5 ms·
The obvious question is will the US government allow one of its most profitable states to leave? Highly doubtful. Great way to start another civil war, though!
by komali2 10y ago
The obvious question is will the US government allow one of its most profitable states to leave? Highly doubtful. Great way to start another civil war, though!
- immigraway 10y agoI think a red government will let a blue state leave (permanent electoral majority). I don't think the same would be true the other way around, because progressive values are more, shall we say, evangelical than those of the nationalists.
- illumin8 10y agoIt actually doesn't matter what California voters want, or what a red federal government wants, a constitutional amendment would require 2/3rds of both the house and senate, as well as 75% of all the US state legislatures to approve Calexit. I think it's a good idea, and would probably move there if they did exit, but it's practically impossible for it to happen.
- caf 10y ago(permanent electoral majority) That's not how a two-party system works. Over time, the positions of the parties would adjust until a new equilibrium was reached.
- dang 10y agoYou can't do single-purpose political accounts here. Also, trolling with a username is trolling. We've banned this account.
- fixxer 10y agoI hear a lot of people in my area (West burbs of Chicago) joke about building the wall up to cut off California. Sure, they're joking, but I don't think the average citizen outside CA gives a damn about the state as a tax revenue base. They do, however, get tired of the far left rhetoric. Nobody thinks more highly about California than Californians. Personally, I am ambivalent (and technically I am a Californian).
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoOnly in the US could middle of the road Keynesian economics with a touch of social liberalism be called "far left" Good grief.
- fixxer 10y agoThe flip side of that sentiment is calling fascism on anyone who thinks sanctuary cities are bullshit. The lunacy is bipartisan.
- komali2 10y agoI could make a strong argument, however, that a government seeking to strip the ability of states (cities) to have "sanctuary status" is fascist, or at the very least not very republican.
- fixxer 10y agoInternational borders fall under federal jurisdiction, so I don't think your point is as strong as you think, but I'll play this game... So, you support states rights? Tell me why abortion is a federal issue then?
- lazyasciiart 10y ago> International borders fall under federal jurisdiction, so I don't think your point is as strong as you think, Sanctuary cities don't change anything about international borders or who can enter the country, because international borders are federal issues with federal staff. Sanctuary cities refuse to make their local staff spend time and money reporting on immigration status every time they issue a parking ticket. It's not even a states rights question - nobody even suggests that city officials should check if you have paid your federal taxes every time you take to them, but that's not because (normal) people are objecting to a federally run tax system.
- kolbe 10y agoI'm sure Cali would be able to leave, they just wouldn't be able to take their assets with them.
- komali2 10y agoOutside oil and crops, California assets are people, yea? Engineers.
- tropo 10y agoHere: You get the entire Los Angeles basin. You get most of the Bay Area: the area served by BART, Berkeley, things west of Berkeley, and Marin County. You also get everything in the middle. Generally the border runs along the ridge of the coastal mountains. The USA keeps San Diego, Eureka, Davis, Fresno, etc. You get exclusive rights to the "California" name. The USA will split the leftover bits into at least 3 states.
- kolbe 10y agosure. you keep the engineers, we'll add all of the stock owned by Californian's in US companies to the Fed's balance sheet. We'll keep the infrastructure and apply tolls liberally. Obviously National Park/Forrest and even state parks will stay. You can visit for a fee, of course.
- bbarn 10y agoThe better question is would the rest of the world allow the remaining US to do a damn thing about it? The US itself has a history of supporting states that leave other states in civil wars.