3 ms·
...but isn't a strong military one of the very few things that even libertarians agree we should be letting the government take care of? A fact, which is often
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
...but isn't a strong military one of the very few things that even libertarians agree we should be letting the government take care of?
A fact, which is often lost in modern political discussions: goals != results. One can oppose a law or program because of poor implementation (or expected poor implementation) even while agreeing with it's goals.
For instance, I favor some banking regulation to reduce leverage and the possibility of contagion. However, I oppose the particular bill currently likely to be passed, because it makes speculation (particularly shorts) more difficult and codifies bailouts/government forced bankruptcy into law. Similarly, I expect the author of this article favors national defense, but opposes this program since it appears to be ineffective and potentially harmful.
- lallysingh 16y agoOTOH, I'm also tired of complaints about the way something is run without presenting a reasonable alternative. Complaining is easy.
- tptacek 16y agoIf anything, the most painful complaint you can make about the modern military's role in information security is their lack of involvement. We're far more likely to lose billions of dollars due to a concerted attack on our utilities or financial markets than China is. So, while I see what you're saying, I don't think it's a coherent response to my comment or the article.
- CWuestefeld 16y agothe most painful complaint you can make about the modern military's role in information security is their lack of involvement. On the contrary. Given that the Internet is the creation of DARPA, indeed, was once called "ARPAnet", they're already up to their eyeballs. And to their credit, they've done an excellent job. I don't have citations handy, but I recall reading over the past year about many supposed "cyber attacks", yet for the most part, we all go about our business and surfing without even noticing that anything was going on. The folks that designed the protocols on which this network runs (everything from ethernet through TCP/IP through DNS) did a phenomenal job. The network just may be the most robust thing ever engineered by man. So perhaps they've already done their job. The front-loaded engineering gave us something that can withstand huge amounts of abuse, and so doesn't require an army (literally) to babysit it.
- tptacek 16y agoYou and I aren't having the same conversation. I tend to agree with everything you just said, but the issue isn't the government's role in running the Internet. It's the government's role in offensive and defensive computer security. In other words: it's preventing China from paying 20 year olds to shut down the power grid (note: plausible) and directing research that would allow us to do that to China.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIn your comment, you suggested that even libertarians (such as the author) should be supporting a strong military: "... isn't a strong military one of the very few things that even libertarians agree we should be letting the government take care of?" This article doesn't address that issue one way or the other. All they do is criticize a specific program for having poorly defined goals and for (by their estimation) it's significant odds of collateral damage.