4 ms·
It's too easy to bash recruiters on HN. They exist because people want jobs and employers give them money to find people.
by andrewstuart 10y ago
It's too easy to bash recruiters on HN. They exist because people want jobs and employers give them money to find people.
- averagewall 10y agoExactly. When I used to be looking for work, I never liked being the one trying to hound companies begging for work. Some people are suited to that kind of work and some aren't. It makes perfect sense for people to specialize so programmers do programming and recruiters do job matching.
- matthewmacleod 10y agoI appreciate the value in theory, but practically tech recruitment seems to be a bit silly. Recruiters have a habit of cornering the market; if they have all the best candidates on their books, employers are almost obliged to indulge what's effectively rent-seeking behaviour. Ideally it would be much better if qualified candidates speak directly to employers and lose the go-between, who doesn't add a huge amount of value (though they can to some extent take a bit of the work out for the candidate, and possible negotiate salary and benefits more forcefully). To me the much bigger problem in tech recruitment is the difficulty of finding permanent staff rather than contractors. I don't know what the state of the market is in the US, but in London good permanent staff are becoming as rare as hens' teeth. The natural outcome of a seller's market, I suppose.
- user5994461 10y agoThere are many companies that you cannot enter without going through a recruiters or an employee referring you.
- smsm42 10y agoThey have potential to add huge value for candidates. I.e., if I looked for a job, I'd appreciate somebody to take the annoying part - scheduling, initial talking/pitching, resume sending, introductions, filtering out obvious mismatches, negotiating good terms, etc. - and only do the actual interviewing and deciding. But from what I hear, most recruiters are underqualified to do that, and/or prefer to play simple numbers game - spam enough people and you may get lucky.
- objclxt 10y ago> They exist because people want jobs and employers give them money to find people Sure. Some recruiters are great. But third party recruitment is a sales led industry. You're under constant pressure to close the deal and make the sale. Salespeople do not always behave honestly or ethically. I have worked with some great third party recruiters who sourced me good candidates. But I also have come across a large number of, for want of a better word, scumbags and hustlers.
- SilasX 10y agoObviously, there is a vital function to be performed here. No one's disputing that a recruiter can add value, only that in practice, the tech recruiters are horrible at their job and accomplish nothing other than nebulous keyword matching, and overhyping some other party's qualifications. They produce very bad matches and just add an extra level of annoyance.