4 ms·
I've always been struck by an odd irony in academia: People tend to have left-wing political beliefs, but maintain an organizational culture that is decidedly a
by analog31 10y ago
I've always been struck by an odd irony in academia: People tend to have left-wing political beliefs, but maintain an organizational culture that is decidedly authoritarian.
Perhaps this is necessary: I can't think of how else to manage a classroom than to have hard deadlines for things like homework assignments. Even in college, by definition, the work is finished when the semester ends.
I'm personally guilty of missing deadlines at work, and if I were permitted to be honest about it (or if it even mattered), my three excuses would be:
1. Managing the complexity of my job is over my head, because there are too many internal dependencies.
2. I'm going to miss this deadline because x[n] didn't happen, and I can't make those things happen.
3. I was kind of hoping the task would vanish, as roughly 75% of urgent tasks seem to.
- aaron-lebo 10y agoNot to detract from your main point, but authoritarianism exists across the political spectrum. See the USSR and Nazi Germany, or modern-day Venezuela and Russia. That there are authoritarians in academia isn't too surprising - it's all about politics ;)
- jacquesm 10y agoIt exists everywhere, no need to single out specific countries.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lucideer 10y agoNolan charts, or the more typical 2d 4-coloured political compasses used for displaying results of buzzfeed quizzes are not exactly a thorough and accurate representation of the intricate nuances of the political spectrum, but they do improve on the typical binary left-vs-right. The authoritarian left is very much a thing, and in the context of the organisation of educational institutions, quite a nice parallel.
- watwut 10y agoThere is no contradiction between left-wing and authoritarianism. Communists as they were rising to power and in power were all about that.
- CalChris 10y agoSimilarly, there is no contradiction between right-wing and authoritarianism. We've seen this in Greece, Latin America, ....
- watwut 10y agoAbsolutely, I agree. I wrote about left wing, because OP specifically mentioned left wing somehow being incompatible with authoritarianism. I think that only wing incompatible with authoritarianism is pro-democracy crowd.
- valuearb 10y agoAnd libertarian-ism!
- CalChris 10y agoLibertarianism or libertarianism? The Libertarian Party has had no problems with nominating authoritarians: Bob Barr comes to mind. Gary Johnson willingly sent people to prison for drugs as governor. The LP is more of a flag of convenience for protest votes.
- protomyth 10y agoI tend to look as the ratio between agreement[1] and force to implement their beliefs. It helps clear out the whole left / right thing that starts people categorizing instead of analyzing. 1) in the freedom of choice way
- paulddraper 10y agoNot all organizations should be run the same way. I would prefer my government to offer more liberty, than, say my employer.
- m-j-fox 10y agoI would prefer my employer to offer more liberty than they do. What's the point living in a liberal democracy if my most local of governments, the corporation, is a bunch of Nazi dick bags?
- tensor 10y agoYou're looking at academia from a teacher student relationship. Outside of the classroom and teaching it's a very flat structure generally. Individual professors have complete independence from one another. Relationships to government grants, on the other hand, are a different beast.