4 ms·
>There is no "canon" explanation for the film, since Kubrick did not provide one, and 2001 was, at heart, his movie, independent in significant respects from Cl
by SilasX 10y ago
>There is no "canon" explanation for the film, since Kubrick did not provide one, and 2001 was, at heart, his movie, independent in significant respects from Clarke's novelization and later sequels.
If you reject the canonicity of Clarke's novel, then everything after the "Jupiter and beyond..." card is nonsensical. What is the viewer supposed to think about the space baby that's actually grounded in something within the movie?
(Edit: Ditto for the aging sequence. I know that you can fit the events into the "alien zoo" framing, but since the film doesn't direct us to that explanation, and if the novel doesn't count, it can't be any more than a fan theory.)
Incidentally, that's why I think the film went sharply downhill after that card.
- nerdponx 10y ago> that's why I think the film went sharply downhill after that card. Agreed. I loved the first part of the movie, but this part literally did not make sense.
- twoodfin 10y agoWe could get into a long discussion about Kubrick's attempts to communicate in a uniquely cinematic way, but in the specific context of 2001: Why would you expect the first direct human encounter with an interstellar intelligence to make sense?
- SilasX 10y agoYeah but you can't let that dynamic turn into license for incomprehensible scripts! "Oh, the movie doesn't have to make sense because maybe they encountered something no one can understand. Mind blown, right? Yeah, here's where to ship the Emmy..."
- Udik 10y ago> What is the viewer supposed to think about the space baby that's actually grounded in something within the movie? Let's see. At the beginning of the movie we witness the dawn of Man. That is, we see tribes of apes shaken by beastly emotions, fear, rage, aggression; eaten by predators, sleeping under rocks, fighting with each other for food and water. Not a pretty sight. The tribe that wins and will give birth to mankind is the most violent one, the one that discovered how to use tools to kill. But jump forward a few million years of evolution, and a seemingly refined humanity is travelling in space and having civilised (if somewhat cautious) conversations about science and current events. On the spaceship (curiously spermatozoa-shaped) that is sent to investigate the mystery of the monolith, there's a crew of hyper-rational astronauts together with science's latest, most refined tool, an evolution of man itself: a super-human intelligence that embodies an ideal of rationality and civility. And how does this end up? In a violent bloodbath, with men fighting to death, tooth and nails, with their own super-human creation. Clearly, anything men can produce is tainted by the original sin of violence. So David Bowman is transported to a place that seems to be outside space or time, a room decorated in a style that's the essence of civility but also of sterile coldness; in this space he sees himself living by a futile ideal of sophistication, only to proceed towards his inevitable decay and death. And as he's approaching his last moments, the monolith (the otherness) intervenes again, extracting from his consumed shell, at last, a really new kind of humanity. Does it make sense? :)
- garyrob 10y agoNice. This may be the best short synopsis/theory I've ever run across. (I've seen the movie probably close to 15 times, starting during its initial run when I was 12. And read the book several times.)
- Udik 10y agoThanks :)
- SilasX 10y agoEverything but the last paragraph, just like the movie.