2 ms·
The Martin M-130 was the main plane Pan-Am used to establish the first cross pacific passenger service. Three were built exclusively for Pan-Ams cross pacific s
by valuearb 10y ago
The Martin M-130 was the main plane Pan-Am used to establish the first cross pacific passenger service. Three were built exclusively for Pan-Ams cross pacific service started in 1936, offering one flight per week.
The Hawaiian Clipper disappeared in the pacific with all hands in 1938. PanAm also used the Sikorsky S-42 on shorter legs, one exploded in mid-air in Pago Pago same year. The other two Martins crashed with heavy fatalities in 1942 & 1945, 100% loss rates. Pan-Ams ten Sikorskies had at least five fatal accidents for a 50%+ loss rate.
They were replaced by the Boeing 314, 12 were made, 3 crashed for a 25% loss rate. They were all taken out of service by Pan-Am quickly after WWII, so Pan-Ams total fatal accident rate for its seaplanes was around 45% in only about 13 total years of service for all types.
Despite this Pan-Am was hugely successful at establishing profitable ocean crossing passenger flights and changed the world doing it.
People will take a lot more risk to reach new worlds, if we only let them.
- vkou 10y agoAssuming each plane flew 1-3 times a week, for 13 years... That would be 600-2000 flights. If half the planes crashed, that would give them a failure rate of 0.1-0.025%. The Space Shuttle (Also a second generation vehicle) had a failure rate of 1.5%. The Souyz (Widely considered to be the most reliable launch system, with a successful launch rate of 97.3%) had 2 accidents which killed everyone on board - out of 136 launches. Also a failure rate of ~1.5%.
- valuearb 10y agoYour estimates are a bit off. Each plane didn't fly for 13 years, on average they flew 5 or 6 years. And the pacific routes were only once a week until the first crash, and Pan Am didn't replace it, just flew the route 3 times a month. Edit: The pacific route was nearly a week long, so obviously if you count each leg separately percentages were better, but passengers had to fly every leg to reach their destination, unless they wanted to be marooned on a remote island. And your failure rates are backwards looking. Flying boats before 1938 certainly had even worse safety records than post 1938, so the first passengers on Pan Am flights had worse safety expectations. Counting legs separately would be like saying the Shuttle actually made 270 trips, 135 up and 135 down. The Falcon 9 and Heavy are likely far safer than the Shuttle, which was a clearly unsafe design, from the rube goldberg melding of solid and liquid rockets to a crew cabin with no abort systems, and unproven reentry shielding on a shape that accentuated the dangers of its use. Falcons are a refinement of proven launch technologies, combined with a much safer crew compartment with excellent abort features and using proven reentry shielding/shape. Odds are it's far safer than the shuttle. Only 10% of Magelleons crew survived the circumnavigation of the world, yet explorers lined up to follow. If SpaceX offered rides to Mars with a 20% chance of death, there would be a waiting list of hundreds of thousands of people. In reality it shouldn't be too hard to reduce launch safety risk by a factor of 10 from historical launches. The Dragon capsule can almost add that improvement by itself.