3 ms·
I'm going to congratulate myself here. This is one of the best sorts of trolls: I told them what they were doing wrong that was making their argument ineffectiv
by jessaustin 10y ago
I'm going to congratulate myself here. This is one of the best sorts of trolls: I told them what they were doing wrong that was making their argument ineffective, and that inspired them to do much more of it.
- vidarh 10y agoMaybe it is a losing battle, but fighting that kind of ignorance is something I see as a moral imperative given the number of deaths that the fear of nuclear power is causing. The anti-nuclear hysteria is in a class together with the anti-vaccine movement when it comes to potential public harm.
- jessaustin 10y agoEven if you were correct about that (you're not! [0]), why would you persist in ineffective rhetoric? [0] Nuclear power is never the best option, no matter what criteria is used. It's always more expensive, it always produces more dangerous waste, and it always poses more risk to the community than numerous competing options. Whatever lives you thought you might save with a nuclear plant, save billions of dollars and decades of development and just put in some wind or solar farms or natural gas turbines or some combination of those.
- mpweiher 10y agoWow! [0] [0] You are citing yourself as a reliable source. That's pretty nifty. > it always produces more dangerous waste, False. > it always poses more risk to the community False. > It's always more expensive That one is closest to the truth, but also not really true: "Some independent reviews keep repeating that nuclear power plants are necessarily very expensive,[26][27] and anti-nuclear groups frequently produce reports that say the costs of nuclear energy are prohibitively high.[28][29][30][31] This is despite the fact that in 2015 the cost of electricity in nuclear France is approximately the same as in Denmark and two-thirds of that in Germany.[32][33]" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economics_of_nuclear_power_plants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economics_of_nuclear_power_pla...
- vidarh 10y agoEven if the truth is ineffective, if the alternative is to lie I will persist with the truth in face of this type of ignorance: > [0] Nuclear power is never the best option, no matter what criteria is used. It's always more expensive, it always produces more dangerous waste, Irrelevant; the waste does far less damage than the alternatives. > and it always poses more risk to the community than numerous competing options. The death tolls shows clearly that this is false for every solution we have for base loads. When battery/storage technology gets far enough this may change, but as long as a single coal, oil or gas plant is active, reducing nuclear is a far greater risk to the community. > Whatever lives you thought you might save with a nuclear plant, save billions of dollars and decades of development and just put in some wind or solar farms or natural gas turbines or some combination of those. Wind or solar farms can not provide baseload without billions in investments in storage. Once we have that infrastructure, sure, then we can consider reducing dependence on nuclear. In the meantime they can not replace nuclear. Natural gas kills more.
- mpweiher 10y ago> best sorts of trolls Good to know that you were just trolling. > I told them what they were doing wrong that You do realize that just because you say something is wrong doesn't actually make it so. Right? Who is "them", by the way? > argument ineffective Nope, the nuclear industry's existing strategy, which closely follows your ridiculous suggestion of admitting things that aren't true, has been extremely ineffective and has backfired. They thought that if they created standards that mandated extreme, one could say ridiculous levels of safety, the public would accept nuclear power as safe. The opposite happened: the high safety standards were taken as evidence of how terrible all this was. And they backfired even worse in that the standards were so high that "keeping the public safe" using those standards actually exposed them to worse danger than looser standards would have. Oh the irony! And yes, I also used to believe your take that, well, every once in a while there are horrible accidents. And unlike you I used to believe that those accidents, even if rare, were horrible enough to rule out nuclear power. That is, until I looked at the actual numbers (and later the WHO reports on Chernobyl). And found out that not only are the amortized numbers ridulously better than anything else. Even the "catastrophes" were (a) both much less catastrophic than I thought and (b) other power sources had much worse catastrophes than I knew (because those aren't reported) and (c) most of the catastrophic effects were actually indirect and due not to radiation but to fear of radiation. Did I mention the irony? So I came around to the view (expressed very well by others in this thread) that not using a power source that is (a) safer than any other available on the planet and (b) >1000 times safer then the most widely used and readily available alternative is morally/ethically completely indefensible, downright repugnant.