5 ms·
As with most nuclear accidents so far, the health risks from fear of radiation exceed the actual health risks from the radiation itself. The boars don't know a
by mpweiher 10y ago
As with most nuclear accidents so far, the health risks from fear of radiation exceed the actual health risks from the radiation itself.
The boars don't know about the radiation and therefore do not fear it.
- masklinn 10y agoWith respect to wildlife, it's more that the health risks of radiation are significantly lower than the health risks of human presence and activities.
- jlebrech 10y agothe average pig in captivity only lives for around 6 months, so them dieing at 1 or 3 gives them plenty of time to procreate.
- sonthonax 10y agoWild animals have a death rate orders of magnitude greater than healthy Japanese people. The increased incidence of radiation sickness probably does little to the overall death rate of the boars.
- sageikosa 10y agoIn those cases it's usually better to check out fecundity rather than life expectancy deltas. Has live birth rate declined or infant mortality increased?
- lubonay 10y agoGo hang out at Pripyat if you really think it's the fear that gets you. I volunteer as the B group, fearing radiation intensely but staying away from it. We can document whose health deteriorates first!
- mpweiher 10y ago"Expert Assessment Consensus The mental health impact of Chernobyl is the largest public health problem caused by the accident to date" -- Health Effects of the Chernobyl Accident, page 95, World Health Organization [1] But what do they know? [1] http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/43447/1/9241594179_eng.pdf?ua=1 http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/43447/1/9241594179_...
- Retric 10y agoThat's with a large scale evacuation, so it says nothing about living in the area. It's like saying Y2K did not cause any major issues so all that effort was pointless. Remember, dealing with probelms alters the outcomes so you can't look at the outcome alone.
- morsch 10y agoExactly, the cited passage goes on: The magnitude and scope of the disaster, the size of the affected population, and the long-term consequences make it, by far, the worst industrial disaster on record. Chernobyl unleashed a complex web of events and long-term difficulties, such as massive relocation, loss of economic stability, and long-term threatds to health in current and, possibly, future generations, that resulted in an increased sense of anomie and diminished sense of physical and emotional balance.
- vidarh 10y agoYou'll note that a large proportion of these are due to the evacuation, and we do not know how much of that was necessary. In terms of directly attributable health effects, including deaths, it's nowhere near the worst industrial disaster on record. It's a curious claim. We'll likely never know whether that was due to the evacuation or simply that the risk were overstated. E.g. consider the Bhopal disaster [1] for comparison - 2259 official immediate deaths in Bhopal vs. 56, and nearly 4000 confirmed dead due to the disaster and 16k+ estimated total deaths, vs. a WHO estimate of 4000 eventual shortened lifespans after Chernobyl (e.g. people whose life expectancy over a period of decades is shortened due to increased cancer risks). Bhopal further caused an estimated 558,000 injuries. For comparison, the Chernobyl exclusion zone used to be home to 120,000 people. Far more people were actually harmed in Bhopal than even lived near Chernobyl. Chernobyl is only worse than Bhopal on a single measure: It will take longer before the area is fully safe to use again (but much shorter than people initially thought - as mentioned elsewhere, there is already pressure to open it up to more activity, as background radiation is already down to relatively safe levels). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhopal_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhopal_disaster
- _ph_ 10y agoSorry, no. There is a distinctive health risk to radioactive radiation, and thus the regions around Fukushima and Chernobyl are evacuated from permanent residency. It is perfectly safe to do short trips into those regions. But long term, this is a considerable health risk. The boars can live there, because they are short-lived animals compared to humans, and the article doesn't say whether they do reach their natural life span even. They only seem to live long enough to procreate, which is 1-3 years for wild boars. Humans could live there as well, but they would experience an unacceptably short live. A human group can survive on a life expectancy of little more than 20 years, thats what human kind did in the past. But by modern standards this is not acceptable, and consequently those regions are not considered safe for settlement.
- ckastner 10y ago> Humans could live there as well, but they would experience an unacceptably short live Is this an assumption on your part, or can you back this up with data?
- _ph_ 10y agoI am not a MD, but I think it is accepted knowledge that elevated radiation levels shorten the life expectancy. How much, depends on many factors, like the exact nature of the radiation, like you are exposed to it, or have a likelyhood of eating contaminated foo, and of course your very age. The older you are, the less likely you are to suffer from this. I haven't done research on this myself, but I would assume that the exclusion zones have been set up according to the accepted standards for radiation safety levels.
- coddingtonbear 10y agoI'd recommend doing a little research about the controversy around the "Linear no-threshold model" of radiation exposure. The answer isn't quite as clear as you might guess.
- mpweiher 10y agoHere is an article explaining.[1] It's a "random site on the Internet", so feel free to not believe anything they say, but I think they provide fairly good references to source material. There was also a documentary film a while ago, I'll see if I can find it. It mentions this apartment complex in Taiwan that was contaminated, and the health of the residents turned out to be better than average, not worse. Ahh, found it[2]. Seem like fairly reputable sources. [1] http://www.21stcenturysciencetech.com/articles/nuclear.html http://www.21stcenturysciencetech.com/articles/nuclear.html [2] http://ecolo.org/documents/documents_in_english/low-dose-Cobalt-taiw-06.pdf http://ecolo.org/documents/documents_in_english/low-dose-Cob...
- maxerickson 10y agoYou are conflating impact and controllable individual risk. If there was no exclusion zone at all the impact from fear would likely still be larger. That measurement wouldn't help the people getting large radiation exposures inside the zone.
- emodendroket 10y agoBut nobody really cares if boars get cancer and die early, unlike humans.
- jlebrech 10y agomost pigs die early, but from humans.
- emodendroket 10y agoYeah, all the more reason why comparing humans' unwillingness to live in high radiation areas with that of boars is kind of a silly comparison to make.
- pvaldes 10y agoMost interesting question about boars is that they are big animals that dig deep in the soil searching for roots, rodents and tubercles. They are basically working hard to return the buried radioactive isotopes to the surface again when they are more dangerous. We should think on it and adjust our models to predict and understand the problem. And Boars will travel in and out of Fukushima of course.
- pvaldes 10y agowhen they are more dangerous -> where (the isotopes) are more dangerous