4 ms·
The nuclear apologists don't seem to realize they would have a more effective argument if they just admitted what is obvious to anyone: that occasionally nuclea
by jessaustin 10y ago
The nuclear apologists don't seem to realize they would have a more effective argument if they just admitted what is obvious to anyone: that occasionally nuclear power causes terrible catastrophes. Perhaps someday in the bright shiny future it won't, but it certainly has for the last 65 years we've been using it. Then they could stack those terrible catastrophes up against what they see as the wonderful benefits of nuclear power, and reasonable people would have some choices to make. Instead, they run around with fingers in ears chanting "nyah nyah nyah no problems here", and reasonable people can only conclude that the analysis is missing some important points.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mpweiher 10y ago> occasionally nuclear power causes terrible catastrophes Except that's not the case, other forms of power generation not only have far higher death tolls overall, but also more terrible catastrophes: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_and_radiation_accidents_by_death_toll https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_and_radiation_... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents
- maxerickson 10y agoThat energy accident table could really use a row for utility solar. edit: No, it's not out of wack, it's just that one uses trillion kilowatt hours and one uses terawatt hours. Oops. It's also hugely out of wack with this article: http://www.nextbigfuture.com/2011/03/deaths-per-twh-by-energy-source.html http://www.nextbigfuture.com/2011/03/deaths-per-twh-by-energ... Do we trust that article and it's many sources or the basically unsourced Forbes article Wikipedia relies on (https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-deathprint-a-price-always-paid/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-d... ) It doesn't matter a great deal for the comparison, both articles point to many less deaths from nuclear.
- onli 10y agoThat's not even internally consistent. We have no terrible catastrophes because the others have terrible catastrophes?
- vidarh 10y agoIt's more that even Chernobyl is a tiny little blip compared to things like the Banqiao dam failure, even if you take some of the worst long term death toll estimates. And coal kills several times as many people every year in the US alone as what Chernobyl is projected to kill from the accident until the radioactivity released is all gone, even without any accidents.
- onli 10y agoThat's not what he wrote though. Besides, why is the coal thing used as an argument? That's a good point to make when discussing with someone who wants to replace nuclear energy with coal. But I doubt anyone here has that goal. Something like the dam does not compare, it is not one or the other, and it is not long-lasting damage.
- vidarh 10y agoSe his own answer. My response mirrors his. And there have been coal fires and explosions that have killed more people in single incidents too. The point is that if you're going to worry about risks, the moral thing to do would be to get rid off coal even if your alternative is massive increases in nuclear. > Something like the dam does not compare, it is not one or the other, and it is not long-lasting damage. No it does not, it is several magnitudes more deaths and millions of homeless. As for long-lasting damage, hydro projects are amongst the most devastating power plant projects we have, routinely displacing millions of people from their homes forever, submerging entire cities, destroying vast forest areas and animal habitats, and setting off ticking environmental disasters in the form of rotting vegetation releasing vast amounts of CO2. So, no, dams do not compare - they are some of the least environmentally friendly options we have, and have killed a lot more people (even excluding Banqiao), and made far larger areas uninhabitable.
- adekok 10y ago> that occasionally nuclear power causes terrible catastrophes. To play devil's advocate...so do cars. Tens of thousands of people die every year in the USA from car crashes, and millions more are injured. These numbers are greater than similar numbers from nuclear power. The nuclear catastrophes which have occurred have largely been predicted. And were preventable. Both for Chernobyl and for Fukushima. Just like most car deaths and injuries in the 1950s were preventable. And... coal plants put out more radiation and pollution than do nuclear plants. And the pollution from coal plants kills or injures more people. No one is saying nuclear power is safe. But if you're going to claim it's terrible, you have to admit that there are many things we live with every day which are much more terrible than nuclear power.
- jessaustin 10y agoI'm going to congratulate myself here. This is one of the best sorts of trolls: I told them what they were doing wrong that was making their argument ineffective, and that inspired them to do much more of it.
- vidarh 10y agoMaybe it is a losing battle, but fighting that kind of ignorance is something I see as a moral imperative given the number of deaths that the fear of nuclear power is causing. The anti-nuclear hysteria is in a class together with the anti-vaccine movement when it comes to potential public harm.
- jessaustin 10y agoEven if you were correct about that (you're not! [0]), why would you persist in ineffective rhetoric? [0] Nuclear power is never the best option, no matter what criteria is used. It's always more expensive, it always produces more dangerous waste, and it always poses more risk to the community than numerous competing options. Whatever lives you thought you might save with a nuclear plant, save billions of dollars and decades of development and just put in some wind or solar farms or natural gas turbines or some combination of those.
- mpweiher 10y agoWow! [0] [0] You are citing yourself as a reliable source. That's pretty nifty. > it always produces more dangerous waste, False. > it always poses more risk to the community False. > It's always more expensive That one is closest to the truth, but also not really true: "Some independent reviews keep repeating that nuclear power plants are necessarily very expensive,[26][27] and anti-nuclear groups frequently produce reports that say the costs of nuclear energy are prohibitively high.[28][29][30][31] This is despite the fact that in 2015 the cost of electricity in nuclear France is approximately the same as in Denmark and two-thirds of that in Germany.[32][33]" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economics_of_nuclear_power_plants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economics_of_nuclear_power_pla...
- 10y ago
- 10238192301 10y agoChernobyl happened during a reckless experiment and Fukushima was built in a Tsunami area. I'm pro nuclear, but obviously I support prohibiting (and shutting down!) power plants in danger zones as well as procedures that make stupid experiments impossible.