3 ms·
he's arguing a proof of mere existence there. You don't need to propose an algorithm, or indeed have any idea how to go about it, you can just assert that it m
by hprotagonist 10y ago
he's arguing a proof of mere existence there. You don't need to propose an algorithm, or indeed have any idea how to go about it, you can just assert that it must exist and that's enough.
it is a bit teeth-gnashing though.
- RangerScience 10y agoA physicist, an engineer, and a mathematician are in a hypothetical theater when the stage curtains catch fire. The physicist makes some measurements as to the volume of curtain, available air flow, chemical properties of the curtain, flow rate and thermal capacity of the water hose and water, formulating a precise equation for how much water is necessary to put the fire out when starting at a given time, and precisely puts the fire out. The engineer makes a few quick estimates as the the volume of fuel and air, uses that to estimate the amount of water needed, doubles it, and puts the fire out (with safety factor 2). The mathematician looks at the fire, looks at the fire hose, states: "The problem is solvable", and exits stage left.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoAnd I'm arguing that his proof of mere existence has holes in it. At a minimum, step 3 is not a mechanistic step that can be simply asserted. Or, rather, I assert that step 3 posits a degree of self-knowledge that no human actually possesses. Now you have to choose which unproven assertion you're going to believe, his or mine, or else you have to find a way to prove one or the other.