3 ms·
It seems like many people implicit assume that a union must involve a list a of traditional practices. It's not an assumption that it must, it's a recognition
by icebraining 10y ago
It seems like many people implicit assume that a union must involve a list a of traditional practices.
It's not an assumption that it must, it's a recognition that very likely, it will. Organizations aren't created in a vacuum, they require bringing in others, and if you're starting an union, you'll attract people who are already predisposed to all the ideas of what makes up a union, and you'll attract offers of help from existing unions, which will try to co-opt you. And there's no valid reason to believe that you'll be able to control that process. Finally, once that it created, it's not just a matter of distancing yourself; once a union grows, it affects every worker, even non-unionized - in some cases, even banning them outright from working.
So it's not surprising that workers which still have it pretty good aren't interest in opening that can of worms, and you must have a better reason to convince them why it won't be one.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> It's not an assumption that it must, it's a recognition that very likely, it will. To add to everything you just said, the NLRA sets very rigid rules regarding how unions can form and how employees and employers can interact with them. So you can't just charter it however you want and assume all the problems are solved - the NLRA imposes a number of requirements and protections for the union (not the members, but the union itself as a corporate structure) which way be at odds with the employees. As a result, once a union forms, it's very difficult (practically) for its members to deunionize, even if a majority of the membership opposes the union representing them. So people are very hesitant to go down a road which is essentially seen as a one-way street, except as a last resort.
- pdkl95 10y ago> no valid reason to believe that you'll be able to control that process People aren't interested in small-scale organizing for specific purposes because strong, traditional unions are too popular? Why aren't the same people you claim will "control [the] process" making a union now? Yes, just like every other type of organization, a union - or business - can evolve beyond it's original purpose. There are no guarantees in most collective actions. However, arguments that assume an inevitable strong union in industries where unions are very unpopular do not seem to be based in reality. > you must have a better reason to convince them why it won't be one The tech industry has been very successful at inventing new types of organizations over the last several decades. The "gig economy" and Bitcoin/Etherium are obvious examples. Silicon Valley is popular because of how easy it is to invent new businesses. Sometimes this creativity extends to new ways to fund startups. A lot of the tech itself revolves around new types of social interaction. I find it very hard to believe that unions - or collective bargaining in general - are somehow immune from "disruption" and creative reinterpretation.
- icebraining 10y agoLook, we weren't discussing whether unions were good or bad; we were discussing why people don't believe it's in their best interest to form or join one. I'm telling you why I think you are mistaken about their motivations, not that you are mistaken in your belief that a union would in fact be a positive thing for tech workers.