9 ms·
Preinstalled Malware Targeting Mobile Users
- rahimnathwani 10y ago"The malicious apps weren't part of the official ROM firmware supplied by the phone manufacturers but were added later somewhere along the supply chain." I'm not sure how they consider that 'pre-installed'.
- empath75 10y agoThey were installed before they opened the box. I think that counts.
- rahimnathwani 10y agoThe article makes no mention of the phones being received in the original boxes, or in any boxes at all. A more appropriate headline might be 'wholesalers install malware on phones before sale'.
- omginternets 10y agoThat's exactly what "preinstalled" means.
- privong 10y ago> That's exactly what "preinstalled" means. Eh, "preinstalled" isn't specific enough. I interpreted it similarly to some of the other folks in the thread, that it meant installed by my mfgs. But whether "preinstalled" is that specific or not is mostly a moot point, since it's apparent that the wording of the title isn't sufficiently precise.
- omginternets 10y agoChrist, the pedantry is reaching unprecedented levels. The wording of the title is just fine. This is just a case of someone trying to show how smart they are by nitpicking on insignificant details and feigning non-comprehension. In doing so, the discussion is no longer on the substance of the article, but rather on insignificant semantics.
- khedoros1 10y agoI originally took it to imply "manufacturer-preinstalled". Skimming the article clarified the meaning.
- bitmapbrother 10y agoNo they weren't. Do you really think a Nexus 5 or Nexus 5X would contain those malware apps? The Nexus 5 isn't even being manufactured anymore. In fact, half of those phones aren't even made anymore.
- srinathrajaram 10y agoThis presents a completely new kind of threat. I wonder how the industry would respond to this. When you do a fresh install, perform some kind of checksumming to verify the integrity of the OS with all its installed software. This cannot possibly be implemented by Google because each manufacturer has its own bloatware that it needs to pre-install. I wonder if Samsung and LG will wake up to this and create a security module?
- Nullabillity 10y agoOr... have users reflash the devices before first use?
- thraway2016 10y agoThis sounds like a great solution for the 99% of mobile phone users who don't even know what NVRAM means.
- khedoros1 10y agoIt's not news that the indifferent, the ignorant, and the uninformed are screwed, or that some things are difficult to solve without individual knowledge and action.
- Cyph0n 10y agoActually, the signature checks would have to be done by an external hardware component, or maybe through something like ARM TrustZone. Otherwise, the attacker could disable or manipulate the checks when installing the malware. So it's up to the phone manufacturers to implement; Google would never be able to implement this in a truly secure fashion, even if they knew all the software installed on the phone a priori. On a related note, I know that Cisco wants something like this for their hardware, but at runtime instead of just on-boot.
- ikeboy 10y agoIf the ROM isn't signed by the manufacturer, or is unlocked and modified, display a warning on each boot. Chrome book does this, as does my moto x. You can change whatever you like, but if it's not stock there's a clear warning. I'm fine with that.
- mattsouth 10y ago"To protect themselves from regular and pre-installed malware, users should implement advanced security measures capable of identifying and blocking any abnormality in the device’s behavior.". Aside from reflashing the device before first use, and I suppose on a reasonably regular basis, are there any other suggestions for implementing this suggestion?
- Ensorceled 10y ago"Why yes! The authors just happen to work at a company that provides excellent products that do just that!" Not saying this isn't an important finding, but that part was a bit self-serving.
- bramblerose 10y agoWell, let's say they provide products. Let's not say they provide 'excellent products'. After all, Check Point is one of those companies that suggests to do SSL MITM 'to provide security'. They sniff your SNI to make sure you don't look at XKCD. They randomly cut your connection if you try to download the SHAttered pdf's over http. They are what makes corporate life tiring.
- rdiddly 10y agoIndifference is my mobile protective strategy. Anything I have that's worth anything is located elsewhere and encrypted, so I have the luxury of not caring. Edit: I guess I never fully drank the mobile kool aid anyway... It's been what 10 years, the gee-whiz-bang effect has worn off, and they're revealed to be little more than a leash/tracking device for humans, with a small shitty interface on which you can't use more than 1 or 2 digits (fingers, son). So that's the foundation of indifference the above indifference comes from.
- marze 10y agoIf I were a spy, I'd certainly make my "malware" look like a common adnet or ransomware app. Surprised this possibility wasn't discussed in the article.
- ebbv 10y agoThis is clearly just an ad post. Can we stop allowing this stuff on HN? This is like Burger King posting an article "Hunger affecting 100% of living people up to several times a day has only one solution." From my perspective there's been a drastic rise in these kinds of ad posts appearing on the HN front page lately. I dunno if it's vote manipulation via paid viral marketing or something else but it sucks.
- tarr11 10y agoThe HN guidelines say that you should just flag the post and avoid comments like this: "Please don't submit comments complaining that a submission is inappropriate for the site"
- ebbv 10y agoDude come on. Don't quote the guidelines at people unless they're new users who might not actually be aware. I think it's pretty clear from my comment why I'm saying something; it's not just about this one article, there's been a rise in these obvious ads on the site in general (from my point of view), and I feel something needs to be done about it. I've obviously flagged every one of them but that's not enough. The point of me making a comment about it is to see if other people feel the same way. If you don't agree, you can reply and say "I don't agree, I think these ads are good / I don't see many of them / whatever." Replying and quoting the guidelines like that is trying to just shut down the discussion and/or just being pedantic.
- pdog 10y agoIf you care at all about security, use an iPhone. Make sure the latest version of iOS is installed. Set up a difficult passcode. Android security is a joke. Seriously. Don't use an Android phone.
- bitmapbrother 10y agoYour post is a joke. Let me clarify, the phones were not directly from the OEM. And if you look at the list a lot of them aren't even manufactured anymore. So what happened? These phones were acquired by some third party, modified and then resold to these 2 companies. If I were to acquire 38 iPhones that were not upgraded to the latest version of the OS and then proceeded to jailbreak them and install malware would you suddenly be saying iOS security is a joke?
- bobsam 10y agoTo add to that, in China people have bought what they thought was a genuine iPhone (in an "Apple store" no less) but turned out to be a clone full of crapware. These are extremely well made clones, people have used them for years without understanding what they were. What does that tell us about iPhone security? Nothing.
- bobsam 10y agohttp://www.imgur.com/a/Khbi9 http://www.imgur.com/a/Khbi9
- dang 10y ago> Your post is a joke. Please edit that kind of name-calling out of your comments here. I realize it started upthread, but this crosses into incivility and tarnishes your otherwise fine comment.
- CaptSpify 10y agoAndroid security is indeed a joke. That doesn't make me eager to use a different device with a bunch of closed-source software. We really need better choices.
- bitmapbrother 10y agoIf you look at the list of phones you'll quickly notice that 1/2 of the phones aren't even manufactured anymore. There is even a Nexus 5 in that list. What does this tell us? These 2 companies purchased these phones from a re-seller that clearly modified the phones by installing malware on them.
- chatterbeak 10y agoYou mean to tell me that I can go buy a brand-new shrink-wrapped name-brand (Samsung) Android phone and it has malware pre-installed? How? Who puts it there?
- rdiddly 10y agoTell you what else is plaguing mobile users: the staunchly non-responsive design of the linked article's page. Is it a mobile article aimed at desktop users?
- JohnTHaller 10y agotl;dr: Don't by used Android phones from third party resellers. Every one of these was bought used from a third party that installed malware prior to reselling. If you buy a new phone from a manufacturer, major retailer, or major carrier, this doesn't apply to you. If you buy a used phone from a trustworthy friend or family member and reset it for use, you're probably cool. If you buy a used phone from someone you don't know/trust online or off, flash it back to factory condition before you use it.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoYour handwavy fix is almost completely unrelated to the research. These were large companies. They generally always buy phones through third parties. And when work gives you a phone how will you figure out who touched it? Rather than giving people a lengthy and arbitrary list of purchase caveats, why not ask why it's so difficult to secure an android phone through the supply chain? And what, if anything, are other phone manufacturers doing that might be making the problem much more secure?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- codedokode 10y agoAndroid phones can have adware preinstalled, especially the cheap ones from chinese noname brands.
- Animats 10y agoNow what? Will there be more action than a blog post? This is a major criminal operation. If this has been found on multiple phones, tracing back the supply chain should reveal the common insertion point. That's a routine law enforcement job. The FBI has a "Cyber Division", and once in a while they catch somebody.
- khedoros1 10y agoSo, it's an ad for their product/services/whatever. I'd be a lot more interested in a discussion of practical things that phone owners can do to detect malware, avoid infection, etc on their own.
- patgenzler 10y agoIf you care about security, use iPhone or Google Android phone (pixel). They're not bullet proof, but they're 5x more secure by virtue of being able to react to issues like this immediately. Third party integrations like rest of Android phones are messy by design security wise.