4 ms·
> It can just mean that the subject has a whole beneath-the-surface thing beyond the conscious layer. But doesn't that mean at some point you can't say effect
by criddell 10y ago
> It can just mean that the subject has a whole beneath-the-surface thing beyond the conscious layer.
But doesn't that mean at some point you can't say effect A was caused by action B? There has to be some point where there are some number of possible outcomes but even knowing the entire state, you cannot predict which path will be taken and that any particular path can be taken reliably.
- naasking 10y ago> There has to be some point where there are some number of possible outcomes but even knowing the entire state, you cannot predict which path will be taken and that any particular path can be taken reliably. Why? It's not predictable whether any random Turing machine will halt, but whether that specific machine halts still has a deterministic, well-defined answer.
- criddell 10y agoI don't think predicting if a Turing machine will halt is the same as saying state n+1 cannot be determined from state n.
- naasking 10y agoWhat I was trying to convey was that unpredictability and and determinism aren't mutually exclusive. The "reliable path taken" could depend on solving the Halting problem, for instance, which we can't do but perhaps our natural laws somehow can. But even if that's immaterial, it's not clear that determinism has any relevance to free will at all. You, like many others, have simply assumed that the "free" aspect of free will implicitly means "freedom from antecedent causes", but the long debate over free will in philosophy casts this interpretation in serious doubt.
- isotropy 10y ago>whether that specific machine halts still has a deterministic, well-defined answer Really? If there is literally no procedure that can tell the difference between "machines that will never halt" and "machines that will run longer than you can afford to wait", you're basically calling for a concept of "deterministic" where it's ok if a final determination never happens, and in some cases (which you can't identify), can't happen. That seems like it's counter to the spirit of calling something deterministic.
- naasking 10y agoJust because there's no general algorithm to determine whether Turing machine X may halt, does not preclude the existence of specific Turing machines that can determine whether X will halt. This is part of the difference between truth and proof. Whether X will halt is true or false regardless of whether to use can prove it to be true or false in any given logic.
- quickben 10y agoSpeed of nerve impulse through tissue: Up to 120 m/s Add to that muscle charging time. Add to that tissue acceleration. Etc. The fact that the brain decided 200 [ms] before the finger moved is just plain newtonian physics in the macro world. But, modern journalism just have to hype it.
- criddell 10y agoI think http://www.nature.com/neuro/journal/v11/n5/abs/nn.2112.html http://www.nature.com/neuro/journal/v11/n5/abs/nn.2112.html is a better experiment. The outcome is predictable 7-10 seconds before the person "decides".
- quickben 10y agoYou will forgive me, but I'm too skeptical. This summarizes my feelings about the 'predictability' of these studies: https://www.theguardian.com/science/2015/aug/27/study-delivers-bleak-verdict-on-validity-of-psychology-experiment-results https://www.theguardian.com/science/2015/aug/27/study-delive... As far as proofs go, there are few elegant free will thought experiments, may it be from philosophical, spiritual or scientific approach/kind, that are actually all for some level of free will in this system we live in. But anything that have people guess something, and then conclude if free will exist or doesn't, just fails bunch of working techniques we have to coming to conclusions from experiments.
- criddell 10y agoI can't think of a non-magical mechanism for free will and so isn't the simpler solution (Occam's Razor) simply that it doesn't exist?
- coldtea 10y agoWell, if you knew the entire state, you could predict which path will be taken. What I said was that that the "agent" having the "free will" in a person can be larger than their conscious layer. Our brains are still ours (and define us) even if we don't consciously know everything they do or all information they keep at all times.