4 ms·
I'm very sorry for your loss. > I can't for the life of me understand or comprehend how one would discriminate against someone based on what genes they have.
by lisper 10y ago
I'm very sorry for your loss.
> I can't for the life of me understand or comprehend how one would discriminate against someone based on what genes they have.
Did you really mean to say "how" or did you mean "why"? Because the "why" is that if you have investors (at least in the U.S.) then you have a fiduciary duty to them to maximize their return by all legal means at your disposal. You do not have a fiduciary duty to your employees. So if you can increase profits by discriminating against employees who are more likely to be sick then you have no choice but to either do it or break your fiduciary duty to your investors. You could actually be sued if you don't.
> What are you going to do? Block them from leading a project since they test positive for XYZ Type A? Or getting a promotion because they're carriers of ALS?
Yes. Exactly. And then hope they quit. Or, if you're in an at-will state, you could just fire them.
Please note that I am not endorsing this system. I think it sucks. But that's the way things currently are in the U.S.
- dredmorbius 10y agoThat fiduciary duty myth you've just restated is just that, a myth. Created from whole cloth (like many others) by Milton Friedman. http://evonomics.com/the-myth-of-maximizing-shareholder-value/ http://evonomics.com/the-myth-of-maximizing-shareholder-valu...
- lisper 10y agoAll social constructs are myths, including the very idea of a corporation itself. When enough people believe the myth it becomes self-actualizing. The law itself is a self-actualizing myth, having power only because enough people believe that it has power. It is that shared belief that causes the law to have actual power in the real world. It's the same with corporations and their duties. Enough people believe the "myth" that shareholders own corporations and that corporations hence have a fiduciary duty to their shareholders that this "myth" becomes self-actualizing in exactly the same way that the law becomes self-actualizing. The law itself even has a mechanism for incorporating such self-actualizing myths, notwithstanding that they are not formally codified into the law. That is called "common law". Common law is a meta-myth. Nowhere will you find the idea of common law formally incorporated into the law. And yet anyone who questioned the principle of common law (at least in the U.S.) would rightfully be considered out of touch with reality. Likewise for the fiduciary duty of corporations to their shareholders.
- dredmorbius 10y agoYou're verging on, if not wholly embracing, a complete dispensing of the very concept of truth. The fact remains that the legal obligation you claim exists does not. Not in statute. Not in jurisprudence. Not in common law. Which is incorporated into law through jurisprudence, e.g., Houston & T.C. Ry. Co. v East, 81 S.W. 279 (Texas 1904), or Pierson v. Post, as examples. Cheers.
- lisper 10y ago> The fact remains that the legal obligation you claim exists does not. Not in statute. Not in jurisprudence. Not in common law. Wrong. The matter was definitively decided in 1916: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodge_v._Ford_Motor_Co https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodge_v._Ford_Motor_Co. Note that Milton Friedman was four years old at the time, so this data point also falsifies your claim that Friedman invented fiduciary duty to shareholders out of whole cloth. You really should do your homework before you accuse someone of "dispensing of the very concept of truth."
- dredmorbius 10y agoReading your own reference: Dodge is often misread or mistaught as setting a legal rule of shareholder wealth maximization. This was not and is not the law. Shareholder wealth maximization is a standard of conduct for officers and directors, not a legal mandate.
- lisper 10y agoYou left out an important bit of context: "However, ONE VIEW is that this interpretation has not represented the law in most states for some time." [Emphasis added.] IMHO that view is wrong. The fact of the matter is that if, as an officer of the company, you do not act in the best interests of the shareholders you can be sued in all 50 states, and if your conduct was sufficiently egregious you will lose. The business judgement rules gives you a lot of wiggle room, but it does not change the basic underlying principle. Whether you call this a "legal mandate" or a "standard of conduct" is just quibbling over terminology. In any case, your claim that fiduciary duty to shareholders is "a myth ... [c]reated from whole cloth (like many others) by Milton Friedman" is plainly flat-out false.