4 ms·
You do a great disservice to the people overdosing with such a middling dismissal. This is not a 'moral panic' this is a medical disaster unfolding in slow moti
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
You do a great disservice to the people overdosing with such a middling dismissal. This is not a 'moral panic' this is a medical disaster unfolding in slow motion.
The combination of the technology to synthesize these drugs from unconstrained pre-cursors, the intensity of their effect, the lack of education on the part of consumers, and a tracking/enforcement system which responds more slowly than conditions change is leading to a situation where tens of thousands of people are going to die essentially at their own hand.
It is not a question of 'people like to get high' it is that 'people getting high on arbitrary things will kill themselves'.
I understand that you're approaching this from a legalization standpoint, and on that we agree. But the overdose rate is "actually" sweeping the country now and that is born out by the available reports of emergency rooms around the country. And between your "regulated and safe" future and now, there is a large pile of unnecessarily dead people.
- myowncrapulence 10y agothe lack of education on the part of consumers You realize if drugs were legal and regulated people wouldn't need to seek out desperate and risky online orders to satisfy their addiction? When weed was legalized in Oregon, I immediately knew exactly what strain/THC%/CBD% I was buying. This was not available on the black market. Education and security come from acceptance and regulation.
- hackuser 10y ago> When weed was legalized That is far less dangerous than opiates; I don't think it's comparable.
- nedwin 10y agoIf we had similar labelling for opiates, and distributed them in the same way we distribute booze or marijuana, surely they could be consumed more safely / appropriately. It seems the overdoses are not necessarily thrill seekers, but where the consumer doesn't know that they're taking a 5000x dose of morphine vs a 2.5x dose.
- hackuser 10y agoSome things are too dangerous to distribute to consumers, no matter how they are labeled. Rather than repeat another discussion, see here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13847136 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13847136 IMHO Marijuana isn't a relevant example for the parent's argument because it's not that dangerous; it still is distributed illegally except for a few states in the U.S. and parts of Europe, and (almost) nobody dies from marijuana overdoses.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> it still is distributed illegally except for a few states in the U.S. There is no place in the US where traffic in marijuana is legal. The absence of state-level prohibition doesn't negate federal prohibition.
- zkms 10y ago> Some things are too dangerous to distribute to consumers, no matter how they are labeled. opioids, especially the lower potency ones, do not meet this criteria at all. With tolerance, minimum effective dose increases, but so does the lethal dose. With pharmaceutical-grade opioids whose amounts are precisely metered, it's possible to live in that window. It's only opioids under prohibition (aka, uncertain/varying doses and ingredients) that are inherently dangerous.
- lightedman 10y agoLabeling for opiates does not matter as opiates in and of themselves are highly unpredictable. Example: The same batch of heroin - first dose could be fine. You come back several hours later, take 1/3 the dose you did before and you're dead from an OD. That's how a couple of people in my rehab ministry died. Meth is more reliably predictable in comparison.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI do realize this, and agree that a saner drug policy is to legalize them and regulate them rather than the prohibition we have today. My point is that between the time we can get to that point, and now, a lot of people are going to end up dead unnecessarily and that they are worth trying to save. Sometimes this sort of 'look how horrible it is' type of article can help with that.
- iopq 10y agoBut "look how horrible" actually prevents decriminalization/legalization efforts.
- WalterBright 10y agoThis is an unintended side effect of the drugs being illegal. Make them legal, and addicts will have a safe, predictable and inexpensive access to the drugs. Addicts are already punished enough just by being addicts. I doubt any of them want to be addicts. Making it illegal, heaping on more punishment, does not help and just makes it worse. Government policy on addictive drugs should be focused on treatment, not punishment.
- hackuser 10y agoInteresting predictions, but I'd like to see research providing a basis for them before I take risks with people's health and lives. I agree that the current approach works very poorly; that doesn't mean any other approach is better. Sometimes what works poorly is still the best we can do, such as our approach to pancreatic cancer (though I don't think that's the case here). Government restricts access to many things for safety reasons, from unsafe cars to prescription drugs to dodgy financial deals to highly enriched uranium. It's a simple formula, almost a slogan, to say 'legalize it and consumers will decide for themselves' (and in fairness maybe the parent isn't being formulaic in this case). In some cases that's true; in some cases consumers simply don't have that capability. In our business, IT security is a good example; consumers have no way to make a judgment or even know that it's working. It's the same for prescription drugs: Am I better? Is that due to the drug? The placebo effect? Natural progress? Maybe I'd be even better without the drug. But that's all theory; before we mess with people's lives, we need evidence.
- WalterBright 10y ago> Government restricts access to many things for safety reasons By making drugs illegal you cut off reliable, safe, and inexpensive access. I personally know two addicts who OD'd because they acquired a batch of heroin that was more potent than they realized. One had been in and out of jail due to drugs. They'd likely be alive today if addiction was treated as a disease rather than a crime. > Maybe I'd be even better without the drug. They didn't want to be addicts.
- 10y ago
- rhizome 10y agoWhat is the proportion between opiate consumption derived from Chinese mailorder sources and those from domestic US ones, prescriptions, and whatnot? NPR doesn't deign to explore this angle, which aids the "moral panic" critique.
- washadjeffmad 10y agoYou're talking about (legally prescribed) opiates, though, right? I'm not really sure what substances you're referencing from ER reports. Could you clarify?
- wavefunction 10y agoFentanyl is commonly sold in place of heroin with 'spacers' that are (hopefully) non-active compounds like talc or something else to mimic the difference in mass between fentanyl and heroin. Or heroin is 'boosted' by adding fentanyl to make it seem more potent/pure. The problem with fentanyl is the dosage is in the micro-gram range which is why so many opiate addicts die from it. You simply can't gauge the dosage with such a powerful compound with any sort of accuracy.
- bfuller 10y agoThis is patently false. Volumetric dosing is easy for even the most brain dead drug dealer to figure out. 1g furanylfentanyl in 1000ml of liquid, you can easily dose out 1ml=1mg The problem is again with education. When heroin addicts are getting stuff cut with fentanyl, they fall out because they do not know what dose they are taking. If you know how much you are taking, these fent analogs can (and have been for years) be used quite safely)