11 ms·
Upgrade your jail cell for a price
- david-cako 10y agoCan't wait for prisons to start selling life insurance :^)
- ryandrake 10y agoMorbid thought: I'm surprised there isn't a cottage industry around buying life insurance policies on prison inmates. I bet you could use statistical methods and/or machine learning to profitably predict inmates most likely to die early, given the prison location, staff, the inmate's crime, and other factors.
- RubenSandwich 10y agoNot only morbid but I'd argue morally wrong as well, as this would be betting on peoples lives. It's just as awful as the coliseum just without you being exposed to the blood.
- drjesusphd 10y agoHow is this different from life insurance in general?
- mikeash 10y agoIf you can do it, surely the insurance companies can too, and adjust their premiums accordingly.
- username223 10y ago"Vitality default swaps?" ;-) I'm sure someone on Wall Street is already working on it.
- kevinpet 10y agoNot specific to inmates, but in general, yes, investors are willing to make money from buying unwanted life insurance policies. http://www.investopedia.com/articles/pf/07/unwanted_policies.asp http://www.investopedia.com/articles/pf/07/unwanted_policies...
- username223 10y agoColor me not surprised. There are probably "synthetic collateralized death obligations" as well, though I'm sure they have a different name. http://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/syntheticcdo.asp http://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/syntheticcdo.asp
- moomin 10y agoThis is despicable, but the conditions at the average prison are despicable too. Just watch almost any cop show to see how the expectation of prison rape has become normalised in American society.
- boundring 10y agoLet it be known: jail is not prison. Short-term incarceration (less than two years, and that's not an arbitrary figure) leads to much different conditions than long-term incarceration. There's different effects on humans and different changes in valuated needs. Rape tends to be the province of those expecting little to no change in their long-term experience. A little different from murder in incarceration, in that the victim has opportunity for reprisal.
- Fjolsvith 10y agoHollywood has normalized it with their shows. I spent over 10 years in various state and federal prisons and never once was an inmate raped while I was in those facilities. I was present during 3 riots, but rapes, not.
- dsr_ 10y agoEvery argument in favor of letting people with money have a nicer prison experience than those without is an argument in favor of fixing prison problems for every inmate, instead. As a side benefit, you avoid seeing rich people swinging from lampposts instead of serving time.
- Toboe 10y ago> Every argument in favor of letting people with money have a nicer prison experience than those without is an argument in favor of fixing prison problems for every inmate, instead. Uhm, could it be that you have a typo in your posts, like a missing not? Because i have a hard time finding logic in the argument as written.
- logfromblammo 10y agoCop: So would you rather go to The Hoosegow, or The Clink? YT: Hoosegow, no question. Cop: You know, we get a kickback from The Clink for every suspect we bring in. YT: How much do you want? Cop: How about a hundred? Swipe your card through the reader. YT: Done. Enjoy your bribe. Cop: The Clink it is. YT: My union will hear about this.
- gmarx 10y agoI don't see this as especially outrageous. The part that bothers me is that it isn't available to poorer criminals. But I don't agree with the ex-gang fellow who said getting your ass beat is part of the punishment. That seems unfair to weaker criminals in the same way this scheme is unfair to poor ones. I think the state has an obligation to keep inmates physically safe. If physical violence is something we want as an official part of the punishment let's just bring back corporal punishment. Also can't help but notice the problem with making this more widely available. The violence in regular jail is a consequence of being locked up with violent people. If you move them to these easier jails they would bring the violence with them
- mikeash 10y ago> The part that bothers me is that it isn't available to poorer criminals. Isn't that the only part that's even there?
- gmarx 10y agoNo. The article seems mostly intended to generate outrage that bad criminals might get out of the ass-beating experience of real jail and have access to flat screen TVs
- leesalminen 10y agoI think exposing rich people to the same conditions as poor people in jail is extremely important. Monetary wealth translates to social power more often than not. If rich people experience the same jail as poor, they will push in society to improve it. If you let the rich opt-out they'll never see it and won't be motivated to induce change. I have spent a couple nights in jail. I know what it's like, and it's not acceptable for anyone to be exposed to this. Change is needed whether you're rich, poor, black, white or purple.
- gmarx 10y agoI agree in principle but I doubt enough rich people would ever get sent to jail to make a difference.
- sevensor 10y agoWhen I read this in Snow Crash, I thought Neal Stephenson was being deliberately absurd. But here we are. Want to go to The Hoosegow LLC and not The Clink, Incorporated? That'll be an extra $50 a night.
- pjc50 10y agoFirst thing I thought of too. Another example of an extreme parody dystopia becoming reality.
- logfromblammo 10y agoI didn't even bat an eye. This was probably because this is completely sensible and logical in a libertarian/anarchist society. The concept is expanded in other works of dystopic fiction. You pay for the best jail you can afford. If you are found innocent, your accuser/prosecutor has to reimburse your costs. If you are found guilty, you have to pay restitution to your victims (or their still-living representatives), and the justice service provider handling your case will take whatever measures may be appropriate to protect their subscribers from you after your release. If you can't immediately make restitution, there may be a supervised work program around that will help you finance your jail boarding and court judgments. Or maybe the judge will work out a deal to reduce your weregeld bill, perhaps in exchange for something like submitting to a specific torture, or having a warning tattooed across your forehead. If you're a really hard case, you just get named outlaw, and someone kills you for the bounty. For most people, instead of paying taxes to a county, you would pay a subscription fee to a company that provides all-in-one security, dispute resolution, arbitration, rehabilitation, and property and casualty insurance. You might pay $99/month to a reseller agent of Brinks Allstate, and your neighbor might pay $119/month directly to Alfa Pinkertons through their website. If your kid's bike gets stolen, the cop-adjuster comes by to take your report, helps you file your claim, and determines whether it would be cost effective to investigate and prosecute. If they do, and it turns out your neighbor's cousin was operating a bike theft ring out of their garage, the Alfa Pinkertons arrest him, put him in their jail, and provide him with defense counsel. Brinks Allstate and Alfa Pinkerton have a pre-existing extradition agreement in place, engage Wopner-Brown-Scheindlin as their arbitration subcontractor, who in turn sub-subcontracts some jurors from YourPeers. (You might also need to have a separate justice provider through your workplace.) After the neighbor is found guilty, he has to pay back the cost of reimbursing the bike owners. Perhaps a few of them are willing to buy their stolen bikes back with [a portion of] their insurance money. Until his checks clear, he stays in the Alfa Pinkerton jail's sweatshop, working off that debt at $X/hour. After he's out, he goes right back to being that creepy guy living above your neighbor's garage, and his credit score goes back up with that "RESTITUTION PAID IN FULL" line on his report. As bad as this all sounds, our actual, real-life criminal control system is in some ways worse.
- aub3bhat 10y agoHaving seen the horrific rikers beating video. [1] I don't understand why in this day and age, prisons are NOT under 100% CCTV monitoring. Is this just out of sight, out of mind approach? As we debate body-worn cameras to prevent police brutality, ensuring prison and jails are kept under constant surveillance might help reduce recidivism. It's also tragic that there is direct equivalence to the charter/public school debate. A lot of the arguments for/against charters schools can be simply applied by swapping school for prison. And just like test-scores/teaching-philosophy, you have a superior scandinavian approach. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/video/nyregion/100000002996576/footage-of-inmate-beating-at-rikers.html https://www.nytimes.com/video/nyregion/100000002996576/foota...
- leesalminen 10y agoI agree. I know someone who was arrested for being drunk in public (very, very drunk and belligerent). Once at the jail I guess she continued being belligerent. At this point she was restrained on a gurney, surrounded by no less than 4 guards. She said something rude and as a result was tazed not once but 3 times. After I bailed her out we went to the sherrifs office and requested an investigation. After a few days they claimed to not be able to find any video of this happening. They conceded that there are multiple areas where the cameras can't see. I also found out that the guards at the jail are not sheriff deputies, but employed by a private corporation. But they wear the same uniform as the deputies, sans badge. The criminal justice system in this country is disgusting. Truly disgusting. If I'm ever fortunate enough to be financially secure (long term) I plan to dedicate my time to induce change in this area of our society. One interest effect this had on me was respect for local law enforcement. I used to have some level of respect for them and what I had observed as professionalism. That's all out the window now, and I have 0 respect for them. Instead of being polite and reasonable I am now combative and uncooperative in any encounter. They can taser me all they want, Ill just use it as a public campaign against them.
- ythn 10y agoWhat the guards did was wrong, but don't you think your belligerent drunk friend needs to share even a tiny bit of the blame? People act like civilians should be able to do or say literally anything and fully expect law enforcement to be perfectly rational and fair and gentle with them.
- rdiddly 10y agoIf people want a relatively comfortable environment where they can come and go as they please, hold down a job, watch TV etc., I highly recommend having a look at the technique of not committing crimes.
- boundring 10y agoThe common phrase is "If you don't like it, don't get locked up." Most people don't get to pick and choose when they wind up in the wrong situation. It isn't just criminals that get locked up.
- rdiddly 10y agoSave the deluxe jail cells for all those non-criminals then.
- dang 10y agoPlease don't post snarky comments, especially not about divisive topics, where the effect is that of trolling. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13830801 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13830801 and marked it off-topic.
- rdiddly 10y agoAdmittedly I didn't put a lot of time into making my point but there was a point: it's disingenuous to portray offenders as hapless victims of cruel cruel prison, when the real victims they f'd over, don't get to choose or buy better treatment.
- dang 10y agoThere are still two problems with putting it this way: name-calling and a logic error. We can edit out the name-calling as follows: it's misleading to portray offenders as victims of prison, when their own victims don't get to choose or buy better treatment Now the statement is probably fine to post to HN in the sense that it meets the basic standard for civility and substantiveness. As a reader, though, I'd go further. I would read the meat of the claim this way: "it's misleading to portray offenders as victims, when they victimized others". This is a logic error because the categories are not mutually exclusive. It's possible for victimizers to also be victims, typically by somebody else. Indeed, that dynamic is so common that a cliché ("the cycle of violence") exists to name it. But we don't have to agree on that bit to have a thoughtful conversation about it. If you'd posted the rewritten statement ("it's misleading...") and someone replied like I did here ("the categories..."), the thread would be fine.
- sneak 10y agoHow do I disable untrusted pages reading my phone's precise 3d orientation without my permission?
- belovedeagle 10y agoDespite the article's inane attempts to link this to sex crimes, I see nothing wrong with this. Housing and feeding prisoners is a huge drain on society; a prisoner who alleviates that drain absolutely deserves a more humane experience. That's not to say that everyone else doesn't deserve a more humane experience, but we simply can't afford it. No one is suggesting we close down shelters and start housing the homeless in five star hotels, and no one seems to be too bothered by that. On the whole I'd rather money be spent first on that than upgrading prisons. EDIT: As to the idea that this somehow reduces the effective punishment: while that might be true for the ultra-rich for whom $10k is irrelevant (but since when do they go to prison anyways?), for everyone else, having to fund your own incarceration [directly, in addition to funding everyone else's via taxation,] seems to offset that.
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoIncentives matter. If you allow prisons to charge for improved prisoner experience, you make the default prison experience the BATNA for negotiating how much money you give the folks running the prison. Like, if you pay ransoms when terrorists take Americans hostage, you're funding kidnap-Americans-and-ransom-them businesses. If you pay prisons for more humane treatment, you're funding imprison-people-and-threaten-them-with-inhumane-conditions businesses. IMO, it should be illegal for prisons to get money from prisoners. There's a bunch of really shitty things that inevitably happen. See: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/31/us/steep-costs-of-inmate-phone-calls-are-under-scrutiny.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/31/us/steep-costs-of-inmate-...
- jMyles 10y ago> we simply can't afford it We can. By simply releasing basically every prisoner. Literally less than 1% are truly such threats to society as to require the kind of sequestration that only prison can provide.
- vfclists 10y agoSome European prisons are way better than the best America's pay fof jail schemes. America's jails are places where people got to get abused rather than get rehabilitated, so what is the big deal about some people paying for a better environment?
- Someone1234 10y ago> so what is the big deal about some people paying for a better environment? Because it incentives the private prison to make the situation even worse for those who fail to pay. Effectively the worse they make the "free" the more money they make. To use an analogy, it is like Amazon Prime, when Amazon Prime first started free shipping was at $25 minimum order. Last year free shipping was at $49. Why? To incentivise Prime memberships. Only competition from Walmart forced them to bring it back down to $35. So back to prisons... If this became popular, we'd see more prisons who offer zero privacy as the "free" option (e.g. shared bunk beds) all as a means to "incentivise" (blackmail) prisoners into paying for a semi-private or private room. Plus when you take into account the safety aspect, the whole thing becomes immoral. You're literally forcing prisoners to pay so they can sleep safely at night, otherwise they might get shanked while they sleep (or not get any sleep due to fear). US prisons are already much less safe than most European, Canadian, or AUS/NZ prisons.
- Toboe 10y ago>America's jails are places where people got to get abused rather than get rehabilitated, so what is the big deal about some people paying for a better environment? Because the general ideal for justice is punishment to be based on guilt, not ability to pay for a lessening of guilt. And allowing some to pay for not going there may be seen as furthering the problem, by making influental people less likely to suffer the same consequences and inspire prisons to treat "second class" inmates worse to increase the motivation to buy an upgrade to "first class"
- clock_tower 10y agoWell, it worked for pre-revolutionary France! What could possibly go wrong?
- dmitrygr 10y agoGiven that current jail conditions are dismal as best, I see no reason for private companies to not offer for-pay incarceration services that solve these problems. This is no different than private companies offering delivery services because USPS sucks, or private transportation companies existing because bus infra simply isn't good enough. If a judge considers these options prison-like enough, then I see no reason they cannot exist. Does it suck because not everyone can afford it? Sure Does that mean we should just screw everyone equally simply to claim we're fair? IMHO no. Not unless you also want to close down UPS, FedEx, and Greyhound. And not unless you are willing to come out and openly say that YOU consider rape, abuse, and neglect to be an official part of our rehabilitation strategy (because that is all that county and federal prisons excel at)
- rdiddly 10y agoYou are getting confused between consumer goods/services (part of a capitalist market and being sold for profit without regard to social good), and the justice provisions of a functioning society (part of the public good, not for profit, can't be sold, and not subject to market forces or imbalancing tendencies... or at least life was better when it was like that and people knew the difference).
- aaron_m04 10y agoYou write as if the current jail conditions are set in stone. Why is that?
- techrich 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debtors'_prison#Great_Britain_.28later_the_United_Kingdom.29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debtors'_prison#Great_Britain_...