6 ms·
So would you rather they burn coal, which they don't have and has to be imported and intoxicate everyone with mercury and arsenic biproducts from coal burning?
by petre 10y ago
So would you rather they burn coal, which they don't have and has to be imported and intoxicate everyone with mercury and arsenic biproducts from coal burning? These two heavy metals also contaminte seafood, which the Japanese are quite fond of.
- sandworm101 10y agoCoal burning also produces significant radiation, enough to have an actual nuclear plant shut down on safety grounds. All sorts of nasty stuff is trapped in coal and it all come out when the carbon is burnt away. I havent seen anyone do the math, but given the amounts of coal involved i would expect more radiation comes from coal plants each year than a yearly fukashima-type event.
- david-given 10y agoDon't have a reference handy, but I've seen estimates that the amount of radioactive material emitted into the atmosphere each year by coal burning is about equivalent to one Chernobyl (which was substantially worse, emission-wise, than Fukushima).
- dredmorbius 10y agoOn a per-plant basis, the level is all-but immaterial. Even Fukushima levels of radiation, spread over the globe, aren't too horrible. There are all kinds of reasons to reject coal-fired power. Radiation isn't one of them. See the xkcd radiation chart for relative measures. https://xkcd.com/radiation https://xkcd.com/radiation
- sandworm101 10y agoIt isnt a logical reason, but it is good to remind the "clean coal" crowd of such facts when they scream about radiation from nuke plants.
- dredmorbius 10y agoA coal plant's regular radiation emissions are as bad as they get, and are orders of magnitude below the least possible clinically significant levels. A nuclear power plants regular radiations are below the level of a coal plant. But a worst-case scenario, of which we have multiple extant examples are unbelievably worse: 9 trillion times more radiation, using the xkcd reference I posted (adjusting the intervals for equivalence -- 1 year rather than 10 minutes as the Chernobyl core instance is given). And it's been non-engineering factors, for the most part (management and oversight) which are the failure modes driving these. Which is to say, the problems cannot be fixed by engineering around them. The fundamental error, though, is that this is a false dichotomy. There are alternatives to both coal and nuclear. And they bypass this problem entirely.
- phkahler 10y ago>> Coal burning also produces significant radiation, enough to have an actual nuclear plant shut down on safety grounds. That's so cute. A nuclear plant would ideally emit zero radiation if everything is designed and working correctly. A leak is a warning sign and the potential danger is an event like the two that have happened so far. In other words, that level of radiation leak from a nuclear plant isn't actually a problem. They shut it down to make sure something really bad doesn't happen. With coal you get the leak without the catastrophe.
- alphonsegaston 10y agoNo, because I don't subscribe to fallacious false binaries about fossil fuels vs nuclear energy. Japan should invest heavily in renewable energy. Despite it's many shortcomings, the Japanese government is quite good at building out and maintaining modern infrastructure. If they developed expertise in this domain, it could also serve as a great export to other markets.
- ckastner 10y ago> No, because I don't subscribe to fallacious false binaries about fossil fuels vs nuclear energy. In real terms, it currently is a binary problem. > Japan should invest heavily in renewable infrastructure. Proposing a hand-wavy solution like "just invest heavily" is only a solution if you ignore the political, financial, social, and technical aspects of providing almost a trillion kWh annually to 120 million people.
- alphonsegaston 10y agoJapan transformed its entire country from nearly complete devastation during WWII into a tech leader in various manufacturing and industrial technologies, including automation and robotics. They also possess some of the world's best research and technology institutions (e.g. Tokyo University). So if it's "hand-wavy" to believe in their capability to build better future, based on a quite miraculous track record, you can call me "hand-wavy."
- AstralStorm 10y agoIt is handwavy. Name the source of that energy that will allow providing that much electricity. Back of the envelope calculations. Even that is somewhat handwavy. For example, with solar power in Japan, you could get maybe 100% (EDIT: fixed the estimates! They're better but not better enough.) more than is currently grabbed - with massive subsidies and research already there! And it is one of the countries relying on a lot of it! Comparable with Germany in fact, but with better insolation. It is not enough. Nowhere near. That expansion will provide about 25-30% of current power use in solar, total. With hydro and tide power, just 10-15% more is available unless you want to destroy all the coastline (then maybe 25%), which you cannot if you want to feed people. Again not enough. Japan already uses a lot of available hydro capacity. Wind is not really feasible either... About 10% more is available of mostly offshore wind. Everywhere feasible is already installed. Biomass, maybe 25% more for total conversion - and it is not a clean fuel. Fusion is too far away for now extrapolating the linear improvements in this technology. Additionally, everything in Japan (production, services etc.) is already tweaked to be energy efficient... As it is now, Japan is burning a lot of oil and coal. On the order of ~50% electricity is fueled by those sources. It has increased additionally since the disaster because no other source can cover it. Serious solutions involve: 1) Clean and safe nuclear fission power. Again. I'm sure Japanese are able to figure that one out, even in their special circumstances which complicate matters. 2) Massive breakthrough in fusion. Good luck with that. There is already much increased investment. Given current trends, even if the linear factor on the development of fusion improves, we're looking at 50 years or so of development time for that to be viable. 3) Solving huge political issues to expand out-of-country solar capacity, import even more green electricity from other countries. We're talking world government scale here. 4) Another undisclosed physics discovery worth a few Nobel prizes.
- marze 10y agoWhat we see here (in the parent comment) is someone parroting standard nuclear industry propaganda: coal is bad too. While those line at least made a bit of sense 15 years ago, it is totally pointless in 2017. No new coal plants are being built now. It is in phase out mode. All new generation is wind, solar, and to a lesser degree methane. Coal is going away; like nuclear, it can't compete.
- jcrawfordor 10y ago> No new coal plants are being built now. It is in phase out mode. All new generation is wind, solar, and to a lesser degree methane. Coal is going away; like nuclear, it can't compete. In the United States, at least, natural gas is the largest component of new generating capacity. Wind and solar are both independently fairly close to natural gas recently, but natural gas is still the #1 increase and has been for most of the last 10 or so years. So yes, the rate of increase in coal capacity is very low (but still net positive), but it is not true that all new generation is wind and solar. New generation is roughly 1/3rd each natural gas, wind, and solar, ranked in that order. Again - in the United States. This varies from country to country, e.g. I believe China is still seeing substantial net increases in coal, whereas I believe Western Europe is seeing a lot more wind/solar. You can get these numbers for the US from EIA reports: https://www.eia.gov/electricity/annual/ https://www.eia.gov/electricity/annual/
- petre 10y agoThe US also has vast geothermal potential and about 3.4 MWh installed capacity. Geothermal power is a suitable replacement for nuclear and coal/gas as one can build base load power stations.
- marze 10y agoWrong on all points, data helpful: http://www.ecowatch.com/ferc-renewable-energy-capacity-2233026420.html http://www.ecowatch.com/ferc-renewable-energy-capacity-22330...
- jcrawfordor 10y ago