3 ms·
> Culpability is a happy illusion outside of a social context I'm sure that's what you believe, but that doesn't make it true. > do you seriously think that t
by naasking 10y ago
> Culpability is a happy illusion outside of a social context
I'm sure that's what you believe, but that doesn't make it true.
> do you seriously think that there is an objective culpability for arbitrary concepts when people won't even interpret the arbitrary concepts the same way?
The whole point of objectivity is that interpretation has no bearing on truth (or culpability in this case).
> in this case, science shows us free will doesn't map neatly into our known universe
Science shows no such thing. Assuming determinism of choice shoes only that philosophies of free will that claim free choice is incompatible with determinism are incompatible with evidence. Of course, we don't actually know that we are deterministic (evidence is not conclusive), and it does not in any way rule out free will that is compatible with determinism, which is the type most philosophers profess.
This is an all too common mistake that scientists make: thinking that their definition of free will is obviously the one everyone is using.