4 ms·
Google may be in the right, but this litigious stance does not play well with the democratization of self driving cars. I hope there will be multiple companies
by visarga 10y ago
Google may be in the right, but this litigious stance does not play well with the democratization of self driving cars. I hope there will be multiple companies offering SDC and a few open source ones, not litigated out of existence. I don't want SDC technology be kept secret like Google Rank.
It is very important that automation be generally available as open source and not restricted by patents, because it might accentuate the migration of capital to the top 1%. We need to empower the 99% as well, as owners of automation, not simple clients of Google and the likes.
- brianwawok 10y agoNo part of robotization is going to help the 99%. The difference is only accelerating with new technology.
- CaptainSwing 10y agoIf 'the 99%' owned the robots it could help
- visarga 10y agoWe should be able to have open source robots. Most AI tools are open source. Datasets as well, at least the research ones. 3D printers and CNC might help with making robot bodies.
- asadlionpk 10y agoTools are open, code is open, but datasets are not. I think they are the main 'secret sauce' in case of self-driving cars.
- CaptainSwing 10y agoThe source code (data sets, license, etc) is one thing, but the actual physical robot is something else.
- commenter55 10y agoGo read the actual court filings. All the news articles are leaving out important details. Techcrunch has them linked at the end of their article: https://techcrunch.com/2017/03/10/waymo-files-for-an-injunction-against-ubers-use-of-its-self-driving-tech/ https://techcrunch.com/2017/03/10/waymo-files-for-an-injunct... Important bits: injunction page 23 line 12-14: Waymo is not seeking to enjoin Defendants from pursuing self driving cars in toto. Waymo merely asks that Defendants not be allowed to use Waymos trade secrets in doing so. Page 24 8-9: Moreover, Defendants would be free to use non-infringing alternative components in their business, such as the same third-party LiDAR system that they had previously used before switching to Waymos patented technology. (Fun fact) From the Gary Brown testimony, page 4 lines 6-8 (Paraphrasing) The "database" was an SVN server, and the specialty software installed was TortoiseSVN.
- Qwertious 10y ago"asks that Defendants not be allowed to use Waymos trade secrets in doing so." I was under the impression that trade secrets were explicitly not legally protected, and the entire point of a patent was that you publicly document your invention, in exchange for legal protection.
- coriny 10y agoThis may (IANAL) be relevant: http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/california-trade-secret-law.html http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/california-trade-secr.... California has laws dealing with the "misappropriation" of trade secrets.
- jlarocco 10y agoIf Uber had independently come up with the same ideas then there wouldn't be a case. The real issue is that the guy "stole" the trade secrets and gave them to another company. No doubt he signed an employment contract with Google saying he couldn't do that.
- londons_explore 10y ago