6 ms·
There is a difference between "there is no risk", which I did not write but you imply I did, and "this risk is greater than this other risk", which is what I di
by mpweiher 10y ago
There is a difference between "there is no risk", which I did not write but you imply I did, and "this risk is greater than this other risk", which is what I did write.
See the WHO evaluation of the the Chernobyl disaster, which states that the largest public health problem of the disaster has been the mental health impact (link in other response: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13829192 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13829192).
Again, that doesn't mean that there weren't other impacts, but the mental health impact was larger. I also remember seeing video footage of all the animals that died after Fukushima. They didn't die of radiation, they died of neglect.
Also, the health impact of fairly low radiation dosages is effectively unknown to date, but data from the Chernobyl incident keeps correcting the effect downward every 10 years.
The idea that "there is no safe dosage" was created artificially, because after Hiroshima and Nagasaki the exposure effects were simply linearly extrapolated to zero. There was no actual data there.
- _ph_ 10y agoWell, obviously, if the regions are evacuated generously, then indeed the health impact by radiation should be close to zero. Do you have any data on how large the health impact would have been without an evacuation? Of course, it is a very difficult to have precise impact numbers of radiation when we are speaking about effects talking place on the scale of decades, but we unfortunately have enough experience that the accepted safety levels are based on reasonable research.
- mpweiher 10y agoIt now looks like a smaller evacuation zone would have been beneficial in the case of Chernobyl, and the same probably goes for Fukushima. We are overcautious as to the effects of the radiation, and undercautious as to the effects of the evacuation etc., as the data gathered over the decades around Chernobyl shows. Look at the WHO reports over the decades, each one downgrades the previous estimate of the radiation effects. > the accepted safety levels are based on reasonable research. That's apparently not the case. As others have suggested look up the LNT model and its criticism in light of (a) how it was derived and (b) data that strongly contradicts it.
- Diederich 10y ago> It now looks like a smaller evacuation zone would have been beneficial in the case of Chernobyl, and the same probably goes for Fukushima. BIG TIME citation needed. See my other post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13829400 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13829400 Again, I'm going on about Chernobyl, not Fukushima. A lot of people received pretty high doses in the former case, and the results have been pretty terrible.
- mpweiher 10y agoHmm...I did give citations, the WHO reports among many others. Where are yours? > I'm going on about Chernobyl, not Fukushima. Yes, and the WHO reports clearly state in unequivocal terms that the mental health effects were the most serious effects. Note that this does not mean "there were no effects and people were just imagining things". No, it means that there were significant effects, just the the most significant effects were mental health related, which then caused other negative outcomes. And I'd agree with you that Chernobyl was much more significant than Fukushima, which means that the relationship between actual radiation effects and other (mental health etc.) effects is going to be even more lopsided in Fukushima.
- Diederich 10y ago> citations ... among many others. I must have missed non-WHO citations about how the mental health impact of the Chernobyl disaster was greater than the actual physical affect. For many people in Belarus, Chernobyl was a very real, very physical health disaster. > Where are yours? Linked in the article I linked. Google trivially returns all kinds of well-documented health impacts in Belarus and neighboring areas. Also, as reported, an eye-witness account of the suffering that Chernobyl brought to so many people.
- mpweiher 10y ago> Linked in the article I linked. Except the article says nothing of the sort. In fact, it explicitly states in the first paragraph that we don't know what the cause of those birth defects is. > eye-witness account of the suffering that Chernobyl brought Once again, you seem to miss the point: the point is not whether or not there was suffering, but what the biggest causes of the suffering was. And once again, the WHO concludes that the biggest cause of suffering were (sometimes severe) mental health effects (which can cause physical suffering). Also there were external effects such as the fall of the Soviet Union and the consequences of that. For example, life expectancy of Russian men dropped by ~10 years in the late 1980s and 1990s. Not due to radiation, but mostly due to alcohol (due to psycho-social/mental health effects).
- onli 10y agoI realize there are a lot of nuclear apologist around here, but this is getting ridiculous. That boars are living in the area means nothing. It doesn't mean in the slightest that it is safe for humans. With Chernobyl and Fukushima we are talking about serious levels of radiation, high enough to kill people very fast. See https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/feb/03/fukushima-daiichi-radiation-levels-highest-since-2011-meltdown https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/feb/03/fukushim... of how high the radiation in Fukushima still is today. To act like "Ah, nothing really happened, see the wild pigs flocking around" is not even close to an appropriate judgment of the situation. We all would like to have safe and cheap energy. We won't reach that goal by trivializing the dangers of nuclear energy, which isn't even cheap to begin with.
- Diederich 10y ago> I realize there are a lot of nuclear apologist around here, but this is getting ridiculous. I'm pro nuclear power, but I agree with you. Boars running around doesn't mean jack squat. We need to look objectively about all of the many aspects of nuclear power production, including its dangers and financial costs. Honestly, the way solar generation and battery technology is taking off, even the most optimistic nuclear technology might become irrelevant.
- jessaustin 10y agoThe nuclear apologists don't seem to realize they would have a more effective argument if they just admitted what is obvious to anyone: that occasionally nuclear power causes terrible catastrophes. Perhaps someday in the bright shiny future it won't, but it certainly has for the last 65 years we've been using it. Then they could stack those terrible catastrophes up against what they see as the wonderful benefits of nuclear power, and reasonable people would have some choices to make. Instead, they run around with fingers in ears chanting "nyah nyah nyah no problems here", and reasonable people can only conclude that the analysis is missing some important points.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 10y ago
- Diederich 10y agoDisclosure: I am and have long been very pro nuclear power. My wife lived near Chojniki, Belarus, for a number of months in 1996. I skimmed the WHO evaluation you linked, and, unless it has some context I'm not aware of, it just doesn't jive with the actual impact, on the ground, near Chernobyl. A quick link: http://www.businessinsider.com/birth-defects-related-to-chernobyl-2016-4 http://www.businessinsider.com/birth-defects-related-to-cher... From that article: "A study by UNICEF suggested that more than 20% of adolescent children in Belarus suffer from disabilities caused by birth defects." In her time there, 10 years after the disaster, she witnessed many gross birth defects in children, and very many cancers in children and adults. I hesitate to bring anecdotes up as anything like a refutation to a formal and proper report from the WHO, but it's clear that something is missing. I'd like to note that, in terms of acute human exposure, there's no comparison between Fukushima and Chernobyl. > Also, the health impact of fairly low radiation dosages is effectively unknown to date, but data from the Chernobyl incident keeps correcting the effect downward every 10 years. Citation needed, though you did mention 'low radiation doses'. That's the thing: a whole lot of people received a pretty stiff dose from Chernobyl. Perhaps the health impact of low doses isn't well understood, but that's not the case with much higher doses.
- mpweiher 10y ago> WHO report doesn't agree with actual impact Hmm...so you think the WHO report is lying? Or did you misread it? > Business-insider Hmm...this is the first paragraph of that Business Insider article: "The scientific debate is ongoing over whether congenital birth defects can be linked to radiation from the Chernobyl nuclear disaster that happened 30 years ago this month." So on the one hand you have the WHO saying something backed by 30 years of observation and analysis of the data, and you contradict that with a Business Insider article saying "we don't know". I think that one thing you are missing is that radiation is not the only or even primary cause of birth defects or cancer. This is one of the things the WHO reports dig into. For example, roughly and from memory, the economic/psycho-social situation brought on a strong increase in alcoholism, which increases the chance of cancer and birth defects. So once again, saying that the mental health problems exceed the (direct) radiation problems is no way of saying that there are no problem. It is saying that the mental health problems were sometimes severe and in any case exceeded the problems directly attributable to radiation. > Citation needed, though you did mention 'low radiation doses'. The WHO site has reports roughly every ten years after the accident. Each time they downgrade the estimate for radiation effects. Once again, that does not mean there are no radiation effects. I have other references in my other comments. Also, yes, this is for low dosages. If you were in the crew that went into the reactor core you were a walking corpse, immediately.