4 ms·
Other than the fact that it seems mind-boggling, is there any reason to believe that time travel is forbidden by the laws of physics, or that causality is an ab
by pavel_lishin 10y ago
Other than the fact that it seems mind-boggling, is there any reason to believe that time travel is forbidden by the laws of physics, or that causality is an absolute?
- M_Grey 10y agoYou've heard of the progress of entropy and the "thermodynamic arrow of time" right? Time travel into the past, violating causality... it breaks the math used to formulate the most basic physics at a very fundamental level.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoDoes that mean that it's impossible, or that our current model of physics simply doesn't account for causality violations? We got along okay with Newton until Einstein came along and upgraded the model.
- M_Grey 10y agoDefinitely the latter, there's no way to say it's impossible, just incredibly unlikely. It's easy to imagine a universe in which it is possible, and that universe could be consistent with the math. The big "but" however is that our universe has none of the features we'd expect from one with the necessary curvature or exotic matter/energy. Does that make sense? I mean, if we discover that there are multiple universes, or that Block Universe is true.... who knows? Even then however, I suspect we'd run into something like Novikov Self-Consistency Principle, or we'd have noticed time travel by now.
- openasocket 10y agoTime travel isn't forbidden. At least, there are solutions to the Einstein field equations that allow for the existence of wormholes between two points in space-time. But that doesn't mean there are wormholes in our universe, or that wormholes could be created (that last part is a little tricky, it's not easy to talk about causality when dealing with time travel). There could well be other laws of physics that prevent time travel, but general relativity seems to allow it.
- M_Grey 10y agoIt's a solution that assumes things like a perfectly uniform sphere of gas collapsing from infinity (Schwarzschild geometry), without any angular momentum. Even then, the ERB isn't traversable. A lot of the talk around wormholes and time travel suffers from map-territory issues. For example, if you look at the maximally extended Schwarzschild geometry (the Kruskal-Szekeres extension) you see two asymptotically flat regions of spacetime connected by a "wormhole". It's probably just an artifact of the model though, and not anything physical. A lot of the, "Math allows" stuff probably falls into that category, which is why when it comes to relativistic masses and velocities, you can't ignore quantum effects either.
- adrianN 10y agoPersonally, I like to believe that NP hard problems can be solved efficiently in our universe. If time travel is possible, PSPACE can be solved efficiently. That is a pretty good argument for me that time travel is not possible. http://www.scottaaronson.com/papers/ctc.pdf http://www.scottaaronson.com/papers/ctc.pdf
- M_Grey 10y agoThat's an interesting perspective I've never considered, coming at it from the physics end of things. I appreciate what amounts to a much more grounded and logical take on why time travel makes so little sense, and is so hard to consider seriously.