2 ms·
I agree with all of that. Part of the question is whether cyber activities are domestic in nature or foreign. While it might seem like a moot point to folks fr
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
I agree with all of that.
Part of the question is whether cyber activities are domestic in nature or foreign. While it might seem like a moot point to folks from other countries, we make a distinction about which agencies can do what and where. There needs to be some thinking about how an actual cyber war would happen. Would Air Force personnel physically take out internet backbones located inside the Continental U.S.? Would they serve search warrants? If not, would they direct the FBI to do so? Can they detain or investigate people?
We focus on the logical structure of a cyber-attack: computers, code, vectors, etc. But there a are a lot of physical components as well, and they can be located anywhere.
I completely agree that the AF is best of all the services to do this. If anything, the eventual solution should probably end up as an equal to DoD and not as a subordinate -- this subject area is just a weird duck when it comes to constitutional law. I just don't think taking the idea of a command and applying it here makes much sense. Sounds like the old "I have the solution, what is your problem" scenario.
And I can't get into your second point without becoming uncomfortable. Yes, we're not talking some kind of loose collaboration. But there's a long way from simple collaboration with industry to having a GS-12 potentially decide the fate of billions of dollars of e-commerce. The career track here does not match at all with the other services.
Or to put this in a personal story, I knew a guy who worked with very sensitive information for the Navy back in the day. He had a PhD from MIT and never wore a Navy uniform. He showed up to work everyday in sandals and Bermuda shorts. While he was incredibly effective for the Navy, he also did not fit into the traditional roles at DoD whatsoever. They had an inspection and he was supposed to have a uniform. He had no idea what a uniform looked like or how to wear one, and it was quite an adventure making it all happen on time. All of the paperwork and procedures the Navy required made absolutely no sense to him -- so he had other people take care of it.
Now you can get away with this for a while in small isolated units where the rest of the organization can "cover" for them, but it's another thing entirely if 90% of the guys doing the work don't fit into the cookie-cutter mold they are supposed to.
An organization structured to hone young people into super responsible war-fighting roles, doing so in ways it has learned in wars since Sparta, is going to have a lot of problems with the people, personalities, and experiences necessary to fulfill this particular mission. In my opinion.
EDIT: Or to put this in terms of my original joke, which was meant to be insightful, I'm not so sure that an organization dedicated to cyber warfare needs to be part of the armed forces.
- tptacek 16y agoYour second graf is very sensible and raises many of the big questions here. At the same time: the threat we're talking about is very real --- it may be the most cost-effective way to hit the US today. We've done much dumber things in the name of national security than anything the "Cyber Command" could possibly execute on. We're way behind the eight ball here --- at least in terms of the stuff we're allowed to know about --- and I think it's probably best to reserve criticism until we actually have something up and running to oversee.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoI like criticism, so I'll take issue there, but for the rest of your comment I wish I could upvote you about a dozen times. And that may be the first time that has happened :)
- tptacek 16y agoThe problem I have is that the notion of "cyber war" is so open-ended, and runs from immediate practical reality to pure science fiction, that a discussion of a "Cyber Command" is just going to waste a lot of time on BS like the government's secret plan to take over civilian computing systems, or to install spyware on everyone's computer. Irony: the crazy-sounding stuff, like remote-destroying people's pacemakers or turning off the power to a whole country --- more plausible than the government takeover of the Internet.