4 ms·
The article addresses this exact form of argument in a manner that I find compelling: > There’s one final problem with these kinds of arguments, and that is th
by CydeWeys 10y ago
The article addresses this exact form of argument in a manner that I find compelling:
> There’s one final problem with these kinds of arguments, and that is the implication that we should be worried by the possibility of poor people buying the occasional steak, lottery ticket or, yes, even an iPhone. Set aside the fact that a better cut of meat may be more nutritious than a meal Chaffetz would approve of, or the fact that a smartphone may be your only access to email, job notices, benefit applications, school work and so on. Why do we begrudge people struggling to get by the occasional indulgence? Why do we so little value pleasure and joy? Why do we insist that if you are poor, you should also be miserable? Why do we require penitence?
- jacquesm 10y agoOr even simpler: why do people whose net worth is likely >> $100K begrudge someone whose net worth is < $1000 their only expensive item?
- M_Grey 10y agoI think it offends them on a basic level... after all it makes their silly purchases so much more obviously silly. It probably explains why at high income levels, people still collect so much useless shit just for the sake of having it. It's also why there's a $10,000 iPhone, or ones you get crusted with jewels. The aristocracy is always seeking to distinguish themselves from the "Nouveau", and far more so from the "peasants". That's not a nice thing to think though, so it's rapidly sent through cognitive/ideological/religious filters and produces a more agreeable output for the thinker.
- Banthum 10y agoDoesn't work, though. An iPhone is not an "occasional indulgence". Fancy chocolates, or a meal at a mid-tier restaurant are an "occasional indulgence". An iPhone is a massive class-signaling purchase that requires expensive ongoing payments to use.
- scaryspooky 10y agoUh, no. Ting supports iPhones and they have $6/mo plus pay as you go. That isn't an "expensive ongoing payment" at all. https://ting.com https://ting.com
- vilmosi 10y agoMost people buy $200 iPhones with massive monthly bills, at least in the US. I don't know if that changed yet.
- parenthephobia 10y agoDo you think it's possible that most poor people don't do that, though? Who do you think the $6/mo deals are made for?
- vilmosi 10y agoI would have thought poor people are more likely to do that because they can't afford the upfront cost of the phone. I mean, I don't have any data, feel free to prove me wrong. But when I was a poor student, I wouldn't even dream of buying a smartphone outright, yet alone an iPhone. And I had a look, those $6/month contracts barely subsidise anything. I don't really get what's relevant about them.
- scaryspooky 10y agoYou can buy a used iphone cheap and get ting. As a bare minimum of needing a phone to get a job anymore this is one of the cheapest options.
- jacquesm 10y ago> a massive class-signaling purchase So here we have the heart of the problem. You begrudge those who you feel are not in your class their ability to lower the value of your signal. Maybe you should stop seeing phones as 'class signaling devices' but see them instead as small portable computers that you can make phonecalls with.
- vilmosi 10y agoWell having a non-iPhone is not really a "miserable" existence...
- vilmosi 10y agoWell having a non-iPhone is not really a "miserable" existence...