4 ms·

Very cool - any thoughts on the relative strengths and weaknesses of the FLIR vs Seek models?

by graedus 10y ago

wlesieutre 10y ago
No personal experience with either. But my quick internet impression: the FLIR's main advantage is that it has a second (higher resolution) visible light camera, which it uses to add an edge detail overlay to the image. The disadvantage is that it has its own battery and has to be recharged. http://www.phonearena.com/news/Battle-of-the-thermal-imaging-cameras-FLIR-ONE-vs-Seek-Thermal-Compact_id78033 http://www.phonearena.com/news/Battle-of-the-thermal-imaging...
bradknowles 10y ago
The problem I had with the Seek model was that it connected to my phone via a Lightning connector, and there was no good way to ensure that connection remained solid. Dropped the thing the same day I got it, and it broke. Haven't tried one since. It's also hard to use them if you have any kind of a case on your phone. If I had one that worked via Bluetooth or Wifi, or was built into a phone case, or had a longer cable that I could route around my existing case, then I might give it another try. Short of that, I'm looking forward to the standalone model.
- wlesieutre 10y ago
  FLIR's upcoming model looks like you can twist a knob to extend the lightning plug, so it should handle cases better than either of the existing ones.
- wlesieutre 10y ago
  Re: camera built into phone case, also worth mentioning that the very first version of the FLIR One was a camera integrated into an iPhone 5/5S case. The obvious downside of this is that if you replace your phone with a new model you can't use the camera anymore. This particular design may have a second lease on life if you go to an iPhone SE, but a lot more people moved to the 6/6S/7/7S which won't be compatible. Standalone versions have been around for years with a really wide array of designs for different purposes (industrial, security, testing, most recently lightweight UAV cameras). For the standalone cameras you pay a bit more because it can't bum off the phone's screen, storage, input, and all that. The TG165 at $350 looks to be the low end unless I'm missing something. No way to browse their site by prices. http://www.flir.com/instruments/tg165/ http://www.flir.com/instruments/tg165/

Very cool - any thoughts on the relative strengths and weaknesses of the FLIR vs Seek models?

by graedus 10y ago

Very cool - any thoughts on the relative strengths and weaknesses of the FLIR vs Seek models?

No personal experience with either. But my quick internet impression: the FLIR's main advantage is that it has a second (higher resolution) visible light camera, which it uses to add an edge detail overlay to the image. The disadvantage is that it has its own battery and has to be recharged. http://www.phonearena.com/news/Battle-of-the-thermal-imaging-cameras-FLIR-ONE-vs-Seek-Thermal-Compact_id78033 http://www.phonearena.com/news/Battle-of-the-thermal-imaging...

bradknowles 10y ago

The problem I had with the Seek model was that it connected to my phone via a Lightning connector, and there was no good way to ensure that connection remained solid. Dropped the thing the same day I got it, and it broke. Haven't tried one since. It's also hard to use them if you have any kind of a case on your phone. If I had one that worked via Bluetooth or Wifi, or was built into a phone case, or had a longer cable that I could route around my existing case, then I might give it another try. Short of that, I'm looking forward to the standalone model.

wlesieutre 10y ago
FLIR's upcoming model looks like you can twist a knob to extend the lightning plug, so it should handle cases better than either of the existing ones.
wlesieutre 10y ago
Re: camera built into phone case, also worth mentioning that the very first version of the FLIR One was a camera integrated into an iPhone 5/5S case. The obvious downside of this is that if you replace your phone with a new model you can't use the camera anymore. This particular design may have a second lease on life if you go to an iPhone SE, but a lot more people moved to the 6/6S/7/7S which won't be compatible. Standalone versions have been around for years with a really wide array of designs for different purposes (industrial, security, testing, most recently lightweight UAV cameras). For the standalone cameras you pay a bit more because it can't bum off the phone's screen, storage, input, and all that. The TG165 at $350 looks to be the low end unless I'm missing something. No way to browse their site by prices. http://www.flir.com/instruments/tg165/ http://www.flir.com/instruments/tg165/