4 ms·
Not really, having a rootkit on a device allows you to bypass anything this is a given. Wikileaks tweets are also quite demagogic and are tailored for maximum
by dogma1138 10y ago
Not really, having a rootkit on a device allows you to bypass anything this is a given.
Wikileaks tweets are also quite demagogic and are tailored for maximum effect, these "techniques" do not actually allow the CIA to bypass the encryption, bypassing the encryption is a whole other thing completely what it does is allow the CIA to read anything on the phone and use any of it's hardware sensors.
Overall the problem with this leak specifically it that there is so far nothing damning, this is exactly the toolkit a modern intelligence agency should have, in fact this is likely to kiddy stuff not the rogue nation targeting kinetic payloads.
What it doesn't show is who these tools target, if Wikileaks to be believed the NSA only targets journalists and human rights activists whilst in reality this isn't the case.
Unlike the NSA the CIA is also not interested in mass surveillance, the CIA produces intelligence analysis primarily revolving around humint sources and targets, which means that their operations tend to be much more targeted a SIGINT agency which relies on bulk data collection.
- recursive 10y ago> bypassing the encryption is a whole other thing completely what it does is allow the CIA to read anything on the phone and use any of it's hardware sensors I really cannot understand the difference between "bypassing" the encryption and allowing the CIA to read anything on the phone. Those sound like trivial synonyms.
- dogma1138 10y agoBypassing encryption means that you are actually bypassing the encryption method, e.g. fooling WhatsApp to not encrypt and not alert the user, forcing WhatsApp to use a specific key again without alerting the user, finding a way to access the clear text messages in the service itself etc. Reading the clear text pre or post description isn't bypassing encryption because this can be done regardless of the type or method of encryption used. If I beat you with a wrench until you tell me your password it doesn't mean I managed to bypass the encryption of your password manager.
- recursive 10y agoThe definition of bypass seems to be exactly the opposite of what you're saying. Here's one. "a secondary channel, pipe, or connection to allow a flow when the main one is closed or blocked" I understand bypass to mean "go around" basically. So if I bypass something, I have found a way to avoid it. I really think this is the common usage.
- revelation 10y agoYou burn a strawman to explain what bypass means then suggest hooking an app to extract data before encryption after gaining code execution is not bypassing. You took a wrong turn here somewhere. I'm not really interested in another repeat of the "there is nothing here" discussion. We seem to get that for each of these releases; lots of people swarming in to tell us they were perfectly aware of all these things since, well, forever.
- rfrank 10y ago> ...these "techniques" do not actually allow the CIA to bypass the encryption... The definition of the word bypass is, "a secondary channel, pipe, or connection to allow a flow when the main one is closed or blocked." How is a rootkit not bypassing encryption? It doesn't break encryption. > Unlike the NSA the CIA is also not interested in mass surveillance... Why do you believe this to be true? > Overall the problem with this leak specifically it that there is so far nothing damning The wholesale violation of 4th Amendment protections isn't damning to you?
- hackuser 10y ago> wholesale violation of 4th Amendment protections Where is there a violation of the 4th Amendment? The 4th Amendment is not about capabilities, which always have existed in one form or another (e.g., reading people's mail), but about legal authorization to use them.
- rfrank 10y agoIn the warrantless wiretapping of US citizens. I do not agree with the court system's rubber stamping of surveillance of the entire US population, and think it and anyone who supports it are disgusting.
- willstrafach 10y ago> rubber stamping of surveillance of the entire US population It would be good to post specific evidence of such a major claim. What "rubber stamping" are you referring to? What are you defining "surveillance" as? I cannot find a solid source for the specific claim above.
- asimpletune 10y agoHe's probably referring to the FISA court. IRC they only turned down a few request and they operate under a secret interpretation of the patriot act.