought this was about the question I get in open enrollment if I'm a smoker or not, or the forced yearly checkup other countries' employers have.