3 ms·
This article significantly misrepresents the study. It says that children prefer to read on paper than on devices, which indicates that children were asked abou
by gnicholas 10y ago
This article significantly misrepresents the study. It says that children prefer to read on paper than on devices, which indicates that children were asked about their preferences, or asked about habits that are likely to reveal their preferences. This is not the case.
Subjects were never asked which they liked better, and the underlying research report clearly indicates that the differences in their behavior between reading on screen and on paper could be due to their lack of awareness of where to get free ebooks.
Since kids don't have credit cards, they wouldn't be able to buy Kindle books, and might not even have an account. So looking at observational data about what kids use to read books is not a good way to determine what kids "prefer" in this instance. You'd have to give kids the same books in paper and on digital and then see which one they end up reading.
The underlying research is fine, and appropriately nuanced. The article describing it is misleading clickbait.
- pharrington 10y agoThe research's starting point is literally treating all iPads and all Kindles as the same device. It is not appropriately nuanced.
- aaron695 10y agoBoth the article and the research is a giant cliché. Neither seems to have a basic understanding of either technology or even perceptions of technology. >Challenging the assumption that all young people prefer to read on screens Who believes this? They don't seem to source this claim. It's seems like academic karma whoring. State people believe something they don't actually believe, disprove it so you get karma.