5 ms·
It's the illegal immigrants that suck the system dry, not the smart, diligent, legitimate ones working in academia and top companies. That sounds like a grossl
by mindcrime 10y ago
It's the illegal immigrants that suck the system dry, not the smart, diligent, legitimate ones working in academia and top companies.
That sounds like a grossly inaccurate generalization to me. A lot of "illegal immigrants" are an absolutely essential part of the economy, performing jobs like picking oranges in the Florida heat/humidity, doing roofing work, washing dishes, etc. Interview farmers in the south and ask them how many American born workers are willing to even take many farm jobs.
These people most definitely are not "sucking the system dry". And a system that can be "sucked dry" has a design flaw which should be rectified anyway.
- immigraway 10y agoIt seems that each largish country has plenty of natives skilled enough and willing to do physical labor. It's the safety net at the base of the workforce. Forcing them to compete on a global labor market drives down wages and creates a bunch of social problems. There are a ton of countries we generally view as being more "progressive" than the USA (Canada! Australia!) that have much stricter immigration standards for low-skilled labor. Consequently, the wage that the bottom of the workforce gets in those places is much higher. Now, top intellectual talent is in scarce supply around the globe and I hope the US competes for that.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoThis is already happening: California Farmers Backed Trump, but Now Fear Losing Field Workers https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/09/us/california-farmers-backed-trump-but-now-fear-losing-field-workers.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/09/us/california-farmers-bac... I don't know why its so uncomfortable for conservatives to admit that illegals play a role in our economy[1]. If they didn't they wouldn't be here as the market would choose against them. This is why Democrats have been fighting for amnesty programs for long time illegals, to keep this labor and the work it does here. Native borns aren't fighting to pick oranges for 12 hours a day at minimum wage, but these guys will and do. On top of the moral argument that these people have kids here and are rooted in our culture and schools and dragging their parents off to Mexico and breaking up families is just inhumane. Thus far Trump has not addressed any of this. He has a "jail and deport 'em at high noon" attitude that does no one any good. Disregarding the labor they do is foolish just as Trump supporting California farmers are starting to learn. [1] The only people I know who are definitely employing illegals are a white wealthy couple with an illegal Mexican nanny. Funny how that works.
- Mikeb85 10y ago> Native borns aren't fighting to pick oranges for 12 hours a day at minimum wage, but these guys will and do. An economist would say it's because the wage being offered is too low. Businesses don't get to have access to unlimited labour at whatever wage they choose in a market economy.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoYet they're not all illegals. Natives of Mexican heritage and others of the poorest class perform this work at this wage. Regardless, why aren't we jailing those who hire these people and cause these problems then? Oh right, they're Trump loyalists, political donors, and white.
- Mikeb85 10y agoPrices are set on the margins. Any illegals in the system will drive wages down.
- remarkEon 10y ago>I don't know why its so uncomfortable for conservatives to admit that illegals play a role in our economy[1]. I guess I'd call myself a conservative (I think) and I don't get uncomfortable at all admitting that, but that doesn't mean that the fact they do "play a role" is right or correct. You're implying something that I think is quite dangerous: that the US economy can't function unless we allow people to break our laws to be here. That sounds like a caste system by another name. I genuinely don't understand arguments from the left that attempt to minimize the importance of State Sovereignty in the context of these debates. "Native borns" used to be able to find that work...until we started importing illegal immigrants willing to work for fractions of the cost.
- rukittenme 10y ago> And a system that can be "sucked dry" has a design flaw which should be rectified anyway. This is politics not engineering. Flaws are part of the design. Every flaw is designed to appease one group or another. Restricting access on any arbitrary basis would lead to calls of racism, xenophobia, class warfare, etc. > Interview farmers in the south and ask them how many American born workers are willing to even take many farm jobs. Working hard is not the issue. Working in the heat is not the issue. Plenty of American citizens do that. The issue is of pay. Southern farmers can not afford to pay above minimum wage which is why they sometimes resort to hiring illegal immigrants or prisoners. Why can't they pay more than minimum? Because they're competing against border states, like California, who have: illegal immigrants working below minimum wage, large economies with well developed public infrastructure, and the greater take of federal and state subsidies.
- zzleeper 10y agoThey are also competing with other countries that might be better equipped to produce those goods (e.g. Chile might have cheaper labor, and better water/soil/climate) for some types of fruits. Without subsidies or this cheap labor, a lot of agr. would cease to be profitable.
- ng12 10y ago> A lot of "illegal immigrants" are an absolutely essential part of the economy, performing jobs like picking oranges in the Florida heat/humidity, doing roofing work, washing dishes, etc This is what kind of gets me though. Supporting illegal immigration is supporting indentured servitude. I've especially noticed it in NYC, it boils down to "I'll support your right to stay here as long as I can still find a $6 burrito and a cheap nanny".
- vinay427 10y agoThat's not entirely fair. If the immigrant feels that they have a better life as a low-wage worker in the US (keep in mind many are escaping violent or oppressive surroundings) then I won't be the judge of that by imposing artificial limits on livelihood. We can at least acknowledge that we are improving the lives of those immigrants for whom this is the case.
- remarkEon 10y agoCan we? There doesn't appear to be a limiting principle in your argument.
- sanguine234 10y ago$6 salary cannot support any family, even if you are living in the cheapest part of the country. Here is what illegals do once they get in, Crime statistics: 611,234 unique crimes in Texas from 2008 to 2014 https://pjmedia.com/jchristianadams/2015/7/23/alien-crime-wave-in-texas-611234-crimes-2993-murders/ https://pjmedia.com/jchristianadams/2015/7/23/alien-crime-wa... There are real innocent humans who suffer and pay price because some greedy wants cheap labor in his farm or restaurant. For these common people, illegals live among them and these normal law abiding and tax paying citizens unfortunately do not have high walls around their houses like elites in silicon valley, hollywood or upper west side of New York. Does anyone give that a thought? specially those who want sanctuary cities.
- illumin8 10y agoMy grandfather owned many apple orchards, and he said without migrant labor, he would have had to go out of business years ago. He could not hire US citizens as workers because nobody that is born here wants to climb trees all day picking fruit for minimum wage. This was back in the 80s. He also had very good things to say about how hard-working and dedicated the migrant workers were. Now, you might argue that without migrant labor, he should just pay a decent wage, but what is a decent wage for hard manual labor? Would you be ok with paying $10 an apple at the grocery store because someone was paid $30-40 an hour to pick them? The narrative that illegal immigrants are all criminals is deeply flawed and inaccurate.
- err4nt 10y ago> He could not hire US citizens as workers because nobody that is born here wants to climb trees all day picking fruit for minimum wage. Then he may have to pay over minimum wage!
- komali2 10y agoThen he would have to charge 10$/apple at the store, his follow-up point.
- illumin8 10y agoAnd, I'm not saying this is wrong, but it appears to me that most people living here have voted with their wallet. If you compare food prices in nordic countries where labor is more fairly priced, you'll see how dramatically more expensive everything is.
- kylestlb 10y agoI'd love to see a formal study on how often Americans "go out" for food rather than buy from a grocery and cook it themselves. In Scandinavia, the cost difference between eating-in and going-out is much, much larger than here in the USA.
- 10y ago
- tropo 10y agoIt's funny how the left is all about living wages except when illegal aliens are involved. Evidently, near-slavery is acceptable for these people. If we didn't have them, wages would rise, and Americans would in fact perform these jobs. It's notable also that some of the worst-affected Americans happen to be black, and that wealthy liberals aren't hiring black housekeepers. It's as if there might be some fear of certain Americans, so we find foreigners to hire instead.